6 Best Vermont Matchmakers [2026 Top List!]

The best Vermont matchmaker depends on your budget and preferences. VIDA Select offers the most flexibility with monthly packages starting at $1,595 and no long-term contracts. For higher-budget clients, Enamour and Agape Match provide elite services starting at $20,000-$30,000. East Coast Match specializes in 55+ singles re-entering the dating scene.

Key Insights:

• Most flexible option: VIDA Select offers pay-by-the-month packages starting at $1,595 with no long-term contracts, plus access to the largest pool of Vermont singles
• Elite tier services: Enamour starts at $20,000 for 6 months; Agape Match ranges from $30,000-$100,000; Bonnie Winston runs $20,000-$60,000+
• Budget-conscious choice: East Coast Match packages are valued around $10,000 for 6 matches
• Free database options: Most services let you join their database for free, but you won't receive active matchmaking and may never be contacted
• Specializations vary: East Coast Match focuses on 55+ singles; Agape Match primarily works with men as paying clients; Elegant Introductions emphasizes psychological compatibility

Disclaimer: This guide was researched and written by VIDA Select's editorial team to help singles find the service that best fits their needs and goals. As a matchmaking service ourselves, we bring a unique industry perspective. Our insights come from 17+ years of matchmaking experience, writing 200+ matchmaking service reviews, analyzing public information and reviews on reputable platforms, and feedback from clients who used other services before hiring VIDA. While this guide is updated regularly, it may not reflect current pricing for all services.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 2/14/2026

Coming up, you’re going to get all the essential information for the top 6 matchmaking services in Vermont! Let’s start with…

Enamour

With an elite matchmaking team that's been in the industry since 2009, Enamour offers a tailored experience for accomplished, highly discerning singles.

Clientele

Enamour works with both men and women as paying clients, and helps singles all over the world.

Cost & Contract

Matchmaking packages begin around $20,000 for 6 months of service.

What To Expect

As a client, you'll be paired with a dedicated matchmaker. After learning more about you, your lifestyle, and your ideal partner criteria, she'll start with the search within Enamour's exclusive, invitation-only database.

Each candidate is carefully vetted either in person or via video, with your matchmaker asking insightful questions that get straight to the heart of compatibility. Candidates who pass the screening will be presented to you for approval.

But the search doesn't stop with the database. Enamour's team also uses recruiting technology as well as an extensive network of scouts to identify highly compatible potential matches from a variety of sources both on and offline.

After each introduction, your matchmaker will follow up with both you and your match. This feedback process provides valuable insights into your dating journey, and also allows for any fine-tuning of your search.

In addition to matchmaking, Enamour also offers complementary services such as personal styling, image consulting, dating & life coaching, and professional photography.

 

VIDA Select (by Scott Valdez)

A professional matchmaker for well over a decade, Scott Valdez and his team have modern matchmaking down to a science.

VIDA Select’s matchmakers have direct access to the single largest pool of Vermont singles there is. That means it’s the perfect option whether you’re dating in Burlington, Rutland, Barre, Montpelier or anywhere else in the state!

Clientele

Clients are typically successful, busy professionals in their 20s to 60s looking to meet highly compatible, relationship-minded matches.

Cost & Contract

Monthly matchmaking starts at $1,595, with no long-term contract. There is also a "90-Day Match Guarantee" that includes at least 5 matches you personally approve for $5,750. Guaranteed results, or the search continues at no additional cost.

With an 82% success rate, the majority of VIDA clients meet someone special in just 3 months.

What To Expect 

The first step is filling out a short form online just to make sure you qualify for VIDA Select’s services. Then you’ll have a complimentary consultation to learn more about the process and how it works.

Then it’s time to chat with your matchmaker! VIDA Select takes a team approach to finding your perfect partner, but she’ll be your dedicated point of contact. She’ll get to know all about you and what you’re looking for during a 90-minute interview.

