12 Best Matchmakers For NYC Singles [2026's Top List!]

The 12 best NYC matchmakers range from $1,595/month (VIDA Select) to $1,000,000+ (Serious Matchmaking). Top-rated options include VIDA Select with 82% success rates and flexible monthly contracts, Enamour for accomplished professionals ($20,000+), and Three Day Rule for comprehensive service ($5,900+).

💡 Key Insights:

• Budget-friendly: VIDA Select (starts at $1,295/month, no long-term contract)
• Mid-range: Enamour, Amy Laurent, Agape Match ($20,000-$30,000+)
• Premium: Serious Matchmaking, Modern Love Club ($50,000-$1,000,000+)
• Most services require 6-12 month contracts with payment in full up-front

From the small boutique operators to the big industry players, we've reviewed over 200 matchmaking services. Our insight comes from 16+ years of first-hand industry experience, comprehensive research, real customer reviews, and a deep understanding of the matchmaking landscape.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 1/9/2026

VIDA Select

One of the most affordable matchmakers in NYC, VIDA Select’s modern approach to finding love may just be the easiest way to meet your perfect match. Founded by Scott Valdez in 2009, VIDA Select's team has helped thousands of singles meet their ideal partner.

Clientele

Men and women typically in their 30s to 50s.

Cost

VIDA Select's matchmaking packages start at $1,595 with no long-term commitment. The Results Guarantee Package costs $5,750, which provides 5+ curated matches you personally approve within 90 days, or the search continues at no extra cost. With an 82% success rate, most VIDA clients meet someone special in just 3 months!

What To Expect

VIDA provides a dating service tailored to fit your busy schedule.

With access to the single largest database of high-quality NYC singles, you’ll get unlimited dates with incredible matches you pre-approve. And with VIDA’s pay-as-you-go model, you’re only paying for the time you need - no long-term contract required.

 

Enamour

Enamour has been providing elite matchmaking services to accomplished and discerning NYC singles for over a decade.

Clientele

Enamour caters to relationship-minded professionals who are looking for a more bespoke matchmaking experience.

Cost

Packages begin around $20,000, with each client's membership tailored to fit their search criteria and requirements.

What To Expect

Each Enamour client is paired with a dedicated matchmaker, who will learn about their preferences and desired traits in a partner.

Using a mix of relationship psychology and advanced technology, Enamour's team carefully curates potential matches from their invite-only database, ensuring that they are highly compatible.

After each date, clients have the opportunity to provide and receive feedback, which helps the matchmaker refine their search as needed. Enamour's matchmakers work tirelessly to ensure that their clients find the perfect partner, taking into account all their unique needs and preferences.

 

Serious Matchmaking

Mother/daughter matchmaking team Janis & Carly Spindel own one of the most high-end dating services in NYC. Janis Spindel launched Serious Matchmaking back in 1993.

Clientele

Successful men seeking a long-term relationship.

Cost

Packages start at $75,000 and can run up to $1,000,000 making them one of NYC’s true millionaire matchmakers.

Serious Matchmaking clients pay a signing fee that starts at $65,000, and it’s paid up front. The same amount will also be due as a finder’s fee in the event you get engaged, move in with, or date a match for 12 months.

If you don’t want to sign a 1-year contract, you can opt for the $6,000 “Flash Match” package. This includes an introduction by Carly to 6 hand-selected women during a single evening at an upscale NYC venue.

The matchmaking process for most women differs. Women pay a one-time screening fee, typically between $250-$1250. That buys a chance to join the database of eligible singles but inclusion requires passing the interview process.

What To Expect

Potential clients meet with Janis or Carly, where they get to know you over the course of a lunch or dinner. Once you’ve selected a membership package, you’ll pay the matchmaking fee upfront and the search will begin. You can expect 12 introductions in 12 months.

Further Reading: Serious Matchmaking reviews

 

Agape Match

One of Manhattan’s most well-known boutique matchmakers, Agape Match founder Maria Avgitidis works with men as paying clients. She launched her NYC matchmaking service in 2009.

Clientele

Men in their mid 20s to mid 60s.

Cost

Matchmaking programs begin at $30,000 for 6 months and include a minimum of 6 matches. Packages can range up to $100,000.

Agape Match also offers date coaching sessions, starting around $10,000.

What To Expect

You’ll meet with Maria face to face for the initial consultation, then she’ll match you with women in their database. (Women can join her database for free, and wait to be matched with paying clients.)

When she finds someone she thinks you’ll like, you’ll receive some biographical information prior to the date they’ll arrange for you. After you provide first date feedback, they’ll arrange the second date for you.

Further Reading: Agape Match review

 

Elegant Introductions

This elite matchmaking service is helmed by former Boston residents Dr. Nancy Gold Zimmer, a licensed psychologist, and Barbara Black Goldfarb, a philanthropist and community leader. Elegant Introductions is now based in South Florida, but the two maintain a presence along the east coast, including NYC.

