Elite Jewish Matchmakers: Find Your Soulmate with a Trusted Shadchan

The 10 best Jewish matchmakers range from $65/month (Saw You At Sinai) to $1,000,000+ (Serious Matchmaking). Top-rated services include VIDA Select for flexibility ($1,595+/month), Three Day Rule for comprehensive service ($5,900+), and J Elegant Introductions for professionals ($25,000+). Services span Orthodox to Reform Jewish singles.

Key Insights:

• Budget-friendly options: SawYouAtSinai ($25+/month), VIDA Select ($1,595+/month)
• Premium services: J Elegant Introductions, Serious Matchmaking ($25,000-$1M+)
• Orthodox-focused: SawYouAtSinai, Simantov International serve observant singles
• Success fees add costs: Many charge an additional $3,000-$65,000+ for successful matches
• Database size matters: Services with larger networks typically deliver better matches
• Professional focus: Three Day Rule and VIDA Select excel with busy professionals

From the small independent boutiques to the big industry players, our team has reviewed over 200 matchmaking services.

Our insight comes from comprehensive research, real customer reviews, and a deep understanding of the matchmaking landscape thanks to 14+ years of experience in the industry.

Finding your bashert requires more than just shared faith. The best Jewish matchmakers combine deep cultural understanding with modern relationship expertise. Whether you're Orthodox, Conservative, or Reform, the right shadchan will respect your religious boundaries while helping you navigate today's dating landscape.

Essential Qualities to Look For:

Experience and Cultural Sensitivity: Look for matchmakers who understand Jewish traditions, holidays, and family dynamics. They should respect your level of observance without judgment and know how to navigate interfaith considerations, kosher requirements, and Shabbat observances in dating scenarios.

Rigorous Screening and Confidentiality Protocols: Top Jewish matchmakers implement thorough background checks, verify relationship status, and confirm professional credentials. More importantly, they maintain strict confidentiality agreements to protect your privacy within Jewish communities. Ask about their data security measures, who has access to your profile, and how they handle discretion for high-profile clients.

Transparent Process and Pricing: The best services clearly outline their matching process, timeline expectations, and all associated costs upfront - including any success fees. Be wary of matchmakers who are vague about their methods or demand large payments without clear deliverables.

Strong Ethical Standards and Professional Practices Legitimate matchmakers belong to professional associations, maintain clear contracts, and follow industry best practices. Red flags include pressure for immediate payment, guarantees that sound too good to be true, or an unclear pricing structure. 

Ongoing Communication and Support: Premium services offer regular check-ins, dating coaching, feedback after dates, and relationship guidance throughout your journey. Your matchmaker should be responsive to concerns and willing to adjust strategies based on your experiences.

The modern Jewish matchmaking process has evolved from traditional shidduch practices while maintaining core values of compatibility and family harmony. Here's how leading services like VIDA Select structure their approach:

The 5-Step Matchmaking Process:

Step 1: Discovery & Onboarding Complete detailed questionnaires covering religious preferences, lifestyle, career goals, and family values. Personal interviews dive deeper into your relationship history and ideal partner qualities.

Step 2: Profile Creation & Matching Criteria Professional photos and compelling bios are crafted. Specific preferences for religious observance, education, and lifestyle are documented.

Step 3: Match Selection & Screening Potential matches undergo thorough screening, identifying red flags early.

Step 4: Introduction Process Matches are presented with photos and profiles for your review, and dates arranged with approved candidates.

