Latter Day Matchmaker Reviews [Best LDS Dating Service?]

Amy Stevens Seal's Latter Day Matchmaker charges $10,000+ for VIP matchmaking serving the LDS community across Utah, Idaho, and nationwide. With 4.4 Google stars (25+ reviews) and free database membership for women, this faith-focused service emphasizes core Mormon values in compatibility assessment.

Key Insights: What You Need to Know

• VIP pricing: Starts at $10,000+ for men with personal service from Amy Stevens Seal including date planning, coaching, and image consulting
• Women join free: "Matchmable Member" database inclusion at no cost, though matching with paying clients isn't guaranteed
• Service area: Headquartered in Sandy, Utah, serving LDS singles in Utah, Idaho, and nationwide
• Faith requirements: Transparent LDS standing required; compatibility assessed on core Mormon principles
• Client reviews: 4.4-star Google rating from 25+ reviews showing mostly positive experiences with some inclusivity concerns
• Match sources: Little Black Book database plus nationwide recruiting on behalf of VIP clients
• Additional services: Dating coaching ($27-$97/month), online dating makeovers ($5,000+), styling packages ($1,500-$2,500)
• Founded: 2010 by Amy Stevens Seal (formerly "The LDS Matchmaker"), combining corporate recruiting expertise with personal experience
• Common praise: Professional team, improved dating skills, successful matches including marriages

Our team has reviewed over 200 matchmaking services, exploring their processes, client experiences, cost, and more. Our reviews draw from over 15 years of firsthand industry experience and a deep understanding of the matchmaking landscape.

Understanding Amy Stevens Seal's journey and approach helps you determine if this faith-based service aligns with your values and dating goals.

From Corporate Recruiting to LDS Matchmaking

Catering primarily to the Latter-day Saints community, Latter Day Matchmaker is headquartered in Sandy, Utah. The company was formerly known as "The LDS Matchmaker" when Amy Stevens Seal founded it in 2010.

Seal's foray into matchmaking was inspired by a combination of personal experiences and a successful career as a corporate recruiter.

After overcoming the hurdles of being married and subsequently divorced in her twenties, Seal gained a richer understanding of the challenges singles face. Seeing an opportunity to utilize her professional and personal insights in a novel way, she decided to apply her corporate recruiting expertise to matchmaking—treating the search for compatible partners with the same strategic approach as talent acquisition.

Addressing a Unique LDS Dating Challenge

This boutique matchmaking service has carved out a specialty niche for itself, helping singles navigate the LDS dating scene in Utah, Idaho, and beyond. As a former employee shared in an interview, 

“Young marriages are very prevalent in LDS culture, and people can feel isolated if they’re not part of that trend, but we take the work and worry out of dating so our clients feel excited again.

This insight speaks to a specific pain point in Mormon culture—where marrying young is common, leaving older singles feeling left behind or pressured.

Media Recognition

Latter Day Matchmaker was even featured in an episode of "Mormon Half Love," a reality show on TLC that follows the life of a single woman in Cedar Valley who is "living with a physical disability, and looking for a partner." This visibility demonstrates the service's commitment to serving diverse members of the LDS community.

The process differs significantly for men and women, reflecting the service's business model where men pay for active searches while women populate the database.

For Women: Free Database Inclusion

The first step for women is to complete an online profile in their system. This means you'll be included in their "Little Black Book" database and potentially be matched with paying male clients if your preferences align.

Important Caveat: There's no guarantee you'll ever meet anyone this way. Your profile sits passively in the database until a VIP male client's criteria happen to match yours—and you also need to match what he's seeking.

For Men: VIP Matchmaking Packages

Men can purchase "VIP" matchmaking packages, provided they pass the screening process. That starts with scheduling a Dating Strategy Session with a Latter Day Matchmaker relationship coach.

VIP Client Experience: VIP clients work personally with Amy Stevens Seal. Services include:

• Personal matchmaking with Seal herself
• Date planning and coordination
• One-on-one coaching sessions
• Image consulting
• Access to the online learning system, Lasting Love Academy

The Matchmaking Philosophy

Seal explained in an interview that matchmaking is like tapping into a hidden dating market. In her own words:

"We are facilitating matches, and so it's really quite fun, being a matchmaker and being able to see these clients' hearts and really understand them."

Faith-Based Compatibility Assessment

All applicants and clients are expected to be transparent about their standing in the LDS faith. Core Mormon principles play an essential role in assessing compatibility, according to Seal. She emphasized the importance of finding a partner who exhibits certain traits in an interview:

"We teach our clients to look for empathy, personal responsibility, and self-control, as like the heart of the things that will really create a lasting relationship and a healthy relationship."

This values-first approach distinguishes faith-based matchmaking from services focused primarily on superficial characteristics.

