KIS Matchmaking Reviews [Best CO Matchmaker?]

Keeper Introduction Services (KIS) is a boutique Colorado matchmaking firm founded in 2020 by Gabriella Aratow, a former Tawkify matchmaker. Packages typically fall in the "5-figure range" for 6-month contracts with 1–2 introductions per month. KIS specializes in outdoor-oriented singles in Colorado ski towns but also serves clients nationwide. The service may work well for those wanting a personal, relationship-focused matchmaker—but limited public reviews make it difficult to assess client satisfaction at scale.

Keeper Introduction Services at a Glance

Quick Verdict: Is Keeper Introduction Services Worth It?

Worth considering if: You're an outdoor-oriented single in Colorado's ski towns who wants a boutique, personalized matchmaking experience with direct access to the founder. Aratow's background at Tawkify and genuine passion for matchmaking suggest a hands-on approach, and her network relationships with other matchmakers can expand your candidate pool beyond the KIS database alone.

Think twice if: You want extensive public reviews to verify client satisfaction before committing, need transparent pricing upfront, or prefer month-to-month flexibility over 6-month contracts. The limited track record (founded 2020) and vague "5-figure" pricing make it harder to assess value compared to more established services with published rates and substantial review histories.

Bottom line: KIS offers a niche, relationship-focused service for a specific demographic, but the lack of public client feedback means you're relying heavily on your consultation impression and any references Aratow can provide.

How We Researched This Review

With over 15 years of first-hand matchmaking industry experience, our team at VIDA Select has reviewed 200+ matchmaking services. We analyzed Keeper Introduction Services' publicly available information and founder interviews, and compared their offering to other Colorado-area matchmakers to help you make an informed decision.

Disclaimer: This review was researched and written by VIDA Select's matchmaking experts to help singles find the service that best fits their needs and goals.

Gabriella Aratow's path to matchmaking began unexpectedly while helping her 70+ year-old mother set up a Match.com profile. That experience led her to discover Tawkify, a national matchmaking service. Rather than applying as a client, Aratow joined as a matchmaker in 2016.

Before matchmaking, Aratow worked at the William Morris talent agency in California, losing her position due to a merger. She spent several years as a caregiver for an ailing family member before her career pivot to matchmaking.

After four years at Tawkify and an affiliation with Love Boss Matchmaking, Aratow relocated from California to Colorado. The move was inspired by a visit to Telluride, and, ironically, a Tinder date who showed her around his favorite spots near Aspen. As Aratow puts it: 

“I tell people, the thing about dates is you don’t know what’s going to come out of them. I did not find my romantic partner from this date. But I did find my home.”

In 2020, she launched Keeper Introduction Services from Basalt, Colorado.

Why "Keeper Introduction Services"?

Aratow chose the name intentionally. "Introduction" rather than "match" reflects her commitment to ensuring actual introductions happen. And "keeper," she explains, has "literary roots about being someone's guardian or caretaker, which is an element of real love, that protective element."

Aratow emphasizes that her own dating experiences inform her work:

“The good, the bad, and the ugly - I know what people are going through.” 

Who Does Keeper Introduction Services Work With?

According to Aratow, KIS clients are typically outdoor fitness enthusiasts in Colorado ski towns. However, she also works with singles in cities across the US including Chicago, Seattle, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and New York, plus occasional international clients.

Client ages range from late 20s to upper 70s, suggesting flexibility in the types of singles KIS serves.

Step 1: Complete the Online Membership Form

The first step is filling out the online form on the KIS website, sharing basic information about yourself, your lifestyle, and what you're looking for in an ideal partner.

Step 2: Choose Your Membership Level

KIS offers two options:

Free Database Membership Your profile is added to the singles database after screening. If a paying client expresses interest and you meet their criteria, Aratow will reach out to see if interest is mutual. If so, she arranges the introduction.

Important caveat: This is not an active search. You may never be contacted—it depends entirely on whether you match what paying clients are seeking.

Paid Matchmaking Client Aratow and her team actively search for compatible singles on your behalf. Matches come from the KIS database or through her matchmaking network, where matchmakers refer candidates to each other.

Step 3: Introductions Begin

For paying clients, typical contracts span 6 months with 1–2 introductions per month. Aratow describes her optimism about each pairing:

“Every date I set up still fills me with hope, like it could change the entire world because it actually can.”

How Aratow Finds Matches

Aratow recruits potential matches through multiple channels. As she explained to City Life, 

“I do everything from using social media and going on podcasts to asking friends and family and attending networking events. I also use other matchmakers a lot. We also refer candidates to each other in the matchmaking business, which is nice.” 

Keeper Introduction Services doesn't publish specific pricing. According to Aratow, matchmaking packages typically fall within the 5-figure range, with exact costs depending on:

• Desired search scope (local vs. national)
• Match preferences and criteria complexity
• Contract length and number of introductions

Typical contracts are 6 months with 1–2 introductions per month.

How KIS Pricing Compares to Other Colorado Matchmakers

Is Keeper Introduction Services Worth It?

May be worth considering if you:

• Live in or near Colorado ski towns and want a matchmaker who understands that lifestyle
• Value a boutique, personalized approach over a larger agency
• Prefer working directly with the founder rather than being assigned to different matchmakers
• Are comfortable with 5-figure investment for a 6-month contract
• Don't need extensive public reviews to feel confident in your choice

May want to explore alternatives if you:

• Prefer month-to-month flexibility without long-term contracts
• Want to see substantial client review history before committing
• Are looking for a larger candidate pool beyond Colorado and matchmaker networks
• Need transparent, published pricing before your consultation
• Want data-driven matching with verified success rate metrics

If Keeper Introduction Services doesn't seem like the right fit, here are other options for Colorado singles:

VIDA Select

VIDA Select offers a modern approach that leverages the largest pool of eligible singles available. Unlike traditional matchmakers with static databases, VIDA's tech-driven process provides access to a much broader candidate pool.

Key differentiators:

• Month-to-month packages with no long-term contracts available
• Transparent pricing: Monthly service starts at $1,595
• Fast results: 82% of clients meet someone special within an average of 3 months
• Flexibility: Monthly clients can pause service as needed

Ready to find your ideal partner? Find out if VIDA is right for you!

Enamour

An exclusive matchmaking service with an "invitation only" database. Uses recruiting technology and scouts to expand searches both online and offline. 6-month packages typically start around $20,000.

Kelleher International

West Coast-headquartered with Denver presence. Contracts typically 1–3 years with prices starting at $30,000. National and international searches possible at the higher package levels.

Keeper Introduction Services offers a boutique, Colorado-focused matchmaking option led by a former Tawkify matchmaker with a genuine passion for helping singles connect. For outdoor enthusiasts in ski towns seeking a personalized approach, KIS may be worth exploring.

However, the limited public review history, vague pricing, and relatively short track record (founded 2020) make it difficult to independently assess the service compared to more established alternatives. If you're considering KIS, request client references and get clear pricing before committing to a 5-figure contract.

For those wanting more flexibility, transparent pricing, and access to a larger candidate pool, month-to-month services like VIDA Select may be a better fit.

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.