Top Utah Matchmaker Services [Which One Is Best For You?]

The 2 best Utah matchmakers range from $1,595/month (VIDA Select) to $5,000/month (Latter-Day Matchmaker VIP). VIDA Select offers month-to-month flexibility for all singles with 11-date average to connection, while Latter-Day Matchmaker exclusively serves LDS singles with faith-focused matching.

Key Insights: What You Need to Know

• Budget-friendly option: VIDA Select ($1,595+/month, no long-term contract)
• LDS-exclusive service: Latter-Day Matchmaker ($3,250-$5,000/month for active matching, free database membership)
• Contract flexibility: VIDA Select offers pay-as-you-go monthly packages without commitment
• Average results: 82% of VIDA clients meet someone special within 90 days
• Faith-based focus: Latter-Day Matchmaker serves exclusively Latter-day Saint singles from Utah, Idaho, and worldwide
• Match sourcing: VIDA accesses Utah's largest pool of singles; Latter-Day uses internal database plus VIP-level nationwide scouting
• Service tiers: Multiple package levels available from both services based on search scope and support needed
• Founded: VIDA Select (2009), Latter-Day Matchmaker (2010, formerly "The LDS Matchmaker")

Disclaimer: This guide was researched and written by VIDA Select's editorial team to help singles find the service that best fits their needs and goals. As a matchmaking service ourselves, we bring a unique industry perspective. Our insights come from 17+ years of matchmaking experience, writing 200+ matchmaking service reviews, analyzing public information and reviews on reputable platforms, and feedback from clients who used other services before hiring VIDA. While this guide is updated regularly, it may not reflect current pricing for all services.

Here are the 2 best Utah matchmaking options.

VIDA Select (by Scott Valdez)

The perfect choice for Salt Lake City singles looking to meet someone incredible, VIDA Select’s team of matchmakers uses a powerful combination of technology and intuition to find your ideal partner.

Clientele

VIDA clients are typically in their late 20s to 60s, successful, and committed to finding a serious relationship. 

Cost & Contract

Monthly matchmaking service starts at $1,595. There is also a 90-day "Match Guarantee" package that includes at least 5 curated matches you personally approve for $5,750. Guaranteed results, or your search continues at no additional cost. 

82% of clients meet someone special within just 3 months.

What To Expect

The road to finally meeting your perfect match starts with a quick screening process to ensure you’re a good fit for VIDA’s services. 

Then, you’ll have an in-depth consultation with your personal matchmaker. She’ll learn all about you, your lifestyle, and, of course, everything you’re looking for in an ideal partner. 

VIDA is a traditional matchmaking service in that you’ll get to review a full profile of all the candidates identified as a potential match. That means you can look forward to first dates with amazing people who check all your compatibility boxes.

But unlike traditional matchmakers, VIDA Select isn’t limited to an internal database. You’ll be meeting highly compatible matches pulled from Utah’s largest source of eligible singles - and the pool is nearly limitless!

You can also benefit from VIDA’s comprehensive dating coaching, image consulting, pro photography and more. 

On average, a client “clicks” with someone incredible after just 11 dates - so what are you waiting for? Go here to see if you qualify!

Founded In

2009

Latter-Day Matchmaker (by Amy Stevens Seal)

Amy Stevens Seal’s LDS matchmaking service made headlines around the US back in 2019 when it rented billboard space advertising a VIP mixer event for an anonymous millionaire client hoping to meet his future wife.

Prior to matchmaking, she was an employment recruiter for 15+ years. When it first launched, Latter-Day Matchmaker was called “The LDS Matchmaker” and later rebranded to reflect the Church’s preferred terminology for its members.

Clientele 

Latter-Day Matchmaker works exclusively with Latter-day Saint singles from Utah, Idaho, and all over the world who are seeking a serious relationship with someone who shares their faith. 

Cost & Contract

Joining the database of LDS singles these SLC matchmakers use to pair clients is free.

At the “Online Concierge” level, your matchmaker selects compatible profiles from the database and exchanges contact information if there is mutual interest. It costs $3,250 per month for both men and women, and includes perks like dating coaching. 