Clientele

Clients are typically highly educated, sophisticated professionals, and the matchmaking duo only works with a limited number of singles at a time.

Cost

Basic packages begin at $25,000 and can range over $100,000. The length of your service, number of guaranteed matches, and geographic scope of the search are some of the factors that can affect the final price tag.

What To Expect

After submitting a short online application, potential clients meet with the matchmakers. During this phase, they'll get to know you and your lifestyle, dating goals, match requirements, etc. If you're taken on as a client, you'll meet the hand-selected matches the team sources for you.

After each introduction, you can provide feedback on the match so that the search can be further tailored if needed. As a client, you'll also have access to dating coaching and styling resources.

Further Reading: Elegant Introductions review

 

Ambiance Matchmaking

Leslie Wardman’s elite matchmaking service is headquartered on the opposite coast, but has expanded from San Francisco to locations around the US - including an office in New York City. Ambiance Matchmaking was founded in 2002.

Clientele

Men and women, typically in their early 30s to early 60s.

Cost

Matchmaking service ranges from $25,000 to $100,000+. Package cost is determined in part by whether you’d like your search to be local, national, or international.

What To Expect

Ambiance Matchmaking is a boutique-style dating agency, meaning Wardman and her staff take on a limited roster of paying clients; typically 20 clients at one time.

After a successful interview, you’ll sign a contract for 12 months of matchmaking service, plus up to a year’s worth of “pause” time. Clients are typically introduced to 1 or 2 matches every month.

Potential matches are identified from among the 10,000+ singles in the Ambiance database. Each potential match is then further screened and interviewed to make sure they fit the client's "must have" criteria, and vice versa. First dates are then arranged with compatible matches.

Further Reading: Ambiance Matchmaking review

 

Modern Love Club

The self-proclaimed “coolest matchmaker in NYC”, professional matchmaker Amy Van Doran launched the boutique matchmaking service in 2008. They work with a small volume, only taking on up to 16 clients at a time. As a client of Modern Love Club, you can expect a white-glove, personalized approach to finding and attracting a secure and fulfilling romantic connection.

Clientele

Van Doran describes her clientele as "self-actualizing humans seeking a hyper-curated approach to their love life."

Cost

Curated matchmaking costs start at $70,000.

What To Expect

Potential clients book an in-depth interview and consultation about the current state of their love life and romantic history, desired search, and lifestyle. If a Modern Love Club matchmaker thinks you’re a good fit for their exclusive matchmaking service, you have the opportunity to be matched within their network of exclusive NYC singles.

Modern Love Club actively searches for impressive individuals who are open to a romantic connection and invites them to join their database.

Further Reading: Modern Love Club reviews

 

Three Day Rule

It’s headquartered in Los Angeles, but Three Day Rule is a popular professional matchmaking company in NYC too. Matchmaker Talia Goldstein launched it in 2010.

Clientele

Men and women in their mid 20s to mid 60s.

Cost

$5,900 for 3 months, during which you’ll receive at least 3 matches. $9,500 for 6 months, which includes at least 6 matches.

There's also a VIP membership option, which starts at $19,500 and includes 6 months of matchmaking services. Both of the 6-month membership options also include a professional photo shoot.

People can join the database for free, and wait to be matched with paying clients.

What To Expect

Matchmaking clients are introduced to other members in the database of local singles. Matchmakers also recruit people to join the database from places like Whole Foods and various local events.

When potential dates are located you'll check out their profiles - including pictures. If you’re interested, you’ll be given your match’s contact information, so it’s up to you to initiate contact.

Further Reading: Three Day Rule reviews

 

Amy Laurent

This executive matchmaker is bi-coastal, with offices in NYC, Los Angeles and Florida. Amy Laurent only takes on up to 30 paying clients at one time. She started her matchmaking service back in 2005.

A celebrity matchmaker of sorts, she starred in Bravo Network's reality show "Miss Advised," which chronicled the daily lives of 3 single relationship experts.

Clientele

Men seeking serious relationships.

Cost

$25,000+ for 1 year, with no guaranteed number of matches.

What To Expect

Prospective clients must first have an hour-long interview with Amy, where you’ll discuss things like what type of person you’re hoping to meet, as well as your personal relationship and dating history. If this New York matchmaker takes you on as a client, she’ll pull suitable matches from her database.

After checking out the photos and descriptions, Amy will arrange dates with any of the matches you’re interested in. You’ll be meeting people who have responded to her advertising campaigns, or whom she’s met at events around NYC and recruited.

Further Reading: Amy Laurent reviews

 

NYCity Matchmaking

Started by a lawyer turned “love headhunter/Chief Love Officer,” Michelle Frankel specializes in matching NYC singles but also works with a national and international network of matchmakers. She founded NYC Matchmaking in 2012.

