Secret Benefits 2024 Review [Is This Sugar Daddy Site Legit?]

You have a lot of choices when it comes to sugar dating websites so it’s no surprise you’re wondering how Secret Benefits stacks up to the competition.

Our dating experts have been helping singles attract the hottest sugar babies since the site launched back in 2016. And in this Secret Benefits review, we’ll give you a full rundown on how it works, how much it costs, real users reviews, and whether or not this sugar site is worth your time!

Let’s dive in!

Is Secret Benefits Legit? 

Secret Benefits is a straightforward sugar dating site, where most women are looking for a ‘mutually beneficial’ sugar relationship. But not all - you’ll also find women open to casual dating or even a more traditional long-term relationship.

Men typically join as sugar daddies, women join as sugar babies. It’s available to users in select regions including the US, UK, Canada, and Australia.

But here’s what you need to know: the Secret Benefits website works on a credit system, so it’s essentially a “pay as you use it” set up. Other sugar sites, like Seeking and Sugarbook, have a premium subscription that’s based on a monthly cost. (Want to see how the two compare? Check this out next!)

On Secret Benefits, you have to buy credits, then spend them to start conversations, see photos, etc. (More on how the credits work coming right up!)

Depending on how active you are on the site, those costs could add up quickly. It’s also an added level of frustration if you spend credits to message a promising sugar baby, and the conversation ends up fizzling out.

On the other hand, if your profile and photos are on point and your messaging game is on fire, Secret Benefits could end up being substantially cheaper than other sugar dating sites. 

A one-month membership to Seeking costs $109.99, or $274.99 if you spring for the Diamond level. On Secret Benefits, it will cost you up to $6 to start a conversation with a sugar baby depending on how many credits you bought at once. 

So if you converse with 10 sugar babies on Secret Benefits in one month (and don’t spend credits to send photos or look at the private albums), you’ve only invested $60.

Let’s take a look at how much those credits cost, and what you can do with them.

Secret Benefits Credits Cost

Signing up, creating your profile, and uploading photos is free. You can also verify your profile and use the search tools and filters to browse sugar baby profiles.

But most everything else, including messaging and viewing private photos, requires credits. As a new member, you’ll be offered these 3 credit package options:

Credits never expire, and they’re also non-refundable.

Many Secret Benefits features cost men 10 credits per use:

• Unlock messaging with a sugar baby (reading a first message from a sugar baby or sending one of your own requires credits, but once unlocked you can exchange as many messages as you want with that user)
• Include a photo in your message (1o credits per photo sent)
• Anonymous browsing for 24 hours
• Unlock a “secret album”

You can also spend credits to turn on message read receipts for a particular conversation or boost your message in her inbox. 

So, is Secret Benefits worth it? Let’s take a look at some other pros, cons, and real user reviews for this sugar dating website!

Secret Benefits Reviews

On the plus side…

Secret Benefits Pros

• Users can verify their profiles, which helps you avoid scammers and bots.
• The website has a clean layout that’s easy to navigate and simply to use.
• Sugar babies don’t pay anything to use the site.
• You’ll find some beautiful sugar babies!

On the down side…

Secret Benefits Cons

• There is no free trial period to test out the site, nor can you purchase a monthly membership. Everything is credit based.
• Unlike other wealth-based sites like MillionaireMatch, you can’t verify your income level.
• It’s a desktop and mobile-friendly website, but offers no dedicated Secret Benefits app for download.

Let’s take a look at what some other Secret Benefits users thought of their experience.

On SiteJabber, Secret Benefits has a respectable 4.13 rating based on over 375 reviews.

Users like these two found the women fairly responsive:

On the flip side, Secret Benefits complaints included the credits set up:

And the number of fake profiles users thought they encountered on this sugar daddy dating site:

But overall, SiteJabber reviews were generally good, with 70% of user reviews in the past year being positive. 
Secret Benefits Trustpilot reviews were also more good than bad, resulting in a 4.5 star rating overall.

This reviewer claimed he met a “possible keeper” on Secret Benefits:

And this user also reported meeting someone special:

Complaints about Secret Benefits included the payment model, with these two reviewers not happy about the credit system:

Other negative reviews mentioned the abundance of profiles the user thought were fake:

Our Secret Benefits verdict:

In our experience, it is possible to meet some beautiful sugar babies on Secret Benefits. But that being said, our dating experts have been helping clients since 2009, and know all the ins and outs of marketing yourself effectively on a sugar site!

If you don’t know how to set up a compelling profile, choose your best photos, and keep a message exchange going, Secret Benefits may not be the site for you. (Want us to do it all for you, so you can just skip straight to the dates with the sugar baby of your dreams? Go here!)

What To Expect When You Sign Up

The Secret Benefits sign up process is quite streamlined.

Begin by selecting whether you identify as a “Man” or a “Woman”. Next, you’ll be asked for basic information like your name, email, username, age, and ethnicity. 

Upload at least one public photo. This will be your primary profile picture, and you’ll have the opportunity to add up to 5 more public photos. You can also create a “Secret Photos” album if you want.

Secret Benefits profiles for sugar daddies have 3 parts: a headline, a description of what you’re looking for, and a description of what you have to offer (i.e. the type of arrangement you’d like to find). 

There’s also the opportunity to include details about your physical appearance, values, lifestyle and interests. 

As a final step, you can verify your profile by tapping the verification link on the profile editing screen. 

You’ll be prompted to repeat a few prompted words in a selfie video.

It’s generally best to verify your profile on any sugar daddy website you use, as that adds a layer of authenticity. It will also get you in more search results, as many dating sites and apps let users screen for verified members only.

Now that you’ve created your Secret Benefits account, check out our Secret Benefits profile tips for two strategies that will attract the best local sugar babies!