Maybe you're fresh onto the dating scene after a divorce, or you've achieved your career goals and now you're ready to start a new chapter with someone special.
Whatever your circumstances are, jumping into the world of online dating when you're over 40 can be tricky. Selfies, swiping, ghosting, catfishing… it's a brand new ball game.
Even if you’ve been at it for a while, if you haven't figured out which are the best dating sites for singles over 40, you’re still likely feeling overwhelmed and frustrated by it all.
|Exclusive Bonus: Download 8 of our best, proven profiles that you can copy & paste on all your favorite dating sites and apps.|
You want real results with real women who are genuinely interested in you. And finding them just got a lot easier. Simply start your search here, with one of these 7 best online dating sites for men in their 40s, 50s, and over:
- PlentyOfFish (POF)
Keep reading to decide which one is best for you!
This popular dating site charges a monthly fee, which means you are more likely to find women there who are serious about meeting someone. It’s also one of the best dating sites for professionals over 40.
Prices may vary slightly in your area, but you can expect to spend in the neighborhood of $16.99 to $36.99 a month, depending on how many months you pay for up front.
|PRO TIP: No matter which dating site you’re using, don’t waste time messaging women who haven’t logged into their accounts within the last week. Use the search filters to sort your matches by last login date so you can focus most on those who are either Online Now or were online within the last 24 hours.|
Because Match.com is such a large site, the competition for the most attractive local women will naturally be fierce.
OkCupid is free and very popular, which is an especially important consideration if you’re not in a mega city like New York or Los Angeles.
The membership demographics tend to be on the younger side of things, so it’s one of the best free dating sites for singles over 40 looking to meet younger women in their late 20s or early 30s.
That said, there are plenty of women of all ages on OkCupid and it just takes a few minutes to open an account and have a look around. If you like what you see, then you will need to create an OkCupid profile and answer dozens of their quirky “Match Questions.”
The questions can be a bit tedious and random, but the more you answer, the higher your match score with another user can be. Plus, answering them just requires checking a box. Then you choose which answers you will accept in a match.
For instance, one of the questions is “Have you smoked a cigarette in the last 6 months”. Then you can specify how you want your match to respond – yes, no, or any of the above, and there’s also a short text box if you’d like to elaborate on your response.
Because it’s free, anyone—including the barefoot lady selling hemp bracelets on the corner—can have a profile on OkCupid. But since it’s such a well-known site, it attracts enough educated, beautiful women to keep your week full of high-quality dates. It may take slightly longer to find them than on Match.com, but they’re there.
By upgrading your account to a paid monthly “A-List Premium” membership, you can access features like invisible browsing (so she won’t see you visited her profile AGAIN), advanced search filters (including one that allows you to only see the most attractive users in your results), and notification of women who “like” your profile.
The bells and whistles are worth the ~$20/month investment, because they allow you to quickly and efficiently identify quality matches and message multiple women in a short amount of time.
If you’re successful and well established, chances are you’ll get excellent results on MillionaireMatch. The site draws an elite pool of interesting, beautiful women who are looking for a guy like you.
Because the women on this site expect to date the cream of the crop, you’ll want to put some extra time into your profile. You won’t want to miss these essential tips on how to write a successful profile for elite dating sites.
Although it advertises itself as a site that matches millionaires, you’ll find plenty of non-millionaire women as well, and it claims to have over 2 million members.
You don’t have to be a millionaire either, although keep in mind women using the site have high expectations concerning the type of man they’re interested in meeting on the site.
If you are a millionaire, taking the time to go through the verification process is worth it. That “certified millionaire” stamp of approval lets her know you’re the real McCoy, plus paid members can limit search results to certified millionaires only.
At $210 for 6 months, the price is higher than some other sites but the women you’ll meet are generally worth the investment. If you’re serious about meeting the “Total Package”, it’s definitely one of the best dating sites for over 40 singles. The quality is there, so check it out.
If you’re on the fence about giving it a try, this MillionaireMatch review is packed with info about this exclusive dating site.
Plenty Of Fish
PlentyOfFish (POF) is one of the biggest free dating sites. As with OkCupid, the site attracts its fair share of fakers and flakers who aren’t really invested in meeting someone new.
But the sheer number of active local users makes it worth checking out, and the advanced search functions are very user friendly so filtering your matches is a breeze. You can also upgrade to a paid monthly membership, starting around $7 a month.
