Susie Q Matchmaking Review [Best Choice For Boston Singles?]

There are plenty of Boston matchmakers out there, so let’s find out if Susanne MacDowell’s Susie Q Matchmaking is the best choice for you. 

From the biggest international services to the smallest local boutiques, our team of matchmaking experts has reviewed well over 200 matchmakers. 

With more than 14 years worth of industry experience, we know firsthand what clients value most in a matchmaking service!

Let’s get started with the face behind the service!

Meet Boston Matchmaker Susanne MacDowell

Susanne MacDowell has an eclectic career background. Studying early childhood education with a minor in psychology, she went on to become an elementary school teacher. She then worked in vacation sales for almost seven years. 

In 2007, she made another career switch, becoming a relationship consultant for Elite Matchmaking and Table For Six. MacDowell was their head of matchmaking and sales until she founded her own matchmaking company – Susie Q Matchmaking – in 2014.

Susie Q Matchmaking caters to singles in the New England area and is headquartered in Beverly.

In an interview with the Boston Globe, MacDowell shared that the age of her clients has changed over time. They used to be mainly between the ages of 40 to 60, but she’s noticing her clients are “all over the board” now. She currently works with singles 25 to 65+.

In addition to matchmaking, MacDowell says she also supports her clients “100% of the way” by dispensing dating tips. She also dishes advice via her socials.

For instance, in one of her TikToks, she suggests that single woman reconsider a common height requirement:

“During a matchmaking meeting the other day, a funny thing came up for the five-millionth time: ‘I want to meet someone who is 6-ft or taller.’ But hey ladies, all these men under 6-ft… they all look the same lying down.”

Here’s another taste of her best dating tips:

What To Expect As A Susie Q Matchmaking Client

Prospective clients start by filling out the consultation form on the website. A team member will reach out to ask you a few screening questions and schedule a complimentary consultation with Susanne MacDowell. 

During this meeting, you’ll have the opportunity to share a little bit about yourself and what kind of matches you’re hoping to meet. You’ll also learn more about how MacDowell’s Boston matchmaking service works, and what packages are available. 

This consultation is also your opportunity to ask questions aimed at helping you decide if Susie Q Matchmaking is the right fit. (Want a list of the most crucial questions to ask any matchmaker you’re thinking about hiring? Bookmark our insider’s guide to hiring a matchmaking service!)

If you decide to move forward, you’ll choose a package and sign a contract. MacDowell will match you with other paying clients, or singles she and her team have scouted via online marketing and public spaces, such as meet-up groups, events, parks, restaurants, etc. 

You’ll have the opportunity to review a profile, including photos, of each potential match.

Now, let’s take a look at what clients have to say about their experience with this New England matchmaker.

Susie Q Matchmaking Reviews

On Yelp, Susie Q Matchmaking holds a 4.3-star rating based on 10 reviews.

The majority of the Susanne MacDowell reviews were positive, with former clients like these three sharing they’d met someone special through the service:

This former client appreciated MacDowell’s approach and that she set realistic expectations:

On the other end of the star rating scale, this former client gave Susie Q Matchmaking a 1-star review based on the perceived lack of quality matches:

There are also 7 not currently recommended Yelp reviews for Susie Q Matchmaking, which are a mix of 1, 4, and 5 stars. 

On Google, Susie Q Matchmaking has a 3.4-star rating based on 5 reviews.

This reviewer shared a positive experience, giving Susie Q Matchmaking 5 stars for getting to know him and helping to set realistic dating expectations:

Another 5-star review was a duplicate of the one the client left on Yelp, and another one simply had the star rating with no additional comments.

There were also a handful of 1-star reviews, the most recent from someone who was not a client because he felt the prices were too high.

The other 1-star Susie Q Matchmaking reviewer expressed frustration with matches not fitting her criteria:

Susie Q Matchmaking has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), with no reviews or complaints to date. It has not yet been reviewed on other platforms like Trustpilot.

How Much Does Susie Q Matchmaking Cost? 

Hiring Susie MacDowell as your personal matchmaker costs anywhere from $5,900 to $15,000+. Package prices depend on the length of your contract, which is typically 6 or 12 months. 

But as a client, the search scope and match criteria can impact the overall cost of what a client pays. So potential clients can expect to pay up to $15,000 for her matchmaking services and $5,900+ for a 6-month contract. 

Curious how this price tag compares to other Boston matchmakers you may be considering? Let’s do a quick comparison…

Tawkify, for instance, offers matchmaking packages that range from around $4,000 for a minimum of 3 matches to $70,000 for VIP matchmaking services. 

Susan Trombetti, founder of Exclusive Matchmaking, charges New England singles anywhere from $7,500 to $125,000+ for her services.

And if you’re looking for a tailored matchmaking experience, Enamour is likely on your radar. 

Enamour packages start around $20,000 for a 6-month contract, with matches sourced from the exclusive, invitation-only database. Your dedicated matchmaker will also use recruiting tools and an extensive network of scouts to source exceptional candidates from a variety of sources.

VIDA Select is also a service worth considering if you want your matchmaker to have access to the largest source of eligible New England singles there is. Packages start at $1195 per month, with Premium options beginning at just $1795. Elite matchmaking services start at just $2595.

Because packages are pay-as-you-go, there are no long-term contracts. You can start, stop, and pause your search as needed. The cost of your package highly aligns with the number of hours your matchmaker should spend on your search that month, taking into account the complexity of your criteria, geographic scope, and other factors.

On average, VIDA clients begin a relationship with a match within just 3 months of starting service. 

Ready to meet your ideal partner too? See how VIDA can make it happen!

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.