Can My Top Matchmaker Find Your Perfect Match? [2026 Reviews!]

My Top Matchmaker was a Sarasota-based matchmaking service founded by Mimi Lee, specializing in Florida singles in their mid-40s and older. Services started around $5,000 for a set number of dates, with an A+ BBB rating and 4.8 stars on Google before closing. While MTM is no longer operating, this review offers valuable insights on what to look for when evaluating any matchmaking service.

Key Insights

• Status: Permanently closed according to Google business profile
• Founder: Mimi Lee, who previously worked for Patti Stanger's millionaire matchmaking service
• Locations: Sarasota headquarters with a Naples office
• Specialization: Florida singles in their mid-40s and older, many divorced or widowed
• Cost: Started around $5,000, increasing based on number of dates desired
• Database size: 1,200+ clients in internal roster
• Screening requirements: Background check, identity verification, and five-panel drug test via oral swab
• Reviews before closure: A+ BBB rating, 4.8/5 stars on Google (40+ reviews)

Our team has reviewed over 200 matchmaking services with 14+ years of industry experience. While MTM is no longer an option, this review highlights important questions to ask any matchmaker you're considering. Then, check out these top matchmaking services for Florida singles!

Mimi Lee was born in SWFL, and MyTopMatchmaker is based in Sarasota with an office in Naples as well. But Lee actually debuted as a matchmaker on the West Coast in the late 1990s, working for millionaire matchmaker Patti Stanger. 

As she told Gulfshore Life, Mimi founded MyTopMatchmaker about 15 years later, bringing her matchmaking service back to her Florida roots.

She credits her intuition for her success at matching up clients, and says she takes the “opposites attract” approach. 

It's friction that causes the flames to ignite; let me hear your story, your character, your passion, and ambitions, as for your hobbies.... well, hobbies are nice.... but I'm always on the hunt for the elixir of spice!

So that’s the theory behind her matchmaking service… Now let’s take a look at how it works in practice!

Lee specialized in helping Florida singles in their mid 40s+, helping those living in cities like Cape Coral as well. She described her typical clientele to Sarasota Magazine, saying:

A lot of them have already been married and they haven’t dated in 20 years or are widowed after being married 50 years or more. I help them get started and feel comfortable about going out.

The process:

1. Free initial consultation covering service details, costs, and contract terms
2. Screening process including identity verification, background check, and drug test
3. Approximately 75% of applicants were accepted
4. In-depth interview lasting at least 2.5 hours with Lee or her team
5. Matches made from internal database of 1,200+ clients
6. First date details arranged once mutual interest was confirmed

Lee emphasized her hands-on approach, stating on her website: "We pride ourselves on not using a computer program to predict a date; our work is all hand crafted."

In an interview with Coastal Breeze News, Lee shared that she’s good at “coaxing out” all the details that will help her make good matches. She said it really all comes down to one factor…

In figuring out who I match as a pair, it always comes down to one thing that I trust more than anything else, and that’s my opinion.

Like most matchmaking services, MTM didn't publish prices online. Based on reviews, services started around $5,000 and increased depending on how many dates you wanted.

Clients paid for a specified number of dates rather than a set length of time—a structure some found appealing because it tied cost directly to introductions received.

Before closing, My Top Matchmaker had generally positive reviews online.

My Top Matchmaker has an A+ rating with the BBB, with no reviews or complaints as of yet.

On Google, the dating service has 4.8/5 stars, based on 40+ reviews. 

This reviewer liked that you paid for a specified number of dates, rather than a set length of time. She also thought not seeing a photo of her match before the first date made the process exciting and allowed her to keep an open mind:

This reviewer said he met many interesting women through the service, and that it was the best option for anyone who has the resources:

Most of the Google reviews were 4 or 5-stars; only 2 were 1-star. Both had to do with the cost, although it was unclear if they were from actual or potential clients:

Google seems to be the main place where you’ll find MyTopMatchmaker reviews, as Mimi Lee has yet to be reviewed on other platforms like Yelp or TrustPilot.

While My Top Matchmaker is no longer operating, the reviews highlight important questions to ask any matchmaking service you're considering.

Let’s take a look at 3 excerpts from the reviews shown earlier.

Will You See Photos Before Agreeing to Dates?

One MTM reviewer mentioned that not seeing photos beforehand made the process "exciting" and helped her keep an open mind. But for many people, physical attraction is a key component of chemistry.

Some matchmaking services let clients approve or pass on matches based on full profiles with photos. Others take the blind date route, or charge more for the tier that includes photos.

Traditional matchmakers working from limited databases often don't reveal photos—sometimes because they genuinely want you to give compatible matches a chance, but sometimes because they don't have many options and don't want to give you reasons to pass.

Question to ask: Can I see photos and a full profile before agreeing to meet someone?

How Is Pricing Structured?

MTM clients paid for a set number of dates rather than a defined time period. Other services work differently:

• Some commit you to 6, 12, or 24 months regardless of how quickly you find someone
• Some charge per introduction
• Some offer month-to-month service you can pause or stop anytime

Question to ask: Am I paying for a time period, a number of dates, or month-to-month service? What happens if I meet someone right away—or if it takes longer than expected?

Where Do Matches Come From?

MTM matched clients with other clients from their internal database of 1,200+ people. This is common among boutique matchmakers, but it creates an inherent limitation.

If your ideal match didn't happen to sign up for the same service, you won't meet them. And with a limited pool, matchmakers may pair you with people who don't truly fit your criteria simply because options are scarce.

Question to ask: Where do you find my matches? Is it only from clients who've paid for your service, or do you recruit beyond your internal database?

Since My Top Matchmaker is no longer operating, here is the best alternative for Florida singles:

VIDA Select

VIDA Select takes a modern approach to matchmaking, accessing Florida's largest pool of eligible singles rather than relying on a limited client roster. This means you're not hoping your soulmate happened to sign up for the same service.

Key advantages:

• See before you meet: Review full profiles with photos and approve or pass on every match
• Month-to-month service: No long-term contracts; pause or stop anytime
• Unlimited matches: No cap on introductions
• Transparent pricing: Monthly service starts at $1,595.

Most VIDA clients meet someone special within the first few months of service. Schedule your complimentary consultation today.