All that information will be used to hand select highly compatible matches who check all your “relationship-worthy” boxes. You’ll be looking forward to all your first dates, because you can approve each match based on a full profile and photos!

In addition to matchmaking, VIDA Select also offers personal styling, dating coaching and more. Everything you need to find the partner of your dreams.

 

East Coast Match (by Michelle Renee Smith)

Formerly known as Executive Matchmaking Solutions, East Coast Match is headquartered in Charlotte, NC. However founder Michelle Renee Smith helps singles all over the east coast, from New York to Florida.

Before launching her own matchmaking service in 2015, Smith worked at one of the largest national matchmaking companies for just over 2 years. 

Clientele

East Coast Match works with professionals looking for a committed relationship. Many of Smith’s clients are 55+, and she also offers life and dating coaching to help them re-enter the dating scene. 

As she explains in an interview, 

People who are suddenly single can find their self esteem is shot. People should not get out there and start dating until they have that in check.

Cost & Contract

Like many Vermont matchmakers, you won’t find the cost of her matchmaking services listed online. 

However during a recent “sweepstakes” promotion, her matchmaking package was valued at $10,000. It included 6 matches and 3 hours of additional services like dating coaching.

There is an option to include your profile in the East Coast Match database, which is free.

But that includes no active matchmaking service, meaning Smith and her team aren’t looking for Vermont singles on your behalf. You may never be matched with anyone at all if you take that route.

What To Expect

To learn more about this Vermont matchmaker, prospective clients fill out an online form. Smith and her team review the information. If you seem like a good candidate, you’ll be invited for a consultation that can last several hours. 

During the conversation, you’ll learn more about the different contract options available as well as how much each package costs.

If you decide to purchase a matchmaking package, Smith will match you with singles from her internal database. If you want to see photos of your potential matches and have the ability to pass on meeting them, you’ll need to purchase the VIP membership.

As part of her matchmaking process, Smith will incorporate dating coaching if she feels you need it. In an interview with Dating Advice, she explains that getting mentally ready is important:

Self-esteem is also a really big one on my list. Not everyone has low self-esteem, but you’d be surprised how many people do. Often I work on their self-esteem with coaching sessions to help them feel good about themselves and get ready for a relationship.

Smith's team also offers additional services like image consulting.

Further Reading

East Coast Match reviews

 

Agape Match (by Maria Avgitidis)

Like Michelle Renee Smith, Maria Avgitidis isn’t a local Vermont matchmaker. She’s actually based in NYC, but her presence extends throughout the Northeast. 

Matchmaking goes back 3 generations in Avgitidis’s family. But before pursuing it professionally herself, she obtained a Master’s in Global Affairs and briefly worked in foreign commercial service for the US Embassy. She founded Agape Match in 2008.

Clientele

Avgitidis and her team typically work with successful men as paying clients, while women join the database to be potentially matched with them. 

Cost & Contract

For women, joining the Agape Match database as a potential match is free. Of course, the downside of that route is you may never be matched with anyone. You’ll only be contacted should your profile meet a client’s criteria. 

If you want the team to actively search for compatible men, you’ll need to see if Avgitidis will work with you as a paying client.

For men (and women who want to pay for service), matchmaking packages start at $30,000 for a 6-month contract. Prices can range up to $100,000.

Your contract may also include a “success fee” due if you date a match for longer than 6 months.

What To Expect

If Agape Match is on your short list, you can get more information by either filling out an online form or calling their office to set up a consultation. During this initial consultation, you’ll share a bit about your relationship goals, your lifestyle, dating history, etc. 

You’ll also learn more about the matchmaking packages, contract length and pricing. She may also recommend dating coaching in addition to (or instead of) matchmaking. As she explains in an interview, “I have a no-nonsense way of communicating with my clients.”

If you decide to come on board as a client, you’ll be matched with compatible Vermont singles from the Agape Match database. Depending on your contract details, she and her team can also scout outside of the database using their professional network. 

