Simply Matchmaking Reviews [Best Service For Seattle Singles?]

Seattle’s singles scene is notoriously frosty, so many frustrated daters turn to a matchmaking service to provide high-quality matches - and hopefully find their ideal partner.

Can Ali Migliore make some magic happen for you?

Our team of experts has reviewed well over 200 matchmaking services, diving deep into their processes, success rates, cost, and customer experiences. Our reviews are built on extensive research and a keen understanding of the matchmaking landscape that comes from 14+ years in the industry.

These Simply Matchmaking reviews have the details you need to help answer that question, like cost, her approach to matchmaking, and even real customer experience!

Let's dive in!

Modern Matchmaking In Seattle

Prior to becoming a matchmaker, Migliore’s background was in event planning. She’d wanted to be a professional cupid since she was 15. When several interviews with matchmaking companies didn’t pan out, her husband suggested she start her own.

She founded Simply Matchmaking in 2013, and her husband is the COO. She employs a team of 11 matchmakers, one matchmaking director, 2 online dating experts, 2 personal stylists, and a VP of client relations.

While Migliore also works with a network of matchmakers all over the country, the majority of her clients are in the Pacific Northwest. Many of them live in Seattle and Bellevue.

Simply Matchmaking has attracted quite a diverse clientele, ranging from 21 to 80 years old. Migliore and her team provide matchmaking services for straight, gay, bisexual and transgender singles.

As she told The Ghosted Podcast,

“We service all ages, all ethnicities, all religions, LGBTQ, you name it – if you are truly looking for a committed relationship and your heart is in the right place, you can work with Simply Matchmaking.”

She hasn’t been in business long compared to some other dating agencies. But she’s already racked up a few awards. In 2015 Simply Matchmaking was named the #1 matchmaker in Western Washington by King 5, and the best Seattle matchmaking service by City Voter in 2016 and 2017.

So what can you expect if you become a Simply Matchmaking client?

How Simply Matchmaking Helps Seattle Singles Find Love

Potential clients can opt to just join the database and wait to be matched with paying clients. Or you can purchase a membership so that a matchmaker will actively search the database on your behalf.

This process starts with a 20-minute matchmaking strategy call where you will go over the interview process for becoming a VIP client or a potential match for Simply Matchmaking’s VIP clients.

Migliore explained her role in an interview with Ghosted:

“My sole responsibility is to take care of all of our male clientele. So I handle everything from the first phone call, explaining our services, answering their questions and then conducting their personal interview to learn all about who they are and what they’re looking for. And then I personally hand-select every match that they meet… I really hold their hand from start to finish.”

According to Migliore, her husband Matt takes care of all of this for their female members.

As Migliore told Dating Advice,

"We get to know every single client who comes through the door. It’s like dating therapy when you sit down with one of us."

If you decide to become a member, you’ll be paired with compatible Seattle area singles in the database. The date details are arranged for you. You’ll also get tips on what to wear and how to prepare for your date, if needed.

Afterwards, your matchmaker follows up with you and your match, and you’ll get constructive feedback on how you could present yourself better next time. You’ll also have the opportunity to give your matchmaker feedback on the compatibility of your match, so she can fine tune her search methods.

All contracts include unlimited matches and last for 12 months, as you'll have the ability to suspend your service as needed.

Matchmaking fees are non-refundable in most circumstances, and they don’t guarantee you’ll actually get any matches. As with any contract, read it carefully prior to signing so you understand exactly what service you’ll be receiving in exchange for your money.

Now let’s take a look at some Simply Matchmaking reviews from out in the wild...

What People Have To Say About Their Simply Matchmaking Experience

On Yelp, Simply Matchmaking has been reviewed 40+ times, resulting in a solid 2.8-star rating.

In their recommended reviews, some happy customers said they had found a serious relationship via the service:

This customer didn’t meet their ideal partner through Simply Matchmaking, but was satisfied with the quality of the service and thought they had picked up some valuable insight along the way:

Other customers however didn’t have such glowing things to say. These clients felt that the service does not cater enough to their female members. In their words:

Simply Matchmaking Google Reviews

Simply Matchmaking also has a 4-star rating when it comes to Google reviews, based on 30+ reviews. The majority of reviews are 5-star.

One Google reviewer was thrilled to have met someone through the service and dated for a few months, even though it did not work out in the long run:

Another praised his overall experience:

Of course you can’t predict exactly what your Simply Matchmaking experience would be like from feedback on local review sites. But they do make a handy starting point for jotting down a list of questions to ask during your consultation.

In the meantime, one thing to consider when hiring a matchmaking service is how you feel about signing a 12-month contract that doesn’t actually guarantee you’ll get any matches at all, as Migliore explained in her response to a Yelp complaint:

So why not consider adding a matchmaking service that allows you to pay on a monthly basis to your list of Seattle matchmaker options?

Let VIDA Select Help Find Your Perfect Match!

With VIDA, you only pay for each month you want service. No long-term contracts! On average, clients meet someone special within just 3 months of beginning service. That’s because VIDA’s elite matchmakers dip into Seattle’s most extensive pool of high-quality singles.

And here’s the even better news - with VIDA, you’re in total control of the process. You’re only meeting matches you’ve pre-approved based on a full profile with photos, so you already know they meet your “must haves.” No more disappointing first dates!

Plus, our pay-as-you-go structure gives you the ultimate flexibility. You can pause, stop, or start your search whenever you’d like, and for any reason at all. If the service isn’t a good fit for you, no problem. You’re not locked into a lengthy, pricey contract.

Want to learn more?

All you have to do is click here to schedule a quick, free, no-obligation phone call with one of our matchmakers.

Why not do it right now? You’ll be that much closer to finally meeting your ideal partner!

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.