Best Connecticut Matchmakers [2026 Service Guide!]

Connecticut's top matchmakers range from $1,595/month (VIDA Select) to $25,000+ (Elegant Introductions, Serious Matchmaking). VIDA offers flexible month-to-month service with no contracts, while boutique firms like Greenwich Matchmaker provide personalized searches for upscale professionals seeking serious relationships.

💡 Key Takeaways

• VIDA Select – Flexible monthly matchmaking with no long-term contract; starts at $1,595
• Elegant Introductions – For upscale singles seeking deep compatibility; starts at $25,000
• Greenwich Matchmaker – Boutique service with unique men/women registry model; $250–$500 screening
• Serious Matchmaking – Luxury matchmaking for wealthy men; $75K to $1M+

Our team has reviewed more than 200 matchmakers and their services, delving deep into their operations, success rates, price tag, and real customer experiences. Our reviews are built on extensive research and a keen understanding of the matchmaking landscape honed over 16+ years in the industry.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 1/09/2026

Let's start with...

Scott Valdez, VIDA Select

VIDA Select is a modern matchmaking service that helps singles all over the world find their ideal partner.

Using the latest technology, VIDA’s elite matchmakers have access to the most extensive pool of Connecticut singles you’ll find anywhere, which is why the average VIDA client finds “someone special” within the first few months of signing up.

Clientele

Professional, relationship-minded singles who are typically in their early 30s to mid 60s, although VIDA has helped clients from 18 to 80 find love!

Cost

VIDA’s packages start as low as just $1595 per month for Basic matchmaking services. With the monthly pay-as-you-go option, you can worth with a professional matchmaker while being in total control of your dating journey.

For guaranteed results, there is a $5750 package that guarantees at least 5 thoughtfully curated matches over the course of 90 days, all personally approved by you. With an 82% success rate, most clients begin a relationship within 3 months.

What To Expect

VIDA’s matchmaking process starts with a free, low key and confidential phone call. If you and your matchmaker agree the service is a good fit, you’ll have a more in-depth interview where you’ll discuss your relationship goals and your ideal partner criteria.

Once your search begins, you’ll get to review a complete profile of each match - including photos. That means you’re only meeting people who meet all your criteria.

Intrigued? Go here and see if you qualify!

Additional Services

Image consulting and styling, date coaching, professional photography

VIDA Select Reviews

On Trustpilot, VIDA Select has a 4.5-star rating based on over 400 reviews. 

One reviewer spoke about how their matchmaker was always positive and uplifting by saying,  “Nordika is absolutely amazing!!! She is uplifting and always in a good mood. 😄 she instantly makes you feel comfortable with the idea of meeting your perfect match… She made this experience pleasant, enjoyable, and fun!” 

And other positive reviews mentioned favorable experiences with their matchmaker: 

Founded In

2009

Dr. Nancy Gold-Zimmer & Barbara Black Goldfarb, Elegant Introductions

Elegant Introductions is a boutique matchmaking firm cofounded by Dr. Nancy Gold-Zimmer, a highly respected psychologist, and Barbara Black Goldfarb, a nationally known connector and relationship strategist.

As native New Englanders who spend significant time throughout the region, the founders bring a nuanced understanding of the region’s culture, values, and relationship dynamics.

Their matchmaking firm is tailored to high-caliber singles looking for meaningful, lasting relationships. Elegant Introductions blends deep psychological insight with vast social networks to create matches that align on compatibility, lifestyle, and long-term relationship goals and dreams.

Clientele

Elegant Introductions is ideal for successful professionals, executives, and high-net-worth individuals who value discretion, intention, and depth. Clients are typically educated, successful, and attractive singles who want a highly personalized matchmaking experience. 

Cost

Pricing starts at $25,000 and is customized based on the scope of the search, client preferences, and geographic reach. Because each relationship journey is unique, Elegant Introductions offers curated packages tailored to the needs and timeline of each client. The initial consultation is required to determine the right service level. 

What To Expect

The Elegant Introductions experience is intentionally selective, deeply personalized, and designed with thoughtfulness at every step. The journey begins with an in-depth intake form, crafted to uncover essential insights into your background, values, and what you're truly looking for in a partner.

If your responses suggest alignment with Elegant Introductions’ unique approach, you’ll be invited to a preliminary discovery call with one of the founders. During this conversation, they’ll explain the company's philosophy and approach to matchmaking, and determine whether you're a good fit for the service.

The next step is a private consultation with co-founders Dr. Nancy Gold-Zimmer and Barbara Black Goldfarb. This is more than just an interview—it’s a comprehensive conversation that explores your relationship history, personal values, emotional needs, and long-term goals.

