Best Matchmakers For Colorado Singles [2026 Top List!]

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 11/3/2025

Key Insights:

• Budget-Friendly: VIDA Select - $1,595+/month, no contracts, 82% success rate, 3-month average
• Mid-Range Premium: Enamour - $20,000+ for 6 months, AI technology + relationship psychology
• Luxury High-End: Kelleher International ($30,000-$300,000+), LUMA ($15,000-$200,000+) for affluent professionals
• Niche Specialist: Keeper Introduction Services - outdoor/ski town focus, 5-figure pricing

We’ve been in the industry since 2009 and we're well acquainted with the major players. We’ve written over 200 matchmaking reviews, leveraging our comprehensive knowledge of the industry and understanding of what clients value most.

Let's start with...

Enamour

Enamour's seasoned matchmaking team uses a blend of relationship psychology, AI, and recruiting technology to find matches with true relationship potential.

Clientele

Accomplished and selective Colorado singles looking for a tailored approach to the search for their ideal partners.

Cost

Packages start around $20,000 for 6 months, with an array of options available.

What To Expect From Enamour

The process starts by filling out a short application via the website, followed by a complimentary consultation. Once you've been paired with a personal matchmaker, she'll get to know more about you, your lifestyle, and your match preferences.

This information gathering session sets the stage for Enamour's screening process, with each potential match thoroughly vetted either in-person or via video. Armed with all your 'must haves' and 'dealbreakers', your matchmaker will get straight to the heart of compatibility.

Matches who pass the screening will be presented to you for approval. After each date, your matchmaker will follow up with both of you, gathering insightful feedback and passing it along to you.

Your matches come from Enamour's exclusive, invitation-only database. But your matchmaker doesn't stop there - highly compatible candidates are also proactively sourced both online and offline via recruiting technology and an extensive network of scouts.

In addition to matchmaking, Enamour also offers complementary services such as dating and life coaching, personal styling, image consulting, and professional photography.

Enamour Reviews 

Enamour has a 4.2 rating on Trustpilot. Many of the favorable reviews shared how their matchmaker made their transition back into dating easier or meeting someone special through the service.  

As this reviewer said, “I was fortunate to work with Stacy, who is a wonderful matchmaker and is very thoughtful about her approach. My date was a perfect match for me, and I give her a lot of credit for being so intuitive and diligent.”  

 

VIDA Select (by Scott Valdez)

Founded in 2009, VIDA Select offers high-end matchmaking services without the high-end price tag - and allows clients to pay on a monthly basis rather than commit to 6 or 12 months at a time.

In fact, thanks to VIDA’s blend of traditional and modern matchmaking, clients typically meet their “perfect match” in just 3 months of beginning service!

Clientele

Successful, discerning professionals looking to meet high-quality singles.

Cost

Monthly Matchmaking: Starting at $1,595 with no long-term commitment.

Results Guarantee Package: 5+ curated matches you personally approve within 90 days for $5,750—guaranteed results or our work continues at no extra cost.

With an 82% success rate, most VIDA clients meet someone special in just 3 months!

What To Expect From VIDA Select

After a quick screening process to make sure VIDA Select is the right matchmaking service for you, your matchmaker will get to know exactly what type of person you’re hoping to meet.

Every client has unlimited matching potential, which means you’ll never be asked to compromise on your dealbreakers - each match is pre-screened by you! After checking out a full profile and photographs, you can express an interest in meeting or pass on the candidate entirely.

Because there’s no lengthy contract involved, you can stop your service whenever you want to focus on dating a particular match.

For that matter, you can stop service to travel, take a break from dating, or for any other reason! VIDA offers flexible matchmaking service that’s customized to fit your schedule.

VIDA Select Reviews 

On Trustpilot, VIDA Select has a 4.5 star rating based on over 400 reviews. 

One reviewer spoke about how their matchmaker was always positive and uplifting: 

“Nordika is absolutely amazing!!! She is uplifting and always in a good mood. 😄she instantly makes you feel comfortable with the idea of meeting your perfect match… She made this experience pleasant, enjoyable, and fun!” 

And this person was happy with their entire experience, including the fact they may have met someone special:  

“What a great experience. Got so many dates that I wouldn’t have got without Vida… Simmy - thank you for everything. Major superstar- no word of exaggeration. And … I think I have found someone special. 🤩” 

 

Kelleher International (by Jill Kelleher)

Founded in 1986, Kelleher International is headquartered on the West Coast but they have a presence in Denver.

Clientele

As former CEO Amber Kelleher explains, this is not a “mass market” dating agency. Instead, these high-end matchmakers only work with a handful of intelligent, affluent, and professional singles at a time.

Cost

$30,000 - $300,000+, a contract is required.

What To Expect From Kelleher International

After going through the screening process, you’ll decide if you’d like to meet singles in Denver, or expand your search nationally or even internationally. That will help determine the final cost of your membership. Membership contracts last 1 to 3 years and include an additional year’s worth of hold time.

Throughout the course of your membership, you’ll likely meet somewhere in the vicinity of 8 to 12 matches, pulled from their internal database of 50,000. Your Denver matchmaker can also scout locally, although that will increase the cost of your matchmaking services.

