Meet Courtney Quinlan [Best Omaha Matchmaker For You?]

Courtney Quinlan has been in the business of love for 15 years. But do she and Midwest Matchmaking have what it takes to find your ideal partner?

Our team of experts have reviewed 200+ matchmakers, diving deep into their service, process, success rate, and client reviews. We've been in the industry since 2009, and our reviews are not only built on our comprehensive research, but also our first-hand experience and insights!

From Quinlan’s dating philosophy to her matchmaking process, this Courtney Quinlan review covers everything you need to decide if she is the right matchmaker for you:

Let's start at the beginning...

Courtney Quinlan’s Midwest Roots

Quinlan became a professional matchmaker in 2006, coming onboard a local dating service after graduating from the University of Nebraska.

As she shared in an interview with VoyageKC, she knew matchmaking was her “forever career” - but she also realized she wanted to do things her own way.   

She launched Omaha Love in 2009, headquartered in Omaha. As the name implied, she specialized in helping singles in and around Omaha.

As the service grew, Quinlan began receiving interest from singles further and further away. In 2018, the company rebranded to Midwest Matchmaking to reflect its larger regional presence. In addition to Nebraska, Quinlan’s service now helps singles in St. Louis, Des Moines, Minneapolis, and Kansas City as well.

Quinlan also offers dating coaching for both clients and non-clients. During these one-on-one sessions with a “Love Coach,” you’ll work on developing personal skills for successful relationships. 

A Peek At Quinlan’s Dating Philosophy 

On her Instagram account, Quinlan said she advises clients against being too specific with a physical “type”. 

“I don’t really ask my clients too much about what they find attractive or if there are certain physical traits they are drawn to. My years of experience have shown me that relationships are built on shared values and goals, which boost compatibility.”

It’s also where she dispenses her top tips on avoiding online dating burnout:

Quinlan briefly discussed her matchmaking process to SmartMatchApp: 

I match with intuition. My main job when I’m matching is really to make sure that the clients I’m matching are ready to start dating and really don’t need anything in life except for that person to share it with.

And in a conversation with Marco LeRoc, Quinlan touches on how someone’s age can play a factor in a successful marriage: 

I don’t necessarily recommend a person get married before the age of 28. I think a person can change so much between the ages of 20 and 28, and that’s where I see the aftermath of that. 

Quinlan often works with clients in their 30s - 50s who have a solid understanding of who they are and what they are looking for in a relationship. She claims that this self-awareness helps her to build lasting connections.

What To Expect From Midwest Matchmaking

Midwest Matchmaking meets and screens all potential clients “face-to-face” via Zoom or in-person. This appointment is an opportunity to share what you're looking for in a partner and ask about membership options.

This boutique matchmaking service connects their clients with singles who have filled out a profile in their database. Potential matches are presented, so you can review a profile and photos before choosing to accept or pass on the opportunity to meet someone.

When both singles in the pairing are interested in meeting, a video call or in-person date is arranged.

Quinlan said she typically suggests cocktails or coffee for in-person dates, and video dates when matches live over an hour apart from each other. But ultimately, those details are up to the client.

Afterward, both the client and the match can provide post-date feedback and decide whether or not there will be another date. 

Midwest Matchmaking also promotes singles on their Facebook page to encourage more singles to sign up for their database and indicate which featured client they would like to meet.

Now let’s talk about the price tag…

How Much Does It Cost To Hire Courtney Quinlan?

Midwest Matchmaking costs range from free to $3,600+, depending on which of the two memberships you want.

Passive: This option is free, but no active search occurs on your behalf. You fill out a profile for the Midwest Matchmaking database and are only contacted if you happen to fit what a paying client is looking for. 

Private: This option is for clients who want a proactive search. Paid memberships are offered at varying levels and contract lengths. At the base level, these memberships begin at: 

• $1,800 for a 6-month contract
• $3,600 for a 12-month contract

Many factors affect the final price of your contract. For example, whether or not you want to: 

• Keep your profile private
• Work directly with Quinlan 
• Have the team scout for matches outside of the database 

Paying members are promised “active matching”, but there is no guaranteed number of matches during the length of your contract.

Is Courtney Quinlan The Best Matchmaker For You?

Online matchmaking service reviews like this one can help you answer that question. And if you want an in-depth look at what former clients have to say about their experience, check out our Midwest Matchmaking review.

Not only will you get a sampling of real client experiences, it also breaks down their star ratings from around the web.

So read that comprehensive review, but also consider what you're comfortable with in terms of contracts. Matchmaking services typically require a commitment of 6 to 12 months, sometimes more - and in most cases you'll need to pay the entire amount up front.

However, there are exceptions. VIDA Select, for instance, offers a selection of packages offered on a month-to-month basis. And thanks to VIDA's modern approach, scouting outside a limited Rolodex doesn't cost extra. That's because VIDA's matchmakers are able to leverage the largest source of eligible singles there is!

Clients typically start a relationship after only 3 months of service... Why not see if VIDA Select is right for you, too? Start by seeing if you qualify for the service: just click here!

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.