Top 6 New Jersey Matchmakers [Includes 2025 Cost!]

New Jersey ranks as the third best state for singles in the U.S., with about 43% of the population identifying as single. The Garden State offers a promising landscape for those navigating the dating world, especially with the help of a NJ matchmaker. 

With so many out there to choose from, no wonder you’re looking for recommendations. And a bit of research is a good idea - some NJ matchmakers are (much) better than others.

This list of the 6 top NJ matchmakers has all the important details at a glance, like cost, who runs the service, and how long it’s been in business.

From the big industry players to the boutique independents, our team of matchmaking experts has reviewed over 200 services. With over 14 years of first-hand industry experience, our insight comes from comprehensive research, real customer reviews, and a deep understanding of the matchmaking landscape.

Now all you have to do is choose which one is best for you!

Enamour

Specializing in tailored searches, Enamour is the perfect choice whether you want to meet exceptional singles in Jersey, New York, or abroad.

Clientele

As selective about their clients as they are about who they match you with, Enamour caters to highly accomplished, selective singles.

Cost

Matchmaking packages begin around $20,000 for a 6-month membership.

What To Expect

Clients work directly with a dedicated personal matchmaker. She'll start the search for your ideal partner by getting to know all about you, your lifestyle, past relationships, interests, match criteria and deal breakers, etc.

Next, she'll select highly compatible potential matches from Enamour's exclusive, invitation-only database. But that's just the beginning. Enamour also utilizes an array of recruiting tools as well as an extensive network of scouts to pinpoint candidates from a variety of offline and online sources.

Each potential match is screened for compatibility either in person or via video call, then a profile with a photo array is sent to you for approval.

Introductions are arranged for you, and your matchmaker will check in with both you and your match after each first date. The feedback process allows your matchmaker to pass along any insights she learns from your match, and also helps her fine tune your search.

What Others Are Saying

On Trustpilot, Enamour has a 4-star rating. Reviews mentioned that working with Enamour had inspired them on their dating journey. And several individuals shared what a wonderful experience it had been working with their matchmaker.    

VIDA Select (by Scott Valdez)

If you’re looking for elite matchmaking services at a more affordable price, look no further than VIDA. Founded in 2009, VIDA's matchmakers have access to the largest number of NJ singles you’ll find in any database. Clients typically meet someone special within the first handful of months!

Clientele

VIDA takes on both men and women as paying clients, and typically works with successful singles in their late 20s to early 60s.

Cost

Here’s one aspect that sets VIDA apart from other New Jersey matchmakers - matchmaking services are purchased by the month, which means no contracts! Your matchmaking service can be stopped, frozen, or restarted any time you want.

Basic packages start at $1195/month, Premium options begin at $1795/month and Elite packages start at only $2595/month.

In addition to the level of service you choose, Package prices highly reflect the number of hours that should be dedicated to the search for your perfect match - so various factors like "must haves" are taken into consideration when recommending the best package for you.

What To Expect

The first step is a short, free, and confidential call with one of our best matchmakers. If VIDA seems like a mutual good fit, you’ll then have a more extensive interview where your matchmaker will learn about you and your relationship history. You’ll also provide an in-depth description of your ideal partner. And then, the search begins!

Highly compatible matches will be presented to you for approval, and you’ll get a full profile and photos of each one. If you’re interested, your dedicated matchmaking team handles everything else. You’ll be meeting high-quality NJ singles that fit exactly what you’re looking for in a partner.

What Others Are Saying

On Trustpilot, VIDA holds a 4.5-star rating based on over 400 reviews.  

Clients shared positive experiences about their matchmakers, saying that they handled “all the logistics” and that “they were passionate and very quick in their response time.”  Many individuals mentioned that they’ve been on “good dates with quality matches.”  

New Jersey Matchmaking (by Michelle Frankel)

Calling herself the “Chief Love Officer,” this former lawyer specializes in networking and recruiting New York and New Jersey singles who match what her clients are looking for. New Jersey Matchmaking is an extension of NYCity Matchmaking, founded in 2012.

Clientele

Michelle Frankel accepts both women and men in their 20s to 60s as paying clients, and will help you find any type of relationship from casual dating to marriage.

Cost

Both genders can submit profiles to her “Free” members database. Assuming you can make it past the screening process, you’ll be included - but without any match guarantees.

For paying clients, the first step is a preliminary interview, which costs $475 in person or $350 via video call. This NJ matchmaker typically uses 6-month contracts. Matchmaking costs vary depending on each client's search parameters.

What To Expect

Frankel limits how many people she works with at a time - usually, it’s only 10 to 12. If you sign the matchmaking service contract after the initial interview, you’ll be paired with compatible singles from Frankel’s “Free” member database.

She also networks with other professional matchmakers in NJ and NY, and has a team who recruit New Jersey singles at art openings, sports games, and other local events. Your matchmaker will arrange all the details of your date, and provide you with ‘objective feedback’ after the fact.