Step 5: Coaching & Support Ongoing dating and relationship coaching covers conversation skills, date planning, and relationship progression. Feedback loops help refine future matches.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 10/30/2025

Accessible Options ($1,500-$5,000+)

VIDA Select

Scott Valdez's team has served Jewish singles since 2009 with modern matchmaking approaches. Monthly packages start at $1,595 with no long-term contracts. The 3-month guarantee package ($5,750) ensures 5+ approved matches or continued service at no cost. Success rate: 99.6% get dates, 82% begin relationships within 3 months. Learn More: The VIDA Select Difference

Fass Pass to Love

Jessica Fass operates from Tel Aviv, serving Jewish singles worldwide. Packages range from $2,500-$20,000 and include 2-hour strategy sessions, professional styling, photography, and first-date planning. Founded in 2013 with a focus on international connections. Further Reading: Fass Pass to Love reviews

Mid-Tier ($5,000-$25,000)

Three Day Rule

Founded by Jewish matchmaker Talia Goldstein, this LA-based service operates in 12 major cities. Packages start at $5,900 for 3 matches over 3 months, including professional photography and coaching sessions. Each potential match undergoes in-person screening. Further Reading: Three Day Rule reviews

Jewish Match NYC

Michelle Frankel's boutique service leverages her legal background for thorough candidate vetting. Serving NYC and New Jersey professionals aged 20-60, consultations start at $475 with customized package pricing based on search criteria. Further Reading: NYCity Matchmaking reviews

Simantov International

This London-based boutique firm has 40+ years of experience matching intelligent Jewish professionals globally. All matchmakers hold Master's degrees. Membership levels range from £250 courtesy introductions to £10,000+ premier international searches. Further Reading: Simantov International reviews

Premium Tier ($25,000+)

J Elegant Introductions

Founded by Barbara Black Goldfarb and Dr. Nancy Gold Zimmer, this South Florida-based service serves professional singles internationally. Memberships start at $25,000 and include personal meetings with founders, extensive screening, and post-date coaching. Their psychology-backed approach emphasizes quality over quantity. Further Reading: Elegant Introductions reviews 

Serious Matchmaking

Janis Spindel's elite NYC service caters to ultra-high-net-worth individuals. Packages range from $6,000 "Flash Match" events to $1,000,000 "Global VIP" searches. Known for exclusive access to successful, attractive singles in major metropolitan areas. Further Reading: Serious Matchmaking reviews

Budget-Friendly ($25-$500)

SawYouAtSinai

This online platform connects 350+ volunteer matchmakers with thousands of Jewish singles globally. Gold membership costs $10.95-$24.95 monthly. Members work with up to 2 assigned matchmakers based on location and religious orientation. Success requires payment of traditional $2,000 shadchan fee upon marriage. Further Reading: SawYouAtSinai reviews

Specialty Services

Sara's World of Jewish Singles

Jerusalem-based Sara Malamud exclusively serves North American and Canadian Jews since 2001. Focusing on 15-20 active clients, she offers Skype consultations and phone screenings before first dates. Services include ongoing coaching with annual fee structures. Further Reading: Sara's World reviews

Aleeza Ben Shalom

Netflix's "Jewish Matchmaking" star offers selective private matchmaking ($15,000-$50,000) alongside her SawYouAtSinai partnership. Based in greater Philadelphia, she serves US and Israeli clients with marriage-focused approaches. Further Reading: Aleeza Ben Shalom reviews

Traditional matchmakers offer personalized service and cultural expertise that Jewish dating apps can't match. However, the best approach often combines both strategies.

When to Choose a Matchmaker:

• You value privacy and discretion
• You're serious about marriage within 1-2 years
• You want pre-screened, high-quality matches
• You need coaching to improve dating skills
• Your career limits time for extensive searching

When Apps Work Well:

• You enjoy meeting people organically
• Budget constraints limit professional services
• You're comfortable with online dating dynamics
• You can present yourself effectively (and attractively) in your profiles and messages

The Hybrid Approach:

Many successful Jewish singles combine professional matchmaking with strategic app usage. A skilled matchmaker can help optimize your dating app profiles while providing high-quality introductions through their network.

Jewish matchmaking investments vary dramatically based on service level, market, and included features.

Typical Pricing Tiers:

Starter Level ($25-$500/month) Platform-based services with volunteer matchmakers. Limited personal attention but access to large databases.