All the details of your date are arranged for you, and afterwards you can check in and let the Agape Match team know how it went. 

Further Reading

Agape Match Reviews

 

Bonnie Winston Matchmaker (by Bonnie Winston)

Marketing herself as a celebrity matchmaker, Bonnie Winston is based in New York but works with clients from all over the US. 

She’s been in the industry for about a decade, and previously worked as a model scout and agent. She has a background in photography as well, having owned a business that represented professional photographers.

But no matter what she was doing as a career, Winston says matchmaking has been a constant. As she explains in an interview with Global Love Report, closing her photography business to open a matchmaking one in 2012 was seamless, since she’d been doing it as a hobby throughout her life.

I have been matching couples since I was 16 years old. I just knew I had a natural knack for it.

Clientele

A boutique matchmaker, Winston works with both men and women as paying clients but limits her roster to under 20 at any given time. 

Cost & Contract

Placing a profile in Winston’s database (or as she calls it, her “Date-A-Base”) is free. But because you’re not actually paying for matchmaking services, it’s a passive experience. You may never meet anyone at all. 

For Winston and her team to actively match you with Vermont singles, you’ll need to purchase a matchmaking package.

Bonnie Winston’s services cost anywhere from $20,000 to $150,000. The final cost depends on the length of your contract, the number of matches you’ll receive, your matchmaking criteria and more.  

What To Expect 

Like any Vermont matchmaker, the process starts with an initial consultation. Be prepared to share what you’re looking for in an ideal match, any criteria that are “non-negotiable”, and a little about your lifestyle and dating history.

You’ll also talk about contract details, how many introductions you’d like, the geographic scope of your search, and more. Once all the details have been discussed, she’ll share the price tag and contract details. 

If you decide to move forward, you’ll be meeting eligible singles from Winston’s internal database. Those are people who have signed up for her Date-A-Base via her website, or that she and her team have recruited.

As she said in an interview with DatingAdvice,

I scout all the time. I don’t limit my scouting to just going to parties. I'm constantly scouting whether I’m at a high-end department store, the dry cleaners, or out at lunch.

Bonnie Winston Matchmaking also offers services such as dating coaching, personal styling and image consulting. 

Further Reading

Bonnie Winston Matchmaker Reviews

 

Elegant Introductions (by Dr. Nancy Zimmer & Barbara Black Goldfarb)

Native New Englanders Dr. Nancy Zimmer and Barbara Black Goldfarb embrace the values that define the region: integrity, loyalty, and honesty. The service is headquartered in Florida, but the duo spends a significant amount of time in the region so they understand the nuances of the New England dating scene.

Zimmer is a respected psychologist, while Goldfarb is a community leader and relationship strategist. The duo pairs their psychological insights with their large network to deliver highly compatible matches to their elite clientele.

Clientele

Elegant Introductions works with successful professionals in Vermont and beyond who are educated, attractive, and looking for a more tailored matchmaking experience.

Cost & Contract

The matchmaking service is customized based on the scope of the search, client preferences, and other factors. Pricing is discussed during the consultation, with each package tailored to meet the requirements and timeline of the client.

What To Expect

Like many elite matchmaking services, not every potential client is accepted. The process begins by submitting an intake form, which provides the team with details about your values, lifestyle, background, and relationship goals.

Those who pass this initial screening are invited to a discovery call with one the founders. This is where you'll learn all about Elegant Introductions' approach to matchmaking, philosophy, and more.

The next step is a private consultation with both Dr. Nancy Zimmer and Barbara Black Goldfarb, which covers topics ranging from your relationship history and personal values to your match criteria and long-term goals. If there is mutual agreement to move forward with the service, your search will begin.

You'll meet matches hand-selected for compatibility, with the opportunity to provide feedback after each introduction.

Elegant Introductions also includes additional services such as relationship and dating coaching, professional photography, and social confidence/communication training in their matchmaking packages.

Further Reading

Elegant Introductions Reviews