Best Matchmaking Services For Buffalo Singles [2025 Reviews & Cost!]

Buffalo matchmakers help Western New York singles overcome limited local dating options. VIDA Select leads with 82% success rates and flexible monthly pricing ($1,595+), while budget option Matchmaking 2 A Tee starts at $200. Premium services Perfect 12 ($60,000+) and Amy Laurent ($25,000+) serve affluent clients nationwide.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 11/08/2025

Key Insights:

• Budget-friendly option: Matchmaking 2 A Tee offers matchmaking services targeting professionals 30-70 starting at $200. 
• Mid-range premium: VIDA Select provides flexible Buffalo matchmaking starting at $1,595 monthly with no long-term contracts, an 82% success rate, and a guaranteed results package at $5,750. 
• Premium services: Perfect 12 and Amy Laurent International serve affluent Buffalo clients with annual fees ranging $25,000-$250,000+ for exclusive millionaire matchmaker services. 
• Local vs. national reach varies significantly - Matchmaking 2 A Tee focuses on Western New York, while Perfect 12, Amy Laurent, and VIDA Select offer nationwide databases.

With our experience in the industry stretching back to 2009, we're well acquainted with all the industry players, big and small. We’ve written over 200 reviews of matchmaking services, leveraging our in-depth knowledge of the industry and keen understanding of what clients value most.

You’ll find all the details you need to decide which one is best for you, from their matchmaking process to how much they cost!

Let's start with...

Scott Valdez, VIDA Select

With over a decade’s experience in the matchmaking industry, Scott Valdez and his team help singles navigate every aspect of modern dating - and find highly compatible matches with true relationship potential. 

Clientele

Accomplished, successful men and women, typically in their late 20s to early 60s, who want to meet “The One.”

Cost

VIDA Select matchmaking has monthly options starting at $1,595 with no long-term commitment. 

Results Guarantee Package: 5+ curated matches you personally approve within 90 days for $5,750 - guaranteed results or our work continues at no extra cost.

With an 82% success rate, most VIDA clients meet someone special in just 3 months!

What To Expect

As with other elite matchmaking services, the first step is a quick online screening process. This helps make sure our modern approach is the right fit.

If you’re qualified, you’ll be invited to schedule a complimentary consultation with one of VIDA Select’s matchmaking advisors.

You’ll discuss which of the pay-as-you-go packages fits your circumstances best. The cost is based on factors like the complexity and scope of your search, and how many hours should be dedicated to your search on a monthly basis.

Service begins with your personal matchmaker guiding you through an in-depth interview so she can get to know what makes you tick - and what your ideal partner is like.

Then, you’ll review full profiles of hand-selected, highly compatible Buffalo singles, and approve or pass on every potential match.

Want to learn more about the easiest way to meet your perfect match in Buffalo? Start by seeing if you qualify!

VIDA Select Reviews

On Trustpilot, VIDA Select holds a 4.5-star rating based on over 400 reviews. 

Several people mentioned how much they enjoyed working with their matchmaker, like these: 

And many others shared that they met someone special through the service, like this person: 

Lisa Brydges, Matchmaking 2 A Tee

Originally founded by Therese “Tee” Forton-Barnes, a long-time event and wedding planner, Matchmaking 2 a Tee is now helmed by matchmaker Lisa Brydges.

Clientele

This Buffalo matchmaker caters to “upscale” singles in Western New York. Typically busy professionals and entrepreneurs who are 30 to 70 years old. 

Cost

$200 - $500+

What To Expect

According to the Matchmaking 2 A Tee website, they use a “very advanced matchmaking and award-winning software” to match profiles from within their database. The first step? Submitting yours.  

A one-time fee of $200 for a Standard Membership gets your profile included in the database.

You’ll be contacted if you’re ever identified as a compatible match for a paying client. But having the matchmaking team screen for matches on your behalf requires paying for a Gold or Platinum membership.