As your matches are found, if there’s mutual interest in the introduction you can meet in person, then let your matchmaker know how the date turned out.

Kelleher International Reviews 

There are only a small number of reviews for Kelleher International across both Yelp and the Better Business Bureau. The feedback from those few reviewers tends to be negative, with most expressing concerns about the high cost of the matchmaking services.

 

Keeper Introduction Services (by Gabriella Aratow)

Keeper Introduction Services, founded by Gabriella Aratow in 2020, is headquartered in Basalt, Colorado, but works with singles nationally and internationally.

Clientele

Aratow works with individuals of diverse backgrounds and ages. However, her niche clientele consists predominantly of people passionate about outdoor activities and those residing in ski towns. 

Cost

According to Aratow, matchmaking packages typically have a 5-figure price tag. Exact pricing is not disclosed on her website as cost varies depending on each client's search requirements. 

Contracts typically last 6 months with 1 to 2 introductions scheduled per month.

What To Expect From Keeper Introduction Services 

Potential clients have two options: have your profile included in their singles database free of charge, or become a paying member. The database option is a passive membership, meaning you'll only be contacted if your profile interests a paying client.

Paying clients go through a consultation and screening process to determine if they're a good fit for the service. If both parties agree, a contract is executed, and the matchmaking process begins.

Potential matches may be selected from the KIS database or are sourced from Aratow's larger matchmaking network.

Once matches are identified, if there's mutual interest a date is arranged. After the date, all that's left is to inform your matchmaker about how it went.

Keeper Introduction Services Reviews 

KIS features a variety of client testimonials on its website, and the matchmaker has been highlighted by media outlets like Medium, Shoutout Colorado, Aspen Magazine, Business Connect, and others. 

That said, you won’t find customer feedback on third-party review platforms such as Yelp, BBB, or Trustpilot. This lack of public reviews isn’t unusual—matchmaking is a highly personal service, and many clients choose to keep their experiences confidential rather than share them online.

Further Reading

Keeper Introduction Services review

 

LUMA Luxury Matchmaking (by April Davis)

LUMA (also branded Luxe Matchmaking) is a national service founded in 2010 by April Davis. It is based in Minneapolis with an office in Denver.

Clientele

As the name implies, LUMA is a high-end matchmaking service that caters to successful singles who want a serious relationship with another “Total Package” type person.

Cost

$15,000 - $200,000+, a contract is required.

What To Expect From LUMA

LUMA matchmaking cost varies, as packages are tailored to suit individual members. There’s also the option to list your profile as one of the 20,000+ singles in their internal database, which you can do for free. But if you want guaranteed matches you’ll need to pay for a membership.

LUMA’s matchmaking process is straightforward - your matchmaker will find up to 40 Denver singles in the database who seem to resemble what you’re seeking in an ideal partner.

She’ll then arrange an in-person interview with the most promising of those matches, and narrow down the candidate list even further. That’s the group you’ll be introduced to one by one, with a guarantee of meeting at least 3 people.

If you hit it off with one (or more) and there’s mutual desire for a second date, simply exchange contact info during the first one and arrange to see each other again.

If you don’t end up wanting to see any of your LUMA matches again, you can arrange to purchase more introductions and your matchmaker will begin the screening all over again.

LUMA Matchmaking Reviews 

LUMA carries a 4.8 rating on Yelp based on 11 reviews. 

The majority are positive, with several clients describing their matchmakers as professional, supportive, and attentive.

For instance, this client wrote "my matchmaker listened attentively to my needs, told me about the services. She was very nice and helpful."

Further Reading

LUMA Luxury Matchmaking review

 

Considering a dating agency that’s not listed here? No matter which Colorado matchmakers you’re considering, making the right investment means asking smart questions during your consultation.

These 5 are a great place to start:

Critical Questions to Ask:

1. Match Sourcing: Do you only use internal databases or actively recruit externally?
2. Review Process: Can I see profiles/photos before meeting matches?
3. Contract Terms: What are the cancellation and refund policies?
4. Success Metrics: What are your actual success rates and timelines?
5. Additional Costs: Are there extra fees for scouting, coaching, or premium services?

Prioritize Flexibility: Traditional matchmakers often require large upfront payments with limited recourse if you're unsatisfied. One way to avoid that is to choose a service that doesn't lock you into a lengthy commitment. You may want to look for services that offer:

• Month-to-month payments over lengthy contracts
• Ability to pause/restart without penalties
• Clear cancellation and refund policies

Verify Credibility: Many matchmaking services rely on carefully curated website testimonials that may not represent typical client experiences. Always seek independent verification of their track record.

• Check third-party reviews on Trustpilot, Yelp, Google
• Look for verified client testimonials
• Research matchmaker backgrounds and experience

Ensure Quality Control: The difference between good and disappointing matchmaking often comes down to the screening process. Make sure you maintain control over who you meet and receive ongoing support.

• Pre-screening approval before all introductions
• Full profiles and photos provided
• Post-date feedback and search adjustments