Elegant Introductions only accepts a limited number of clients at a time, ensuring they can provide the hands-on, boutique-level service their reputation is built on.

If you both agree that it’s a good fit, you’ll officially become a client and begin your matchmaking journey. This phase involves defining your ideal partner criteria, outlining deal-breakers and essential compatibility factors, and discussing any red flags or past patterns. A tailored search strategy is developed for you, led directly by Dr. Gold-Zimmer and Ms. Goldfarb.

Additional Services

Elegant Introductions' matchmaking service also includes relationship & dating coaching, image consulting & styling, professional photography, and social confidence & communication training.

Founded In

2012 

Elegant Introductions Reviews

The service has yet to be reviewed on mainstream platforms like Trustpilot or Yelp, nor does Elegant Introductions have a listing with the Better Business Bureau. 

A lack of reviews is not uncommon in the matchmaking industry, given boutique matchmaking clients generally value their privacy. Given their media coverage and long-standing presence in the matchmaking industry, Elegant Introductions is an option worth considering for Connecticut singles.

Further Reading

Elegant Introductions reviews

Lory Kelsey, Greenwich Matchmaker

With a background in social work and psychology, plus a previous stint at a NY dating company, Lory Kelsey is no stranger to helping people.

She started her own professional matchmaking service in Greenwich after getting divorced and finding it difficult to meet quality men. She realized there were plenty of people experiencing the same frustration, and the rest is history.

Clientele

“Upscale and professional” men (and occasionally “high net worth” women). Kelsey is a boutique style matchmaker, and she only accepts a limited number of paying clients at a time.

Cost

Cost & commitment varies per client.

Women can interview to be included in the Platinum Registry for 5 years, provided they pass the screening process. The interview fee is $500 for women 30+, and $250 for those under 30. Having a profile included in the registry does not come with a guarantee of ever being matched with a paying client.

Men who don’t want to pay for matchmaking services can interview to be included in the Gold Registry for 5 years, which costs $500. Men in the registry will be matched with paying female clients, although no matches are guaranteed.

What To Expect

Male clients will have a free 30-minute phone call, followed by a paid one-on-one consultation provided they pass the phone screening process.

The cost of the matchmaking service depends on the specificity of your ideal partner criteria, and how easy (or difficult) Kelsey believes it may be to match you. Clients are matched with singles in her database.

Additional Services

Date coaching

Greenwich Matchmaker Reviews 

The service has a 3.7 rating on Yelp based on only 3 reviews.  The 2 5-star reviews mentioned a good experience working with Lory: 

Further Reading

Greenwich Matchmaker reviews

Janis & Carly Spindel, Serious Matchmaking

This mother/daughter team is one of the East Coast’s most well known millionaire matchmakers. Serious Matchmaking is headquartered in New York, but they also have a presence in Connecticut.

Clientele

Serious Matchmaking’s core clientele is wealthy, successful men who want a serious relationship (read: marriage).

They don’t typically provide matchmaking services for female clients.

Instead, women can interview to be included in their national database, and then potentially be matched with paying male clients.

There is a one-time fee to participate in the screening process, which ranges from $250 up to $1,250 depending on factors such as whether the interview is in-person or not.

Cost

$75,000 - $1,000,000/1-year commitment

Matchmaking packages all include 12 months of active search time, during which you’ll receive at least 12 matches as required by NY law.

Serious Matchmaking contracts also include a signer's fee and a finder's fee. The rate starts at $65,000, and the same amount is due for both. The signer's fee is paid up front; the finder's fee is only due upon forming a successful relationship with a match the Spindels found for you.

If those prices are out of your budget, there’s a $6,000 “Flash Match” option. It’s a one-night event such as a cocktail party where you’ll get to meet 6 hand-selected women during the course of the evening.

What To Expect

For women, the process begins by filling out the online application and paying the fee for the interview. If you make it through the screening process, your profile will be included in the Serious Matchmaking database. But there’s no guarantee for when (or even if) you’ll be matched.

Men meet with Janis or Carly for an initial consultation. Then you’ll select which package the two of you agree is the best fit. You’ll then be matched with women from the database, and you can provide feedback after each introduction.

Founded In

1993

Serious Matchmaking Reviews

With a 3.1 rating on Yelp, Janis Spindel's Serious Matchmaking receives mixed feedback. Satisfied clients highlight how Janis was attentive during the matchmaking process and helped them with personal growth.  

Further Reading

Serious Matchmaking reviews

Making a smart decision about matchmaking services requires preparation. Here's how to protect your investment and find the right fit.

#1: Check Credible Review Sources

Don't rely solely on polished websites and sales presentations. Dig deeper into each company's actual track record.

