Greenwich Matchmaker Review [Best CT Dating Agency?]

Greenwich Matchmaker LLC is a boutique matchmaking service founded by Lory Kelsey in 2012. Based in Connecticut, the service assists singles within a 100-mile radius of Greenwich, including New York and New Jersey. Consultations cost $600 per hour, and the service holds a 5-star Google rating based on 6 reviews along with an A+ BBB rating.

Key Insights

• Founded: 2012 by Lory Kelsey, who has a master's degree in social work and background in clinical psychology
• Service area: Singles within a 100-mile radius of Greenwich, including New York, Connecticut, and New Jersey
• Consultation cost: $600 per hour for professional consultations (typically 1-2 hours)
• Membership options: Paying matchmaking clients or database membership (Platinum Registry for women, Gold Gentlemen's Registry for men)
• Database membership: $600 consultation fee with profile active for 5 years, but no guaranteed matches
• Package costs: Not disclosed; customized to individual clients
• Reviews: 5-star Google rating (6 reviews), A+ BBB rating with no reviews or complaints

Disclaimer: This review was researched and written by VIDA Select's editorial team to help singles determine the right service for their needs and goals. As a matchmaking service ourselves, we bring a unique industry perspective. Our insights come from 17+ years of matchmaking experience, writing 200+ matchmaking service reviews, analyzing public information including reviews on reputable platforms, and feedback from clients who used other services before hiring VIDA. While this review is updated regularly, it may not reflect the latest public data or current pricing.

Lory Kelsey began her professional journey in clinical psychology and holds a master’s degree in social work. Beyond her educational credentials, she also gained industry-insight working for a dating service called Turning Point International. 

After her divorce, she experienced for herself how hard it could be to meet quality singles in Greenwich. Kelsey found herself “frustrated with the bar scene” and knew she couldn’t be the only person in this predicament.  

As she shared with CT Insider,

"I live in Greenwich and was looking to date in Greenwich and thought to myself, 'Maybe I should be the Greenwich matchmaker.'"

Kelsey put her idea into action and, in 2012, she established Greenwich Matchmaker LLC.

Her service assists both men and women in New York, Connecticut, and New Jersey, specializing in working with singles within a 100-mile radius of Greenwich. 

As someone who thoroughly enjoys her work, Kelsey finds matchmaking an immensely rewarding profession. Identifying as a "romantic at heart," she believes that we're all in search of that special connection. 

Or as she puts it,

“It’s really thrilling when two people meet and want to go out again. I can’t think of anything more thrilling, everyone is looking for that moment.”

In an interview with Hamlet Hub, Kelsey explained the benefit of working with a matchmaker and the personalized touch it offers: 

“With a matchmaker’s expertise, you will be meeting people you would never meet otherwise and who share similar interests, values, goals in life. A matchmaker hand selects introductions for you having interviewed them in person ahead of time.” 

Adopting a boutique-style approach, Greenwich Matchmaker caters to a limited number of clients at any given time.

The process starts by applying for an interview:

If she thinks you’re a good fit for the service, the next step is a complimentary consultation followed by a “professional” consultation that has an associated cost of $600 per hour. (The calls typically run between 1 and 2 hours.)

During this process, Kelsey gains an understanding of the client's personality and preferences for a partner, while clarifying membership options and corresponding costs. 

Kelsey's matchmaking service offers two main membership choices for both men and women: becoming a matchmaking client or joining the “Platinum Registry” as a potential match.

Women wishing to become a “Private Lady Client” need to be between the ages of 25 and 60 years and meet certain net-worth criteria. 

Joining the Platinum Registry requires a 1-hour, $600 consultation call. You’ll then be eligible to be matched with paying clients for 5 years. There are no guaranteed matches as a database member, so you may never meet anyone this way.

Greenwich Matchmaker also offers additional services for women, such as dating makeovers, nutrition counseling, and more.

Men can purchase a matchmaking package, or also have the option to join the “Gold Gentlemen’s Registry”. 

This involves a $600, 1-hour consultation call. If selected, your profile will be included in the database for 5 years. You’ll be matched with the “Platinum Lady Clients” who purchased matchmaking service. 

There are, however, no guarantees you’ll ever be contacted as a database member. For an active search, you’ll need to purchase a package.

Paying male clients are matched with the 2,000+ women from Kelsey’s database, or with candidates she’s scouted via her network of contacts. Clients can also purchase dating concierge services, where she plans out the dates for you.

Apart from the $600 per hour consultation fees, matchmaker Lory Kelsey does not divulge her matchmaking package costs online. As she states in the FAQ on her website, her packages are tailored to fit individual clients.

But taking a quick look at what other Connecticut matchmaking services charge can give you a general idea of the financial investment you might be making.  

For instance, Enamour is an option to consider for Connecticut singles looking for a hyper-curated pool of matches. 

But the Enamour team searches far beyond the invitation-only database, using an extensive network of scouts and recruiting tech to pinpoint compatible matches both offline and online.

Enamour packages start around $20,000.

And VIDA Select leverages the largest pool of eligible singles there is, thanks to taking a modern approach to matchmaking. VIDA clients look forward to meeting highly compatible singles, and on average meet someone special within just 3 months of signing up.

Some packages are purchased on a monthly basis, so you won’t need to commit to a long-term, multi-month contract. Monthly service starts at $1595.

Now that you have a ballpark idea of cost, let’s take a look at what past clients of Greenwich matchmaking have to say about their experience with Lory Kelsey. 

Greenwich Matchmaker holds a 5-star rating on their Google business page, however that's based on only 6 reviews.

Most of the reviewers mentioned meeting quality matches:

And this client shared that Kelsey was professional and gave her wonderful post-date feedback:

Greenwich Matchmaker has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), with no reviews or complaints listed.

Lory Kelsey’s Connecticut dating service has a Yelp entry, but no reviews there yet either.

You have plenty of Connecticut matchmaking services to choose from, so that’s the good news. Now it’s time to start narrowing down your options, and the best way to do that is considering factors like cost, the duration of the contract, where your matches come from, and your feelings about the initial consultation. 

If you’re not sure what to expect from that first call, or you’re not sure what type of questions you should be asking, our team of experts has you covered. 

Our quick guide to hiring a matchmaking service is packed with tips on what to consider before signing a contract, insightful questions to ask any potential matchmaker, and ways to avoid making a costly mistake.

All the info you need to be confident you’re making an informed decision!