Matchmaker Of Maine Review: Is Ron Cater Legit?

The Matchmaker of Maine charges $1,000+ for 3 months to $2,000+ for longer memberships (negotiable with price match guarantee) serving New England singles aged 30-60, founded by industry veteran Ron Cater in 1997 with 4.4-star Google rating (predominantly positive), A+ BBB rating (4 reviews, 4 stars), and 1-star Yelp rating (2 reviews).

Using personality testing and compatibility assessments, Cater targets emotionally ready professionals with college degrees and non-smoking preference, matching from internal database after 40-minute consultations focusing on realistic expectations.

Key Takeaways:

• Estimated pricing range: The Matchmaker of Maine charges $1,000+ for 3-month memberships to $2,000+ for longer terms based on online reviews, with pricing discussed during consultations and price match guarantee offered to meet or beat some competitors
• Industry veteran founder: Ron Cater founded The Matchmaker of Maine in 1997 after launching Successful Singles in Boston in 1984, bringing 30+ years matchmaking experience with "worked out all the kinks" system
• Target demographic specificity: Service targets professionals aged 30-60 (ideal clients 40+) with college degrees who are non-smokers, focusing on emotionally ready singles with realistic expectations
• Personality-driven process: Matchmaking utilizes detailed compatibility assessments and personality tests to understand characteristics and qualities clients seek, with 40-minute personal consultations for fit evaluation
• Selective client acceptance: Cater doesn't accept everyone, prioritizing "emotionally ready, emotionally available" singles with realistic match criteria rather than taking all interested applicants
• Mixed review patterns: 4.4-star Google rating with predominantly positive feedback (successful matches, personalized attention), A+ BBB rating with 4-star reviews, but 1-star Yelp rating from 2 dissatisfied clients citing match quality/quantity issues
• New England regional focus: Based in Maine with primary location serving entire New England area, complementing Cater's Boston-based Successful Singles with locations across Massachusetts and New Hampshire
• Traditional database approach: Matches clients from internal database using personality tests and compatibility assessments, with potential mutual compatibility challenges common to limited-pool services

Wondering whether The Matchmaker of Maine can help you connect with someone special? With an abundance of Maine matchmakers to choose from, deciding on the right one can feel overwhelming.  

Not to worry, this Matchmaker of Maine review has all the information you need to help you decide if Ron Cater and his team are the best matchmaking service for you. 

Our team has reviewed 200+ matchmakers, digging deep into their processes, customer experiences, and success rates. Our reviews are built on extensive research and a keen understanding of the matchmaking industry.

Ron Cater, founder of The Matchmaker of Maine, is an industry veteran. 

Before establishing The Matchmaker of Maine, Cater launched his first matchmaking company, Successful Singles, in 1984. Based in Boston, Successful Singles has locations across Massachusetts and New Hampshire.

But Cater's initial foray into the matchmaking world began while he was attending dental school. A conversation with a friend who was already involved in the matchmaking industry out in California ignited a spark within him, eventually leading him to an unexpected career transition.   

In an interview with Portland Phoenix, Cater recalls, 

“He started talking to me about this whole industry and what they did and how they worked, and I didn’t even know it existed. It was just very, very fascinating.”

As Successful Singles continued to grow, Cater expanded his matchmaking presence by opening The Matchmaker of Maine in 1997.

With its primary location in Maine, The Matchmaker of Maine extends its services throughout the entire New England area.

Cater shared in the interview how The Matchmaker of Maine has carved out a specific niche in the marketplace. He explained it this way:

"We’re not trying to be all things to all people. We know who we are. We know our system works because we’ve worked out all the kinks."” 

Cater revealed that clients aged 40 and above are their ideal demographic, and that the majority of his clients are between 30 and 60, have a college degree, and are non-smokers.

Potential clients begin with a personal 40-minute consultation. This one-on-one meeting is an opportunity for clients to share what they’re looking for in an ideal partner.

The Matchmaker of Maine team uses this session to evaluate if you’re a good fit for their service. 

Cater described the consultation this way,

"As our objective is to get acquainted with the client, we conduct an interview. We strive to assure that, when people join us, we feel confident that we have appropriate matches for them."