Paying the monthly fee gives you several benefits, including showing up first on “Meet Me,” where she can say “yes” “no” or “maybe” in response to your photograph. Sometimes that little boost can make all the difference in the over 40 dating world.
Another handy benefit is the ability to see the date and time that she checked out your profile, and having your profile will stand out in search results.
You’ll definitely want to invest some time in screening profiles, and the best way to do that is by using the site’s detailed search function. (Want more dating advice? Check out these great POF tips and tricks!)
For those who practice Christianity (or were at least raised in a Christian home), ChristianMingle is where you should go to meet high-quality women with similar values.
It’s the most popular dating site for marriage-minded Christians, which makes it an excellent place to start if you’re looking for a serious relationship.
Christian Mingle's cost depends on the type and length of your membership, and range from $14.99 a month to $49.99 a month. The more time you purchase up front, the lower the monthly cost. A Basic subscription allows you to exchange messages with other paid members, while a Premium subscription gives you the ability to freely message any singles on the site.
The members on this site range from devout to casual, but most importantly, the quality level is high and the women are responsive. Plus, women tend to outnumber men on the site, and plenty of them are in their 30s and up.
Women on ChristianMingle are typically serious about meeting someone, so it’s one of the best dating sites for singles over 50. But it is a niche dating site, so your user pool could be limited in size if you’re not living in a big city. You’ll generally want to use it in addition to at least one mainstream site like Match.com, OkCupid or POF.
For an indepth look at this faith-based dating site, check out this Christian Mingle review, or give one of these other top Christian dating sites a try!
JDate is another popular faith-based online dating site that attracts successful, high-quality women.
Because it’s a niche site, you won’t find as many users as you would on a mainstream site like Match or OkCupid… but if you know you want a nice Jewish girl who makes a mean matzo ball soup, you don’t want to skip JDate.
JDate has the same pay-to-message structure as ChristianMingle. Free members are only able to replied to messages sent from Premium members, so you'll need to invest in a membership to communicate with all the singles whom you find intriguing. A Premium membership runs between $29.99 a month for 6 months and $59.99 for a single month.
The women on JDate are usually serious about meeting someone, so a “eh, good enough” profile won’t cut it. Check out these online dating profile tips for guys that will help you catch the eye of your perfect match!
SugarDaddie matches successful men with attractive young women. And while many of those women are seeking a “mutually beneficial” arrangement, you’ll also find beautiful women looking for long-term relationships.
For those well-established gents who are entering the world of online dating over 50 and in the market for someone substantially younger, this is not a bad place to start looking.
Although overall the site isn’t as classy as MillionaireMatch, both men and women pay to send/receive messages. The fee cuts down on the number of fake profiles and scammers that tend to proliferate on “seeking arrangement” type sites.
Getting started on the site is easy, and you can typically score a reduced membership rate for the first month. That gives you plenty of time to take the site for a test drive.
The Easiest Way To Meet High Quality Women Fast
These are the 7 best online dating sites for over 40 singles. But if you’re curious about one that’s not on this list, these expert tips will help you decide if a dating site or app is worth your time.
For instance, you may be wondering why OurTime didn’t make the cut. We’ve found that a very high percentage of OurTime users are already on Match.com. Both sites are owned by the same parent company, and Match.com is OurTime’s primary marketing outlet for recruiting new members.
So paying for both of these sites isn’t the best investment. And, as it turns out, Match.com has the larger volume of 40+ year-old users.
If you want to meet high quality local women, you need to put in time and effort to get the best results. In fact, the average man spends 5 hours a week browsing profiles, and then another 6+ hours sending messages. That’s almost 12 hours a week you need to cram into your already busy schedule.
And if you’re new to online dating, dating while separated, or ready to date again after a divorce, getting good results might not come easily. Writing your profile and sending messages is a creative endeavor, and if you don’t get it right you’re looking at another Friday night alone.
Why go through all that frustration when you could reap all the benefits while doing none of the actual work?
Calling in a professional will give you a quick start and a permanent upper hand on the competition. Even better, our online dating experts can do it all for you, from building your profile to finding attractive women you approve of and messaging them for you. All you have to do is show up for the dates!
Why not have a quick, free consultation, and find out how we can help get you dates with high-quality women today?