Sarasota Singles Reviews [Legit Florida Matchmaking Service?]

Sarasota Singles is owned by Romance Pros International, an Oklahoma-based company operating 100+ similarly branded matchmaking websites across the US and Canada. Costs range from $1,000 to $7,000 based on BBB reviews, with no refunds after 3 business days. Customer feedback is split: 4.5 stars on Google but a D rating with the Better Business Bureau, where common complaints include low match quality and unmet expectations from the sales pitch.

Key Insights

• Not locally owned: Sarasota Singles is operated by Romance Pros International out of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma—not a local Sarasota company

• Part of a large network: The parent company owns 100+ similar "local" matchmaking sites across the US and Canada, including Tampa Singles, Naples Singles, and DC Singles

• Cost range: $1,000 to $7,000 according to BBB reviews; pricing may be influenced by your financial situation and is negotiable

• Contract terms: No refunds after 3 business days; no guarantees on match frequency, timeline, or criteria alignment

• No photos provided: You receive basic background information on matches but won't see photos before meeting

• Mixed reviews: 4.5 stars on Google, 1 star on Yelp, D rating on BBB with 31 complaints

• Data sharing: Signing up grants permission to share your contact information with third-party service providers

We've reviewed over 200 matchmaking services with 14+ years of industry experience. Here's what you need to know before signing a contract with Sarasota Singles.

You may have noticed there’s no local address for Sarasota Singles on the website. That’s because they’re owned by a national company that’s based out of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma.

According to a WINK news investigation, Romance Pros International also owns Naples Singles, Tampa Singles and DC Singles.

The owner of Romance Pros, William Broadbent, has quite a few other matchmaking services under his ownership as well, according to the Better Business Bureau:

It’s actually a longer list than that - there are at least 100 similar websites in the US and Canada.

That being said, you’ll be matched with singles in Sarasota - but it may not be by a local matchmaker.

Getting started requires either calling the number on their website or filling out a contact form with basic information.

Important privacy note: Clicking the green “Complete” button also grants them permission to share your personal contact information with third party service providers, as outlined in the Privacy Policy you probably didn’t read:

According to their Privacy Policy, this exempts Sarasota Singles (and those third parties) from the Do Not Call list and may result in increased personalized ads on social media. You may also be contacted by other direct marketing services—suggesting the parent company sells user data.

After submitting your information, you'll have the option to fill out a questionnaire about your background, relationship history, and goals. You can also wait and discuss these details directly with a matchmaker when they contact you.

The matchmaker will arrange an in-person meeting. This consultation is when you'll finally learn about cost, the matching process, and contract terms—none of which are listed on the website.

Once you sign a contract, you'll be matched with other singles in their database. You'll receive contact information and basic background details to arrange meetings, but you won't see photos of your matches beforehand.

According to some of the reviews you’ll read in just a bit, Sarasota Singles is somewhat flexible when it comes to the final price tag. But being open to negotiation also means you're likely to experience some very persuasive sales pitches.

You may also find the price is affected by factors like your credit limit/score and your present financial state. Customers reported spending between $1,000 and $7,000 in Sarasota Singles BBB reviews.

Once the cost is settled, you’ll sign a contract for the matchmaking services. Make sure you fully understand everything that’s put on paper, as that’s what will end up being legally binding.

Sarasota Singles won’t provide a refund after 3 business days. Being on the same page before picking up the pen is essential.

As the matchmaking service explained in this response to a BBB complaint, there are no guarantees when it comes to the frequency and time frame of the referrals. And they may not match your criteria:

When it comes to Google reviews for Sarasota Singles, the news is good - they have a 4.0 star rating.

This customer was happy to find her soulmate via the Sarasota dating service:

These two customers also met someone special:

This customer thought the match quality could improve but was otherwise satisfied:

This customer, on the other hand, wasn’t happy with the matchmaking and gave them only 1 star:

Sarasota Singles Yelp Reviews

But when it comes to Yelp, the news isn’t as good. This Florida dating service only has a 1-star rating, based on 4 currently recommended Sarasota Singles reviews.

This reviewer likened the initial consultation to buying a used car, and ended up leaving without signing up:

This customer signed up after being reassured there were plenty of compatible people in the local singles database for him to meet. But that didn’t end up being the case:

The one not currently recommended review was from someone who thought her matches were low quality. She didn’t think they meshed with the criteria she provided during her initial consultation:

Sarasota Singles BBB Reviews

The Better Business Bureau combined Sarasota Singles with Tampa Singles and Naples Singles, since they’re all owned by the same company.

They have an overall “F” rating, 4 negative reviews, and a total of 31 complaints.

Many of the Sarasota Singles complaints had to do with the quality of the matches, like this one:

This customer also felt her matches were low quality, and wasn’t happy with the customer service either:

This customer reported difficulty reaching her matchmaker. She was also unhappy with the quality of matches she received (review edited for length):

Sarasota Singles also had numerous negative reviews on Pissed Consumer.

Common complaints being lack of matches, low quality matches, and promises made during the sales pitch that never came to fruition:

Given the mixed reviews and non-refundable contract structure, ask these questions during your consultation:

1. How many active members are in the Sarasota database who match my criteria?

2. How many matches can I expect, and over what timeframe?

3. What happens if I'm not satisfied with match quality?

4. Who specifically will be my matchmaker, and how do I reach them?

5. Can I see the full contract terms before the consultation ends?

6. What's included versus what costs extra?

Trust your instincts. If the consultation feels high-pressure or your questions aren't answered clearly, that's valuable information.

If you're uncomfortable with blind dates, non-refundable contracts, or not seeing photos before meeting matches, consider alternatives with different structures.

VIDA Select

VIDA Select offers month-to-month matchmaking with no long-term contracts. You see a full profile—including photos—of every potential match before agreeing to meet them, and you can approve or decline each introduction.

Key differences from Sarasota Singles:

• No long-term contracts: Pay-as-you-go monthly structure; pause or stop anytime

• See photos first: Review full profiles before agreeing to any date

• Unlimited matches: No cap on introductions

• Transparent pricing: Monthly service starts at $1,595

Most VIDA clients meet someone special within the first few months of service.

Schedule a free, confidential 20-minute consultation to learn more.