Janis Spindel Serious Matchmaking Review: 2026 Cost & Process

Key Takeaways:

  • Every tier includes both Janis and Carly.
  • The search area sets the price: Basic covers the Tri-State area, Elite covers 2 to 3 states, VIP covers the US, and Global VIP covers the world.
  • Janis has said clients owe a finder's fee equal to their signing fee once they've been together 12 months, live together, or get engaged.
  • Contracts run 12 months, and the full membership fee is paid upfront.
  • The process starts with a screening call, then a "simulated date" with Janis or Carly, then a visit to the client's home.
  • Paying clients are mostly men. Women join the Our Love Sphere database and hear back only if they fit a client's search.
  • Most public reviews come from women in the database, so male clients' experiences are hard to verify.

If you're looking at Janis Spindel, you're past wanting more first dates. You want someone to run a serious search for you, and you're ready to invest in it.

Serious Matchmaking is one of New York's best-known high-end matchmakers, and its pricing reflects that. Before you book a consultation, it helps to know what each tier covers, how the process works, and what the contract says about success fees.

This review covers all of it, using the tiers on the company's own site, Janis and Carly's interviews, and public reviews. We're a matchmaking service ourselves, so we also show how VIDA's approach compares.

Who Are Janis and Carly Spindel?

Janis & Carly Spindel, millionaire matchmakers in NYC

Janis Spindel founded Serious Matchmaking in New York City in 1993. Before that, she was the friend who kept setting people up. After 14 of her guy friends married within eight months, she turned it into a business.

Her daughter Carly grew up in it, sitting in on her mother's interviews from age 10, and joined as a matchmaker in 2009. The two now work every membership together as a mother-daughter team. Janis's husband Allen has served as the company's COO.

Janis has appeared on Dr. Phil, The Today Show and CNN, and wrote two books: Get Serious About Getting Married and How to Date Men. Serious Matchmaking works from a New York City office, open by appointment only, and takes clients nationwide.

How Much Does Janis Spindel Serious Matchmaking Cost in 2026?

Serious Matchmaking prices each membership by how far the search reaches.

TierStarting PriceSearch Area
Basic$75,000Tri-State area (NY, NJ, CT), subject to minimum age requirements
Preferred$150,000Outside the Tri-State area
Elite$300,0002 to 3 states of your choice
VIP$600,000Anywhere in the US
Global VIP$1,000,000Worldwide

These are starting prices. The company says each membership is customized to the client. Janis has said her specialty is billionaires "who pay upward of $1.5 million dollars." Clients cover travel and lodging for the matchmaking team during the search.

Does Serious Matchmaking Charge a Success Fee?

Finder's fee (success fee): A second payment a matchmaking client owes once a relationship reaches an agreed milestone. At Serious Matchmaking, Janis has said it equals the signing fee and comes due when a couple has been together 12 months, moves in together, or gets engaged.

If that structure still holds, a $75,000 Basic membership costs $150,000 in total once you meet your partner. Ask how the finder's fee works for your tier before you sign.

How Does the Serious Matchmaking Process Work?

  1. Book a screening call with one of the Spindels' assistants.
  2. Meet Janis or Carly for a "simulated date," usually over lunch or dinner, so they can see how you date and learn what you want.
  3. Host a home visit. Janis has said they "look inside the drawers, the fridge, the closets," because a home shows who a person really is.
  4. Customize your membership and sign a 12-month contract, paid in full upfront. You can cancel within 3 business days. After that, refunds typically aren't offered.
  5. Meet your first introductions. Clients typically see a couple of matches in the first two weeks.
  6. Debrief after the first two or three dates. If none click, Janis talks with the client directly about what he's looking for.
  7. Pause when you meet someone. Memberships include up to a year of hold time.

Serious Matchmaking doesn't guarantee results. In Janis's words in an interview with Natfluence, "you can't put a guarantee on feelings."

How Do Women Join Janis Spindel's Our Love Sphere?

Women don't buy a membership. They apply to Our Love Sphere, the Spindels' database of women considered as matches for paying clients, and pay for an in-person interview.

Meeting OptionPrice
Small group meeting with Janis & Carly$500
Private meeting with Carly$1,000
Private meeting with Janis$1,500
30-minute private meeting with Janis & Carly$2,200
60-minute private meeting with Janis & Carly$4,000

The Spindels contact a woman only if she fits what a current client is looking for, and the site says there's no guarantee of a match. Members stay in the database indefinitely.

What Do Serious Matchmaking Reviews Say?

Most public reviews of Serious Matchmaking come from women in the database or at its events, not from paying clients. Many of them enjoyed working with Janis and Carly personally. Others joined the database and never heard about a match.

Reviews from male clients are rare. One man on Yelp questioned an $80,000 quote and asked why so few men had posted reviews. Janis replied that "The men are extremely private and they are the clients."

That leaves your consultation as the best source on client results. Ask how many introductions to expect, how the finder's fee is triggered, and what happens if you pause.

Is Janis Spindel the Right Matchmaker for You?

Serious Matchmaking fits men who want a hands-on, personality-driven executive matchmaking firm and are comfortable with a large upfront investment. It suits you best if you:

  • Can commit $75,000 or more upfront, plus a possible finder's fee
  • Want matchmakers who meet you in person and visit your home
  • Are ready to sign a 12-month contract
  • Need a search that reaches beyond your city, nationally or worldwide

Weigh the total cost carefully. With the finder's fee, the price can double, and there are few male client reviews to check results against.

Janis Spindel vs VIDA Select: How Do They Compare?

 Janis Spindel Serious MatchmakingVIDA Select
Starting price$75,000 per membership$1,695/month
PaymentFull fee upfrontMonthly or by package
Contract12 monthsNo long-term contract required
Success feeEqual to the signing fee, per JanisNone
Who the client isMostly menMen and women
How matches are foundThe Spindels' database plus in-person scoutingA dedicated matchmaker searching across multiple channels, including an internal database and proactive scouting

VIDA Select is a modern matchmaking service for accomplished professionals. A dedicated matchmaker sources and screens every candidate, and you approve each introduction before meeting. 82% of VIDA clients meet someone special within 90 days.

See if VIDA is right for your search.

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Janis Spindel cost?

Serious Matchmaking memberships start at $75,000 (Basic, Tri-State area) and run to $1,000,000 (Global VIP, worldwide). Preferred starts at $150,000, Elite at $300,000 and VIP at $600,000.

What is Janis Spindel's success fee?

Janis has said clients owe a finder's fee equal to their signing fee once they've been with a match for 12 months, live together, or get engaged.

Can women work with Janis Spindel?

Women apply to the Our Love Sphere database and pay for an interview meeting, from $500 for a small group meeting to $4,000 for a 60-minute private meeting with both matchmakers. They're contacted only if they fit a client's search.

How long is a Serious Matchmaking contract?

Contracts run 12 months and are paid in full upfront, with up to a year of hold time if you meet someone.

Who is Carly Spindel?

Carly is Janis's daughter. She joined Serious Matchmaking as a matchmaker in 2009 and works every membership alongside her mother.

How long has Janis Spindel been matchmaking?

Janis founded Serious Matchmaking in New York City in 1993.