The “Online Matchmaking” level is for women, and costs $4,000 per month. In addition to selecting compatible profiles from the database, your matchmaker also conducts more in-depth screening and arranges dates.

The “VIP Matchmaking” level costs $5,000 per month, and is for men. It includes both matching with singles in the database as well as personalized scouting for potential matches nationwide.

All levels include access to members-only events.

What To Expect 

Whether you’re interested in personal matchmaking or just joining the database as a Matchmable Member, the first step is filling out the online profile. If you sign up as a paying client, your matchmaker helps you identify 10 to 15 traits you’re looking for in an ideal partner. 

She then consults the database and selects a pool of compatible potential matches, then screens that shortlist. If you opted for the VIP package, the Latter-Day Matchmaker team scouts outside of Utah as well.

Stevens Seal combines ongoing dating coaching with matchmaking, and offers practice dates with employees so clients can get feedback on how they present themselves in social situations. 

Founded In

2010

Further Reading

Latter Day Matchmaker review

When it comes to hiring a matchmaker, there's good news and bad news.

The good news is you're not lacking for choice. From Salt Lake City matchmakers to Southwest services to national agencies who can help singles living just about everywhere, there are plenty of dating services out there.

Now the bad news: The quality of the service you'll receive varies wildly. Unfortunately, some matchmaking services have their hearts set on your wallet and not much else.

You're savvy enough to be looking for matchmaking reviews, so here are two ways you can get the most out of what you find.

Tip #1: Look at More Than Just the Numbers

A star or numerical rating is helpful. But seeing how (and if) a representative from the matchmaking service responds to the review can be even more valuable.

That peek behind the curtain can provide a goldmine of information, and sometimes even a glimpse at some of the language that's included in the contract if the service requires a long-term commitment.

You can also see if any specific complaints trend across multiple review platforms.

Example Pattern Recognition: Consider these three reviews of a Salt Lake City matchmaker not included in this article. All three clients complained about not having a consistent point of contact—highlighted in their reviews as a recurring frustration.

What This Tells You: This pattern reveals a systematic issue with customer service structure rather than isolated incidents. You can use this intel to formulate better questions during your consultation.

For example, consider these three reviews of a Salt Lake City matchmaker not included in this article.

Utah Matchmaker Review Example #1:

Utah Matchmaker Review Example #2:

Utah Matchmaker Review Example #3:

As you can see from the highlighted portions, these 3 clients all complained about not having a consistent point of contact.

You can use that intel to...

#2: Formulate Insightful Questions

Building on the examples above, if having a dedicated personal matchmaker is important to you, you’d definitely want to ask about that aspect of customer service during your initial consultation with that particular Utah matchmaker.

Some people may not mind explaining who they are and what they're looking for every time they call in. But others may find it a lot more convenient to work with the same matchmaker throughout the process so she's already familiar with you and your matching criteria.

Strategic Approach: Take notes on anything in the reviews you want clarified, and ask direct questions during your initial consultation.

That phone or video call shouldn't be a one-way street where the company learns more about you. It should be an exchange of information, where you're learning about their approach to matchmaking as well.

Essential Questions to Ask

About the Process:

• Will I have a dedicated matchmaker throughout my membership?
• How many active clients does my matchmaker work with at one time?
• Where do my matches come from—database only or active recruitment?
• How many introductions are guaranteed in my package?

About Results:

• What's your average client success rate?
• How long does it typically take for clients to meet someone?
• What happens if I'm not satisfied with match quality?

About the Contract:

• What's your refund and cancellation policy?
• Can I pause my membership if needed?
• Are there any hidden fees beyond the package price?
• What happens if I don't receive my guaranteed matches?

About Match Quality:

• How do you vet matches before presenting them to me?
• Do I get to approve matches before dates are arranged?
• What criteria do you use to determine compatibility?

There are no "correct" answers—it all boils down to what you're comfortable with. The key is getting clear, direct responses that help you make an informed decision.