Match Sourcing Strategy

Potential matches are sourced through multiple channels:

1. Little Black Book Database: Free female members who've completed profiles
2. Nationwide Recruiting: Active scouting conducted on behalf of VIP clients beyond the database
3. Events: Speed dating gatherings and coaching sessions where singles can meet

This dual approach (database + recruiting) provides VIP clients with more options than database-only services, though the recruiting extent isn't specified.

Latter Day Matchmaker offers tiered services at various price points to accommodate different needs and budgets.

VIP Matchmaking Packages

Prices for VIP matchmaking start at $10,000 and go up from there, depending on the services you'd like included. All options can be discussed during your initial consultation.

VIP packages include:

• Personal matchmaking with Amy Stevens Seal
• Date planning and coordination
• Image consulting
• Coaching sessions
• Access to Lasting Love Academy

The final investment depends on:

• Length of service commitment
• Whether nationwide recruiting is included
• Level of coaching and consulting desired
• Additional services bundled into your package

For Women: Free Matchmable Membership

Joining the database as a "Matchmable Member" is free. You'll be considered as a potential date for paying male clients, but there is no guarantee you'll ever meet anyone this way.

This model is common among matchmaking services targeting successful men—women populate the database at no cost while men fund the operation.

À La Carte Services

Beyond full VIP matchmaking, Latter Day Matchmaker offers several standalone services:

Dating and Relationship Coaching:

• Lasting Love Academy membership: $27 to $97 per month
• Online learning system with courses and resources

Online Dating Makeovers:

• Plans begin at $5,000
• Includes profile optimization and dating coaching

Styling Packages:

• Range from $1,500 to $2,500
• Varies based on services included (wardrobe consulting, personal shopping, etc.)

These options allow clients to access specific support without committing to full matchmaking packages.

Review analysis from available platforms shows predominantly positive feedback with some notable concerns about inclusivity.

Google Reviews: 4.4 Stars from 25+ Reviews

This LDS matchmaking service has a 4.4 rating on their Google business page based on 25+ reviews, indicating generally satisfied clients.

Positive Experiences - Improved Dating Life

Success Stories - Finding Spouses

Multiple reviewers reported finding their spouses through Latter Day Matchmaker:

Negative Reviews - Inclusivity Concerns

On the opposite end of the star ratings, there were a handful of 1-star Latter Day Matchmaker reviews.

One reviewer felt the matchmaking service wasn't inclusive enough, suggesting the service may have limitations in serving certain demographics within the LDS community.

Dissatisfied Client Experience

One former client wasn't happy with his experience, though specific details about the nature of his dissatisfaction weren't elaborated in the review.

There was another 1-star Latter Day Matchmaker review from someone who also thought the service was “a total ripoff”, however according to the company’s response their records show no client by the name used on the review.

Limited Review Coverage

Latter Day Matchmaker has not yet been reviewed on platforms like Trustpilot or Better Business Bureau. This limited review presence makes it more challenging to assess overall satisfaction patterns compared to services with hundreds of reviews across multiple platforms.

Several factors beyond reviews should inform your decision about whether Latter Day Matchmaker meets your needs.

Using Reviews Strategically

Online reviews can help spark insightful questions to ask during your initial consultation, as they give you a peek at what former customers experienced. But ultimately, deciding which Utah matchmaking service to hire will likely boil down to factors like cost, contract terms, and the vibe you get from your initial consultation.

Understanding Contract Commitments

Long-term contracts are the norm for most matchmaking services, with commitments often spanning 3 months to 1 year or even longer. Generally, the entire package price is paid upfront, before the search for your ideal partner gets underway.

Important Consideration: With a $10,000+ investment paid upfront, you'll want absolute clarity on:

• Guaranteed number of introductions
• Contract length and hold time provisions
• Refund or cancellation policies
• What happens if you're unsatisfied with match quality

The Faith-Based Service Decision

Latter Day Matchmaker's explicit LDS focus makes it ideal for singles who:

• Prioritize faith compatibility as the foundation of relationships
• Want a matchmaker who understands Mormon culture and values
• Seek partners who share commitment to LDS principles
• Appreciate assessment based on empathy, personal responsibility, and self-control

However, some reviews mention inclusivity concerns, so it's worth clarifying during consultation how the service approaches:

• Singles with diverse backgrounds within the LDS community
• Those who may not fit traditional Mormon profiles
• Divorced individuals or those with complex faith journeys

Alternative Approaches for LDS Singles

If you're interested in exploring other options for LDS matchmaking:

VIDA Select offers matchmaking packages on a pay-as-you-go basis. Instead of a long-term contract with upfront payment, clients simply purchase service one month at a time.

Key Advantages:

• No long-term financial commitment
• Pay only for active search months
• Stop if you meet someone special or want to take a break
• Average client meets someone within 3 months

The cost of each package highly aligns with the number of hours your personal matchmaker devotes to the search for your ideal partner. While not exclusively LDS-focused, VIDA can accommodate faith-based preferences in matching criteria.