Once a compatible match gets suggested by their matching algorithm, the team takes a closer look at the pairing. They do a short interview with both halves, and arrange either a virtual or face-to-face date if there's mutual interest.

As the matchmaker explained in an interview, 

We’re more about quality than quantity. We’re not trying to get you 20 dates a month - we’re trying to get you quality dates that could potentially turn into a relationship.

Matchmaking 2 A Tee specializes in helping people date in Buffalo. But depending on your package level, they will scout for matches outside of their database via a network of matchmaking contacts.

Matchmaking To A Tee Reviews

There are mixed reviews for the service on Yelp, resulting in a 2.3-star rating. This rating is based on less than a handful of reviews.  

This reviewer mentioned that the pricing was comparable: 

And there were two other ‘not recommended reviews’ that gave the service 5 stars. 

Founded In

2018

Simona Fusco, Perfect 12

As with Therese Forton-Barnes, matchmaking wasn’t Simona Fusco’s first business endeavor.

Fusco models and acts, and said her Hollywood experience sparked her interest in matchmaking. She works with singles in Buffalo as well as throughout New York, but her dating service is headquartered in California.

Clientele

A boutique matchmaker, Fusco takes on a very limited number of paying clients at a time. She typically works with successful, affluent men in their 30s to 60s, and “total package” women in their 20s to 50s.

Cost

$60,000 - $250,000 annually

What To Expect

Joining as a female “Affiliate” is free. But your profile needs to pass a screening process.

Once your profile is among the other ~200,000 singles in Fusco’s database, there’s a chance you’ll be matched with one of her male clients who is interested in dating in the Buffalo area.

Men, on the other hand, must purchase a matchmaking service package.

There is a $2,500 initial consultation, during which Fusco said she’ll decide “whether their expectations are realistic and match the values and core morals of our company.”

If you come on board, you’ll be choosing from a Gold, Platinum or “Carte Blanche” membership. Fusco’s prices aren’t listed anywhere online, but you can likely expect to pay in the same ballpark as other elite matchmakers with a national reach - in the tens of thousands.

Once you’ve decided on a package level and signed the contract, her matchmaking staff will get to know you and start pulling potential local matches from their national database.

Depending on your customized matchmaking service, Fusco may also scout for compatible singles outside of her existing match pool.  

Perfect 12 Matchmaking Reviews

On Yelp, Perfect 12 has a 4.0 rating. Of those who gave the service 5 stars, several people shared that the service matched them with quality matches, like these: 

Founded In

2005

Further Reading

Perfect 12 Reviews

Amy Laurent, Amy Laurent International

Amy Laurent is another national professional matchmaker who is no stranger to the media - she’s an author, media contributor, and was the celebrity matchmaker on Bravo’s reality show “Miss Advised.”

She has matchmaking offices on both costs - one in LA, and one in NYC, but extends her reach into Buffalo as well. 

Clientele

This millionaire matchmaker generally limits her paying client roster to affluent, successful men seeking a serious relationship.

Cost

$25,000+ 

What To Expect

As with most personal matchmaking services, the process starts off with an initial consultation.

During this initial chat, you’ll be shown a handful of potentially compatible matches. You’ll also discuss your relationship objectives, dating history, etc.

If Laurent feels like she can help you, you’ll sign a year-long contract. (It also includes up to 12 additional months of “hold” time.) She’ll give you an idea of how many matches you may expect, as the number varies per client.

She and her staff will then present matches a few at a time, and you’ll have the option to meet the singles you’re interested in.

Amy Laurent Reviews

While Laurent has garnered lots of media attention, you won’t likely find many reviews online. The service hasn’t been reviewed on mainstream platforms like Trustpilot, and it has unclaimed business profiles on Yelp and the BBB. 

So determining if Amy Laurent Matchmaking is your best bet you’ll want to take into consideration other factors like how you

Founded In

2005

Further Reading

Amy Laurent Reviews

Founded In

2009