What Others Are Saying

On Yelp, NYC Matchmaking has a 4.9-star rating based on around 50 reviews. Many of the 5-star reviews mentioned a positive experience working with Frankel and her team.  Several mentioned meeting someone special through the service, like this person: “The first woman I was introduced to has been a great match.”     

For more information, check out this Michelle Frankel review!

AVConnexions (by Arlene Vasquez Washburn)

She did a stint as CEO, trainer, and consultant for the Matchmaking Institute, and also runs a life coaching business called Life Past Divorce in addition to offering traditional matchmaking services via AVConnexions.

Clientele

Washburn works with successful, commitment-minded NJ singles, typically professionals like lawyers, pharma execs, and doctors. She takes on men or gay/bi women as paying clients.

Cost

Women can join the AVConnexions database for free, provided a screening process is passed. However, as a non-paying member, there won’t be any guaranteed matches.

Professional matchmaking services for men (or women seeking a same-sex partner) start around $50,000 and include image consulting and date coaching sessions.

What To Expect

Potential clients start by filling out a questionnaire online, which is followed up by a “discovery” call where Washburn will go over the membership options. If you decide to move forward, you’ll have a “clarity session,” during which you’ll let her know the type of person you want to meet.

She’ll then identify potential matches based on compatible core values, life goals, and physical criteria. Dates are arranged for you, and you’ll provide feedback after each one. You can also attend AVConnexions’ NJ speed dating events, mixers, and other social gatherings.

What Others Are Saying

AVConnections doesn’t have a listing with the Better Business Bureau, and you aren’t likely to find any reviews on Yelp or Trustpilot. This absence of online reviews isn’t all that surprising since upscale matchmaking clients typically value discretion in regards to their matchmaking experience.  

New Jersey’s Matchmaker (by Julianne Cantarella)

A licensed therapist with a background in social work, Julianne Cantarella is not only a successful dating coach, she’s one of New Jersey’s most elite matchmakers as well. She got her matchmaking feet wet working as a consultant at eHarmony and then launched her own NJ dating agency in 2009.

Clientele

Single men (typically in their 40s+) seeking anything from casual dating to a long-term relationship in New Jersey and Rockland County.

Cost

Women can be included in the database free of charge, provided they pass Cantarella’s screening process. For male clients, the cost of a membership package varies depending on what level of date coaching you want, and how many matches you’d like.

What To Expect

She’s basically a one-woman show, so she generally works with only 10 or so men at a time. Becoming a New Jersey's Matchmaker client starts with a 1 to 2-hour consultation.

Cantarella will get to know you, the type of person you’d consider an “ideal partner,” and also decide how much date coaching you may need. Assuming you sign the contract, you’ll meet with NJ singles from her database or that she’s recruited via her matchmaking network.

What Others Are Saying

You won’t find many New Jersey’s Matchmaker reviews through common review platforms like Yelp, Trustpilot, or the BBB. Cantarella has a few reviews on their Google listing page, mostly citing favorable experiences. Reviewers mentioned how Cantarella’s dating coaching helped them find relationships, some leading to marriage. 

For more information, check out these New Jersey's Matchmaker reviews.

Serious Matchmaking (by Janis & Carly Spindel)

Widely considered one of the most famous millionaire matchmakers in NYC, Janis Spindel and her daughter work their magic in New Jersey too. Janis Spindel launched Serious Matchmaking back in 1993.

Clientele

Men looking for serious relationships (read: marriage).

Cost

The cost for 12 months of matchmaking service depends on who you work with. Having Carly Spindel search for compatible singles starts at $25,000 and tops out over $350,000. If her mom Janis is on the case? That will run you $50,000 up to $1,000,000. And if you want both of them to look for your soulmate, that starts at $80,000.

New clients pay a signing fee that starts at $65,000. The same amount is due as a finder’s fee should you stay in a relationship with one of your matches for 12 months, get engaged, or move in together.

There’s also the “Flash Match” package, which costs $6,000 and doesn’t require a matchmaking contract. You’ll meet 6 women selected by Carly Spindel at an upscale venue in New York City.

Women are included in the Spindel’s database if they pass an interview and pay a one-time screening fee, typically between $250 and $1250, depending on the interview’s format.

What To Expect

If you’re thinking about hiring Serious Matchmaking, the first step is a face to face meeting - usually over a meal - with either of the Spindels. You’ll be presented with the option they feel is the best fit for you, and if you agree you’ll sign the contract and pay for the service up front. All clients get a minimum of 12 matches in 12 months.

What Others Are Saying

On Yelp, Serious Matchmaking and Janis Spindel have a 3.1 rating with less than 100 mixed reviews. 

Of those who had positive things to say about the company, they mentioned the matchmaker's helpful commentary and support.  In addition, many women in their database shared positive experiences about being a part of their database for matchmaking clients.  

For a deeper look at this matchmaking service, check out our Serious Matchmaking review.

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.