Amy Laurent Matchmaking Reviews [Is She Worth The Price?]

Celebrity matchmaker Amy Laurent charges $25,000+ annually for her NYC/LA service, working with only 30 male clients at a time through 12-month contracts requiring full upfront payment. While she has strong media credentials (Bravo's "Miss Advised," major publications) and limited negative reviews, her one-woman operation and mandatory annual commitment present significant risks compared to modern alternatives offering month-to-month flexibility.

Key Insights:

• Cost: $25,000+ annually with full upfront payment required
• Capacity: Only 30 male clients at a time, 12-month contracts + 12-month "hold" time
• Locations: NYC (personal screening), LA (team screening with oversight)
• Media: Bravo's "Miss Advised," Fox Business, Men's Health, authored dating book
• Reviews: Limited online presence, some positive feedback on consumer sites
• Legal: 2010 lawsuit (later dropped) regarding match quality complaints
• Alternative: Modern services offer monthly flexibility, faster results (3-month average)

From the small boutique operations to the biggest industry players, we've reviewed over 200 matchmaking services. Our insight comes from more than 14 years of industry experience, comprehensive research, real client reviews, and a keen understanding of the matchmaking landscape.

Amy Laurent's executive matchmaking service has operated since 2005 with offices in New York and Los Angeles. She maintains strict capacity limits, working with only 30 paying male clients at a time who must be committed to long-term relationships.

As Laurent explains,

“My clients as a whole are not looking for arm candy. They are not looking to party, juggle random women, or just focus on someone hot. If that was all that my job entailed, I would only need to work a few hours a day and two days a week!”

Service Structure

NYC Clients: Work directly with Amy Laurent, who personally screens all matches LA Clients: Team members handle screening with Laurent's oversight

Initial Process: Hour-long interview covering relationship goals, background, and ideal partner criteria

Laurent's Client Evaluation: Three key questions determine acceptance:

1. Does Amy understand what you're looking for?

2. Is what you're looking for reasonable?

3. Can Amy find the matches you'd like to meet?

If accepted, she shows potential matches to demonstrate her search process before you commit.

Investment: $25,000+ for 1 year of active service Additional Time: 12 months of "hold" time included Payment: Full amount required upfront

Hold Time Benefits:

• Freeze membership to explore promising relationships
• Pause for extended travel or personal reasons
• Resume search if relationships don't develop

No Match Guarantees: Number of introductions varies based on database compatibility assessed during initial interview

Laurent says singles in her database come from multiple sources. They include word of mouth, events she attends, articles she’s written in magazines like Cosmo, and her TV appearances. Many women hear about her service and want to meet the eligible bachelors who hire her.

Database Sources

• Word-of-mouth referrals
• Events and networking
• Magazine articles (Cosmopolitan, etc.)
• TV appearance exposure
• Women seeking to meet her eligible bachelor clients

Unique Matching Approach

Unlike traditional one-at-a-time matching, Laurent presents multiple candidates simultaneously:

• Reviews several potential matches with photos and descriptions
• Client selects preferred meetings
• Dates arranged for mutual interests

Quality Control: NYC matches personally screened by Laurent; LA matches screened by her team

Television & Media

• Bravo's "Miss Advised": 8-episode reality show appearance
• Media Expert: Fox Business, Dating News regular contributor
• Publications: Men's Health, Cosmopolitan, Huffington Post, New York Times
• Columns: In Touch Weekly, iVillage dating advice
• Author: "8 Weeks To Everlasting" (St Martin's Press)

Professional Recognition

Frequently positioned as relationship expert across major media outlets, indicating industry credibility and expertise.

Online Review Landscape

Major Platforms: No reviews on Trustpilot, CitySearch, Yelp (listed but unrated), or BBB

Consumer Feedback Sites: 17 reviews on theconsumersfeedback.com (dating to 2021) with 4-5 star ratings praising professionalism

Industry Context

Limited negative reviews may indicate satisfactory service, as dissatisfied matchmaking clients typically post negative feedback more frequently than satisfied ones.

Legal Considerations

2010 Lawsuit: John Friedland sued regarding match quality (women in relationships, criteria mismatches). Case later dropped with undisclosed settlement terms.

Even if you’re rich, $25k is a serious chunk of change. Like any investment in your life, it’s important to feel confident you’ll get a solid return. Let's consider the pros and cons of working with Amy Laurent.

Amy Laurent seems to know what she’s doing and that’s something you frankly can't say about many of her competitors.

The lack of negative reviews certainly seem to support this idea. She’s frequently billed as a relationship expert, so if you’re in the market for some dating advice to go with your matches, Amy Laurent might be a good option for you.

One potential downside to working with Amy is she's basically a one-woman show, working with up to 29 other high-paying male clients at the same time.

She also claims to have personally met and screened every woman in her NY database. Even if she's working around the clock, this could signal a limited number of matches. Clearly, there are a lot of demands on her time.

Another potential drawback is you’ve got to pay the entire $25k+ up front.

Contracts are for 12 months of service, with an additional year of “hold” time. While that gives you flexibility if you want to take a break and explore a relationship or travel, that also means you’re paying for time you may not actually need.

And what if you realize after just 1 month that Amy’s not actually going to be able to set up with the caliber of matches you were expecting? You're already locked in.

When you have an entire team of expert matchmakers working to find your ideal partner, you get results fast.

In fact, clients at VIDA Select typically meet that special someone within 3 months, sometimes even within the first few weeks.

The best part is you only commit to one month at a time, so you could try it out first before deciding to ante up a small fortune to hire an expensive celebrity matchmaker like Amy Laurent.

Why not invest 20 minutes of your time in a complimentary phone call to see if VIDA is the right matchmaking service for you? If we mutually decide we’re a good fit, you could meet your first match within days!

Learn more and schedule your confidential, risk-free consultation today!