Professional Level ($1,000-$5,000/month)
Dedicated matchmakers, customized searches, and basic coaching. Good balance of service and affordability.

Premium Level ($5,000-$25,000/package) Comprehensive services including styling, photography, and extensive vetting. Typically 3-12 month commitments.

Ultra-Luxury ($25,000-$1,000,000+) White-glove service for high-net-worth individuals. Global reach, celebrity discretion, and unlimited resources.

Hidden Costs to Consider:

• Success fees ($2,000-$65,000 for engagements)
• Additional coaching sessions
• Professional photography
• Travel for out-of-town matches
• Extended contract fees

3 Biggest Factors Impacting Costs

#1: How Your Matches Are Sourced

Generally speaking, the less work your matchmaker does to find potential matches, the less the service costs. Many traditional Jewish matchmakers make pairings from within an internal database of Jewish singles, and do little if any active scouting beyond it.

Why The Scope Of The Search Matters

If budget is a big consideration, it can be tempting to go with the cheapest option and simply meet Jewish singles sourced from a matchmaker’s internal database. 

But consider this: The size of the dating pool plays a crucial role in the quality of matches you're likely to receive. A matchmaker's job isn't just about finding singles who align with your criteria; it's also about ensuring compatibility goes both ways so a relationship will work in the long run.

And that’s where the challenge with a limited database arises. It’s nearly impossible for any matchmaker to make consistently high-quality matches from within a limited dating pool in any one location. 

The numbers required to ensure compatibility goes both ways simply aren’t there, and that’s one of the reasons why meeting singles who don’t really fit what you’re looking for is a common industry complaint. It’s not that the matchmaker is bad, it’s that she’s simply matching you with the best options drawn from the candidates she has available.

So even though investing in a service that proactively scouts beyond a database will cost more, it’s the best way to increase the odds that you’ll meet your bashert.

#2: Additional Complementary Services

Many matchmakers offer extras that are designed to enhance the matchmaking process. Options might include services designed to help you date better and boost your confidence, like dating coaching and personal styling. 

Clients may also consider services that help them make the best possible impression digitally, like professional photography, image consulting, and even social media management.

You may find that some matchmakers also take an ala carte approach to some aspects of the matchmaking process, considering some elements as “add ons” to your package. For instance, you may find with some services that seeing photos of your potential matches before agreeing to meet them costs a little extra. 

Others might have you pay extra if you want the dates arranged for you, instead of your matchmaker swapping contact information and leaving it up to you and your match to coordinate a meeting.

What’s included in your service - and what isn’t - will be spelled out in the contract you sign. It’s crucial to understand exactly what you’re getting for your investment to avoid any potential surprises or misunderstandings.

#3: Success Fees

According to the Shidduch Laws of Jewish matchmaking, it’s traditional for a couple to pay their shadchan in the event of a successful match. 

This fee varies, and it’s something that’s generally set during a discussion that includes the couple, rabbi, and matchmaker. But success fees are not exclusive to Jewish matchmaking. 

Agape Match, a NYC matchmaking service founded by Maria Avgitidis, requires some clients to pay a $5,000 success fee in addition to the $30,000+ package. 

Steve Fox, a matchmaker that’s popular with Jewish singles in South Florida, has several additional “bonus” fees built into his matchmaking contract. His services run between $5,000 and $10,000.

If you go on more than 11 dates with the same match, there’s an additional $3,000 due. Dating a match for 6 months or longer is considered an “engagement” and you’ll pay an additional $7,500.

Janis Spindel, one of New York’s most well-known millionaire matchmakers, has a signing fee that starts at $65,000. An equal amount will be due as a finder’s fee if you get engaged, move in with, or date one of your matches for 12 months. 

And that’s all in addition to the cost of your matchmaking package. Serious Matchmaking services run between $25,000 and $1,000,000.

Not all matchmakers charge an additional fee upon a successful relationship, but some do - and it’s a cost-affecting factor you’ll want to know up front.