Check Multiple Review Sites

Google, Yelp, and Trustpilot offer different perspectives on customer experiences. Look for patterns rather than isolated incidents. A few negative reviews among mostly positive ones might not be concerning, but consistent complaints about the same issues are red flags.

Understand the Absence of Reviews

Many boutique matchmakers have few or no online reviews. This isn't necessarily negative—successful clients now in relationships rarely take time to write reviews, and privacy-conscious professionals avoid public testimonials. However, only finding angry reviews without any positive feedback is concerning.

Consult the Better Business Bureau

The BBB goes beyond simple star ratings. You can see how companies respond to complaints, whether they attempt resolution, and view specific contract language in dispute cases. This reveals their approach to customer service when things go wrong.

Search for Legal Issues

A quick Google search including terms like "lawsuit" or "complaint" with the company name can uncover legal problems. Check public records for pending or resolved lawsuits. Even successful companies may have isolated disputes, but patterns of legal trouble should give you pause.

Investigate Local News

Local news stations sometimes investigate matchmaking services accused of scamming customers. These reports often include details not found in standard reviews.

All this research prepares you for the next crucial step: the consultation itself.

#2: Bring A List Of Questions To Your Consultation

Whether your matchmaking consultation is via phone or in person, having a list of questions ready to ask during the conversation is a savvy move.

Here are 5 good questions to ask a potential matchmaking service:

Trust Your Instincts

If someone seems evasive or uncomfortable answering straightforward questions, that's a warning sign. Professional matchmakers should be confident and transparent when explaining their process, pricing, and policies.

Watch for High-Pressure Tactics

Some matchmakers employ aggressive sales techniques during consultations, pushing you to sign immediately with "limited time" offers. Take the time you need to make an informed decision. Any legitimate service will respect your need to think it over.

#3: Scrutinize The Contract - Before You Sign It

If you decide to move forward, the contract is where good intentions meet legal reality. Never sign anything without fully understanding what you're agreeing to.

Payment Terms

Most matchmaking services require full payment upfront. Once you've paid, you'll have virtually no recourse if you're unsatisfied. This puts all the risk on you, so be absolutely certain before committing.

Service Guarantees

Read carefully what's actually guaranteed. "Five introductions" doesn't mean five great matches—it might mean five introductions to anyone in their database who meets all, some, or none of your basic criteria depended on how your contract is worded. Understand the difference between quantity guarantees and quality promises.

Cancellation and Refund Policies

These are typically heavily weighted in the company's favor. Many contracts state that once signed, you're committed regardless of satisfaction level. Know exactly what your options are if things don't work out.

Contract Length

Some services lock you into 12, 18, or even 24-month agreements. Others offer month-to-month flexibility. Consider how much uncertainty you're comfortable with before committing to a long-term contract.

Success Definitions

How does the contract define a successful match? Some consider it fulfilled if you go on one date, even if there's no chemistry. Others consider their job complete if contact information is exchanged between you and your match, regardless of whether the two of you meet or not. There is no right or wrong way to do it, but understanding the process helps you avoid disappointment down the road.

Ask Questions Until You're Satisfied

Don't let anyone rush you through contract review. If you don't understand something, ask for clarification. If they can't explain it clearly, that's a problem.

Consider Alternatives to Long-Term Commitments

If paying $25,000+ upfront for a year or more makes you uncomfortable, consider services like VIDA Select that offer monthly subscriptions. You maintain flexibility to stop if you meet someone quickly or if the service isn't delivering results.

Your budget matters too. Decide your maximum investment before the consultation, and don't let persuasive salespeople push you beyond it. This is about finding a partner, not impressing a matchmaker with your willingness to spend.

Traditional matchmaking locks you into expensive, lengthy contracts with money paid upfront and limited recourse if unsatisfied. But there's a better approach for many Connecticut singles.

VIDA Select offers professional matchmaking without the commitment anxiety. You pay monthly—no annual contracts, no massive upfront fees. If you meet someone special in month one, you're not stuck paying for 11 more months of service you don't need.

How VIDA Works Differently

Rather than limiting searches to a small local database, VIDA's matchmakers access one of the industry's largest pools of potential matches. They search across platforms, networks, and regions to find truly compatible partners based on your specific criteria.

You approve every match before any introduction happens. Your dedicated matchmaker handles all the logistics, from profile optimization to date arrangements, saving you countless hours while ensuring quality over quantity.

With an 82% success rate and most clients meeting someone special within 3 months, VIDA delivers results without the risk of traditional matchmaking services. Packages start at just $1,595 per month—a fraction of boutique matchmaker fees—and professional photography, image consulting, and ongoing date coaching are also available.

Learn more about VIDA's modern approach to matchmaking with a free, 20-minute consultation call.