Clientele

Men and women in their 20s to 60s wanting a range of relationships from dating to marriage.

Cost

The mandatory preliminary interview costs an additional $475 in person, or $350 remotely. Matchmaking package prices vary based on factors such as your search criteria and contract length.

What To Expect

This boutique matchmaker generally only takes on 10-12 clients at any one time.

After meeting with her for the initial interview, you’ll be presented with compatible matches from the free member database. The NYCity Matchmaking team also recruits singles from places like events, art openings, sports games, etc, or from Michelle’s network of affiliated matchmakers.

Further Reading: NYCity Matchmaking review

 

Lisa Ronis Matchmaking

Founded by fashion industry veteran Lisa Ronis in 2000, Lisa Ronis Matchmaking is headquartered in NYC.

Clientele

Clients are typically successful professionals in their 20s to 70s. She provides active searches for both men and women.

Cost

A 1-year matchmaking package starts at $15,000.

What To Expect

A boutique matchmaker, Ronis and her staff work with up to 100 active clients at any given time. After an initial interview, she'll find compatible matches from the Lisa Ronis Matchmaking database. You'll then meet with her to review them and decide which matches you'd like to meet.

When it comes to arranging the date, Ronis admits she's old-fashioned in that she expects the man to set it up. This is the case even when the woman is the paying client; she'll have the man make the phone call.

Ronis provides feedback after each first date, and also offers image consulting and dating coaching if needed.

Further Reading: Lisa Ronis Reviews

 

Sameera Sullivan Matchmakers

Sameera Sullivan's matchmaking service was initially called Lasting Connections back when it was founded in 2012. She has since rebranded as Sameera Sullivan Matchmakers.

Clientele

Sullivan specializes in matchmaking for high net worth individuals. A boutique-style matchmaker, she only personally works with 10 clients per year. Members of her matchmaking team each work with 8 to 10 clients at a time. The majority of clients are successful men, typically in their 40s or 50s.

Cost

$25,000 - $250,000+ for a 1-year commitment

Women can include their profile in Sullivan's database free of charge, or join her "priority paid membership registry" for $500. As a free member, you may never actually meet a paying client, as it all depends on whether or not you happen to meet someone else’s search criteria.

As a priority member there is still no guarantee of meeting anyone, but you'll have a higher chance because priority members are considered first when matching clients. Priority membership includes a 1-hour interview and a background check.

The cost of matchmaking packages for paying clients varies, as factors like dating locally versus in multiple cities and the selectivity of your search criteria factor into the cost. Memberships include an additional 6 months of "hold" time if needed.

What To Expect

Your matches will be pulled from her database of New York singles depending on which area you reside in. If you’re willing to travel, she has singles in a national database as well, so you can potentially meet people in any city you’re willing to visit.

Sullivan’s scouts also recruit women at charity galas, sporting events, coffee shops, and via their friends network. You can approve each match based on photos and detailed information. Confidentiality is of utmost importance, so information is only shared with your match after this approval. No blind dates here!

Further Reading: Sameera Sullivan reviews

With so many options available, choosing the right NYC matchmaker can feel overwhelming. The key is systematically evaluating your priorities, budget, and relationship goals against what each service actually delivers. A methodical approach to this decision can save you thousands of dollars and months of frustration while maximizing your chances of finding lasting love.

Assessing Your Priorities and Budget

Risk Tolerance: Determine whether you prefer monthly flexibility (VIDA Select) or are comfortable with substantial upfront investments for traditional elite services.

Service Expectations: Consider whether you prioritize guarantee structures, cultural specialization, celebrity access, or boutique exclusivity when comparing options.

Timeline Requirements: Evaluate whether you need proven results within 3 months (VIDA Select) or are comfortable with longer-term search processes typical of ultra-premium services.

Geographic Scope: Decide whether NYC-focused searches meet your needs or if national/international capabilities justify higher investment levels.

Due Diligence and Red Flags

Review Patterns: Analyze feedback across multiple platforms, noting both positive experiences and recurring complaints about match quality, service delivery, or value propositions.

Guarantee Specificity: Services offering measurable outcomes (VIDA Select's 90-day guarantee, Three Day Rule's 3 & 6 month guarantees) indicate accountability, while vague promises may signal potential issues.

Contract Terms: Extremely limited refund windows combined with massive upfront costs increase client risk and warrant careful consideration.

Pressure Tactics: Reputable services allow time for decision-making without aggressive sales pressure during initial consultations.

NYC's matchmaking market offers variety from flexible monthly services to ultra-exclusive annual packages. Success depends on matching your specific needs, budget, and timeline with appropriate service levels while conducting thorough due diligence on contract terms and success guarantees.