Secret Benefits Review [2026 Cost, How It Works & More]

Secret Benefits is a legitimate sugar dating site where sugar daddies pay per action using credits ($0.29-$0.59 each) while sugar babies use the platform free. With 3.4 stars on Trustpilot and roughly 70% positive reviews, it's a viable option—though complaints about fake profiles and the credit system are common. If your profile and messaging skills are strong, Secret Benefits can be cheaper than subscription-based competitors like Seeking. If not, credits add up fast.

Key Insights

• Payment model: Credit-based (pay per action) rather than monthly subscription—costs vary based on your activity level
• Credit pricing: $0.29-$0.59 per credit depending on package size; 10 credits unlocks messaging with each sugar baby
• Free for women: Sugar babies use the site at no cost; only sugar daddies purchase credits
• Verification available: Video selfie verification helps legitimate users stand out, but no income verification like MillionaireMatch
• User reviews: 3.4 stars on Trustpilot (900+ reviews), 3.1 stars on SiteJabber (440+ reviews)—roughly 70% positive
• No mobile app: Desktop and mobile-friendly website only; no dedicated app download
• Shared database: Same parent company as Sugardaddy.com; profiles are cross-listed between sites
• Available regions: US, UK, Canada, and Australia

Our dating experts have helped singles connect with attractive sugar babies since Secret Benefits launched in 2016. Here's our full breakdown of how it works, what it costs, and whether it's worth your time.

Secret Benefits is a straightforward sugar dating site. Most women are seeking "mutually beneficial" sugar relationships, though you'll also find some open to casual dating or more traditional long-term connections.

Men typically join as sugar daddies; women join as sugar babies. The platform is available in the US, UK, Canada, and Australia.

Pros:

• Profile verification through video selfies helps avoid scammers and bots
• Clean, easy-to-navigate layout
• Sugar babies use the site completely free
• Attractive sugar babies on the platform
• Credits never expire

Cons:

• No free trial or monthly subscription option—everything is credit-based
• No income verification (unlike MillionaireMatch)
• No dedicated mobile app
• Credit costs can add up quickly with unsuccessful conversations
• Fake profiles remain an issue despite verification options

Our Verdict

It's definitely possible to meet beautiful sugar babies on Secret Benefits. However, success depends heavily on your profile quality, photo selection, and messaging skills. If those aren't strong, credits will drain fast with little to show for it.

The credit system rewards efficiency: if you can convert conversations to dates quickly, Secret Benefits may cost less than subscription-based sites. If you struggle with messaging, a flat monthly fee might be more economical.

Unlike sugar sites like Seeking or Sugarbook that charge monthly subscriptions, Secret Benefits uses a "pay as you use it" credit system. You buy credits, then spend them to unlock features.

This can work in your favor: A one-month Seeking membership costs $109.99 (or $274.99 for Diamond). On Secret Benefits, unlocking a conversation costs up to 60 credits (~$35 at the highest per-credit rate). If you're efficient and connect with 10 sugar babies in a month without extra spending, you've invested less than Seeking's monthly fee.

Or it can work against you: If you spend credits on promising profiles that don't respond, or conversations that fizzle, costs add up with nothing to show. The lack of a flat monthly rate means your spending is unpredictable.

Signing up, creating your profile, uploading photos, verifying your account, and browsing are all free. But messaging and viewing private photos require credits.

New members see these package options:

Secret Benefits Credit Cost* (2026)
Introductory: $59 for 100 credits ($0.59/credit)
Elite: $169 for 500 credits ($0.34/credit)
Best Value: $289 for 1,000 credits ($0.29/credit)
*Cost may vary by location

Important: Credits never expire but are non-refundable.

What Credits Buy

Most features cost 10 credits per use:

• Unlock messaging with a sugar baby (first message sent or received costs credits; after unlocking, unlimited messages with that user)
• Send a photo in messages (10 credits per photo)
• Anonymous browsing for 24 hours
• View a "secret album"

You can also spend credits to enable read receipts for specific conversations or boost your message visibility in her inbox.

SiteJabber: 3.1 Stars (440+ Reviews)

Roughly 70% of reviews are positive.

Positive feedback:

Users praised the responsive matches. One 5-star reviewer noted: "You got to use credits to message and not all will respond but from my experience, not a lot of funny business with the women as most seem eager to carry on a convo and meet up."

Another user shared: "To my pleasant surprise, many responded back, and I continued with a few interesting conversations."

Common complaints:

• The credit payment system feels "gamified"
• Concerns about site administrators editing profiles
• Fake profiles and bots burning through credits

Trustpilot: 3.4 Stars (900+ Reviews)

More positive than negative overall.

Success stories:

Multiple reviewers claimed to have met someone special. One sugar daddy initially left a negative review but later updated it: "You have to be patient on this site and if you have nothing to offer in return to SB's then this site is not for u."

Criticisms:

One user acknowledged his experience improved over time but noted: "I still think they need to change their payment model so it's not so gamified or incremental, but it's not a scam."

Others were harsher, with one calling it a "circle trap to spend more and more money" and another warning of "hundreds of messages from bots and fake accounts designed to burn your credits."

Reddit Feedback

Reddit complaints mirror other platforms—concerns about scams and fake profiles dominate.

However, some users reported success. One shared that sugar sites work, but "you do need different tactics." His strategy involved "ruthless filtering"—blocking women with only one photo, sparse profiles, and no verification video.

Important discovery: One user found that Secret Benefits and Sugardaddy.com share profiles. A sugar baby discovered her Sugardaddy.com profile appearing on Secret Benefits without her signing up there. As one Redditor explained: "SB and Sugar Daddy dot com are owned by the same company. Profiles are cross pollinated."

The signup process is streamlined:

1. Select whether you identify as "Man" or "Woman"
2. Enter basic information: name, email, username, age, ethnicity
3. Upload at least one public photo (up to 6 total public photos allowed)
4. Create a "Secret Photos" album for private images
5. Complete your profile with headline, what you're looking for, and what you offer

Profile Sections for Sugar Daddies

• Headline: Your attention-grabbing opener
• What you're looking for: Describe your ideal arrangement
• What you have to offer: The type of relationship/arrangement you'd like
• Additional details: Physical appearance, values, lifestyle, interests

Verification

Tap the verification link on your profile editing screen to record a video selfie repeating prompted words. Verified profiles:

• Add authenticity and trust
• Appear in more search results (many users filter for verified members only)
• Stand out from fake profiles

Verification is generally worth doing on any sugar dating platform.

Filter Ruthlessly

Given concerns about fake profiles, be selective. Red flags include:

• Only one photo
• Sparse or generic profile text
• No verification video
• Profiles that seem too good to be true

Invest in Your Profile First

Since every conversation costs credits, make sure your profile converts views into responses before spending heavily. Strong photos and a compelling headline reduce wasted credits on sugar babies who won't respond.

Message Strategically

The credit system punishes scattered approaches. Focus on fewer, higher-quality prospects rather than mass messaging.

Want to skip the trial and error on sugar dating sites? VIDA Select has helped singles find beautiful sugar babies since 2016. We handle profile creation, photo selection, and messaging—so you just show up for dates with compatible matches.

Book your complimentary consultation and discover how easy it can be to find the relationship you want.