Next is a detailed process encompassing compatibility assessments and personality tests. These evaluations give Cater and his team a deeper understanding of the characteristics and qualities a client is looking for in a partner.

However, they don’t accept every person who is interested in working with the service. The company’s interest predominantly focuses on partnering with singles who have realistic match criteria and are emotionally prepared to find someone special.

As Cater explained in an interview, 

"We desire clients who are emotionally ready, emotionally available and have realistic expectations of what they're looking for, so we're selective in terms of who we bring on board."

According to Cater, The Matchmaker of Maine's methods are clear-cut, concentrating on helping individuals who’ve simply not had any luck in meeting the kind of person they’re hoping to find. 

"These are individuals who are very genuine and sincere and eagerly wish to be in a good, healthy relationship. It's not an easy task, and we just try to make this process a bit more manageable."

He encourages singles  to maintain a positive attitude throughout the process and to always remain open to possibilities. 

He shared with Dating News that there are so many singles out there who are looking for the same things in life, you just have to find them. 

"You have to put yourself in situations where you can meet individuals who are single and available."

The Matchmaker of Maine doesn’t openly advertise their prices online, choosing instead to discuss pricing details during consultations. 

But per online reviews, pricing can vary depending on the duration of the membership selected. 

Costs reportedly range from  $1,000+ for 3 months to $2,000+ for longer-term memberships, however, there may be room for negotiation. 

The Matchmaker of Maine offers a price match guarantee on their website, saying they will meet or beat the price of some competitors.

This Maine matchmaking service is accredited with the BBB, and has a rating of A+. 

There are 4 customer reviews, resulting in a 4-star rating. 

The 5-star reviews reported an overall positive experience working with Ron Cater and his team, as in this review:

On the other hand, this 1-star reviewer was dissatisfied with her matches and asked for a full refund:

The company has a 1-star rating on Yelp, based on just 2 reviews.

This client expressed frustration with both the quantify and perceived quality of her matches:

The other 1-star reviewer was the same former client who left a 1-star review on the BBB site.  

Google reviews for The Matchmaker of Maine are predominantly positive, resulting in a 4.4-star rating.

This 5-star reviewer said he met several women, and eventually his perfect match:

This former client mentioned that Cater really took the time to listen and find out what kind of partner she was seeking: 

This client said he was meeting compatible women, but hadn’t met his ideal partner yet:

There were also a handful of 1-star reviews for The Matchmaker of Maine on its Google Business page. One of them was from a client who also left a negative Yelp review.

And this client reported not being able to actually connect with his matches:

With over 30 years of matchmaking under his belt, there's no question that Cater has established himself in the industry. 

However, the question remains: Is his service the right choice for you? One factor worth considering before hiring any matchmaker is the source of your potential matches.

Many matchmaking services pair clients with others from their internal database. And while it's possible that your ideal partner has signed up with the same company you went with, there’s one thing to keep in mind: 

Achieving consistently high-quality matches from a limited database of singles in any one city is challenging for any matchmaker.

The reason? 

Mutual compatibility. It’s not just your checklist that matters - you also have to mesh with what the other person is seeking. 

If the service you sign up with is pulling matches from a limited pool, the odds are high you’ll be meeting people who don’t fit some (or any) of your criteria. They have to match you with who they have available, not necessarily who is compatible. 

That’s why one of the most common complaints you’ll read in online reviews is meeting people who don’t fit your ideal partner criteria. 

To help ensure that doesn't happen, some matchmaking services, like Enamour, take a slightly different approach than most traditional matchmakers. Enamour has a curated, invitation only database of singles.

But the Enamour team also uses recruiting technology along with an extensive scouting network to extend the search for your ideal partner far beyond that database, proactively identifying compatible singles for you to meet.

VIDA Select also takes a modern approach, using a search process that leverages the largest source of eligible Maine singles there. 

That means clients enjoy dates with truly compatible, relationship worthy singles. On average, singles meet someone special within just 3 months of beginning service.

And with VIDA, some matchmaking packages are pay-as-you-go - no long-term contract required. Monthly packages start at just $1,595.

To learn more about VIDA, just go here!