Should You Hire Janis & Carly Spindel? [Matchmaker Reviews]

Janis Spindel and her daughter Carly Spindel are two of New York City’s most well known matchmakers, so it’s no wonder they made your short list. But does name recognition automatically = great matchmaking service?


Keep reading for everything you want to know about these elite New York matchmakers, and details about Serious Matchmaking – including costs, complaints, and authentic customer reviews!

A True Family Business

Serious matchmaking reviews

Janis Spindel founded Serious Matchmaking in 1993, and her husband of 30+ years, Allen, is the Chief Operating Officer.

Their daughter Carly joined the business as a professional matchmaker in 2009, and eventually became the company’s VP.

The company has grown into one of New York City’s most elite dating agencies, with Janis joining the “millionaire matchmaker” ranks alongside people like Patti Stanger.

No stranger to the press, she’s been described as “a force of nature in her field” and often credits her success to having a matchmaking sixth sense. As she told one interviewer,

“They’ve been calling me clairvoyant and I guess I am because I just get these weird ‘flashes,’ I call them, or premonitions at the oddest times and in the oddest places.”

Those flashes often prompt her to approach anyone she feels is “marriage material”, asking the million dollar question – ‘are you single?’ while holding out her business card.

Women pay a one-time $500 fee to sit down with Janis for 30 minutes or so. If they meet her strict criteria, she’ll list them in the database as potential matches for paying clients.

As she told the Boston Globe, she’ll literally chase down an attractive woman heading for the bathroom in a restaurant if she thinks she’d make a good addition to her rolodex.

So how much does hiring someone that dedicated to her craft cost you?

The Price Of Elite NYC Matchmaking

Working directly with Janis starts at $50,000 and ranges all the way up to $1,000,000. For that, you’ll receive at least 12 matches in 12 months, as mandated by the NYC laws governing personal matchmaking.

Working with Carly costs less, starting at $25,000 up to $350,000+. Or you can work with the mother/daughter duo, for somewhere between $65,000 and $300,000.

Factors affecting the cost include whether you want a local, national, or global search, and how difficult it may be to find your ideal partner. As Janis told Urbanette, men often have their “perfect match” lists engraved in stone:

“In an already superficial world, these men have their future lady chosen down to preferred eye color, hair color and weight. No ifs, ands or buts about it.”

If you’re not looking to commit to an entire year’s worth of matchmaking services up front, there’s always the “Flash Match” option:

Flash Match NYC cost

The Matchmaking Process

The first step is a face to face consultation with Janis or her daughter. Typically it’s over a lunch or dinner – they call it a “simulated date” since they’ll be getting to know you and what/who you’re looking for in a relationship.

Membership options will be discussed, and your package will be customized. The entire fee is paid up front, and you may also have an additional “success” fee due when you get engaged or married to someone you met via the service.

All those details will be clearly specified in the contract, which runs for a year. It also includes a year’s worth of “hold” time. Once you sign the contract, you can cancel your membership within 3 business days. After that there are typically no refunds offered.

As with most matchmaking services, Janis doesn’t guarantee she’ll find your perfect partner:

“I don't do guarantees, if anyone offers you a guarantee, run away from them- you can't put a guarantee on feelings. I can lead a horse to water but I can't make it drink.”

She will, however, do everything in her power to make you an attractive marriage prospect. Here is an example she shared during an interview with Elle:

Janis Spindel Elle Magazine

Janis & Carly Spindel Reviews

Both Janis and Carly have been profiled in various media outlets over the years, but what do real customers have to say about this NYC matchmaking service?

Not a lot, as it turns out. Most of the online reviews are from women who either paid to be in the Serious Matchmaking database or attended events.

Recommended reviews on Yelp are a mixed bag, although slightly more positive than negative resulting in a 3 ½ star rating.

Many women were happy with their experience at the recruiting events, like this reviewer who not only enjoyed reading Janis Spindel’s book, she also liked meeting her in person:

Janis Spindel yelp reviews

Others felt they paid a lot of money but never got anything in return, like this woman:

serious matchmaking yelp

The not currently recommended Yelp reviews for Janis Spindel were much the same – all from women who either had a great experience at the mixers or during the in-person screening interview, or felt they had paid a lot of money and gotten nothing in return.

There don’t seem to be any reviews from paying male clients, which is a good sign. Besides, Janis Spindel has been matchmaking for over 20 years, so she’s definitely doing something right.

Are Janis And Carly Spindel The Best Matchmakers For You?

Here’s what you need to decide: are you ready and willing to make a substantial financial commitment up front, or would you rather opt for a less expensive modern matchmaker that can also help find your ideal partner?

New York City doesn’t lack for elite dating agencies, and many, like VIDA, charge substantially less. It all comes down to budget, and the amount you’re comfortable spending.

VIDA offers the ultimate in flexibility – you pay by the month, so there are no risky contracts. You can start or stop your service as needed, allowing you to explore promising relationships, travel, or just take a break from dating.

And VIDA’s elite matchmakers aren’t limited by the size of their database – they know how to leverage New York City’s single largest pool of incredible singles, and you pre-approve every single match.

See what VIDA can do for you! The first step is easy, free and confidential – just a quick 20-minute phone call with one of our top matchmakers. Just click here

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.

Steal Our 8 Best-Performing Profiles.

Copy & Paste Our Best Profile Examples To Get More Views, More Responses, And More Dates!

About VIDA

VIDA is your very own team of experts who set up high-quality dates for you so you can finally meet your ideal woman. Say goodbye to the hassle and frustration of online dating - we'll craft an irresistible dating profile, send engaging messages, and even book your dates for you. Thousands of guys have already made lasting connections with beautiful women, and we're ready to make you our next success story. All you need to do is schedule your free confidential consultation with us now.

Step 1 of 11

Do You Qualify?

I am a...

Step 1 of 11




Give me your 5 best-performing messages so I can get more women responding and get more dates!

I think I can eventually figure out the best messages to send women.

From Women!


Get More Responses

Use Our 5 Highest Performing Icebreaker Messages & Fill Your Inbox With Responses From Women Eager To Meet Up With You...

Just sign up below and we’ll send you the report right away:

Copy & Paste Our Best Profile Examples To Get More Views, More Responses, And More Dates!

Steal Our 8 Best-Performing Profiles When You Download This FREE Guide...

Download Your



Appear Twice As Attractive Online With These Secret Photo Techniques...

Use These 5 Sure-Fire Conversation Starters

Copy & Paste Your Way To Guaranteed Responses From Attractive Women Using Our 5 Favorite Opening Messages...

Now You Can Copy & Paste Your Way To Responses On Tinder

Use Our 14 Best-Performing Tinder Messages Now...

Yours FREE: Use These 21 Proven Profile Headlines To Get More Dates

Sparking Interest Online Is Now As Easy As Copy And Paste With This Free Guide...

Schedule A Quick Call

To Simply Get Started, Enter Your BEST Email Address Into The Form Below, Then You Will Be Taken To The Book Page To Choose The Times That Work Best For You...

More Responses. Better Dates.

Discover The Perfect Dating App For You...