Midwest Matchmaking Reviews [Best Way To Find Your Perfect Match?]

Midwest Matchmaking has mixed reviews across platforms with 4.2 stars on Google, 1 star on BBB, and 1.8 stars on Yelp (under former name Omaha Love). Founded by Courtney Quinlan in 2009, the boutique service costs $1,800-$3,600+ and operates across Nebraska, St. Louis, Des Moines, Minneapolis, and Kansas City. Clients receive matches one at a time with no guaranteed numbers, though premium packages include database scouting beyond their internal pool.

💡 Key Takeaways:

• Platform rating variations: Google (4.2 stars), BBB (1 star with A+ business rating), Yelp (1.5 stars from 8 reviews)
• Mixed client experiences: Positive reviews mention quality matches and successful relationships, while negative reviews cite limited database size and matching concerns
• BBB complaints: 1 complaint closed within last 3 years
• Service evolution: Expanded from Omaha Love (local focus) to Midwest Matchmaking (regional coverage) in 2018
• Intuitive matching approach: Founder uses intuition-based matching rather than personality tests or formulas

Our team has reviewed more than 200 matchmakers and their services, diving deep into their operations, success rates, and customer experiences. These reviews are built on extensive research and a keen understanding of the matchmaking landscape honed over 15+ years of first-hand industry experience.

Membership Types:

• Passive membership: Free database inclusion with no active search
• Private membership: Active matching starting at $1,800 (6 months) or $3,600 (12 months)
• Premium packages: Higher investment for database privacy and direct work with Quinlan
• Platinum level: Includes scouting outside Midwest Matchmaking database

Payment Structure:

• Contract lengths vary (6-12 months typical)
• No guaranteed number of matches
• One match presented at a time as identified

Google Reviews (4.2 stars): Positive experiences include successful matches and quality introductions. Negative reviews express frustration with the matching process and limited options.

Better Business Bureau (1 star, A+ rating): A single review from a client who was dissatisfied with the number of matches she claimed to have received. BBB shows 1 complaint closed in recent years.

Yelp Reviews (1.5 stars): Limited reviews show predominantly negative experiences, with only one 5-star review among 8 total reviews.

Getting Started:

1. Short online form submission
2. Initial consultation covering dating goals and service options
3. Contract signing for private membership

Matching Process:

• Matches from paying clients and database members
• Profile and photo review before acceptance/decline
• Mutual approval required before date arrangement
• Post-date feedback surveys for both parties

This midwest matchmaker has been in the love business since 2006, after she graduated from the University of Nebraska. 

Quinlan tells SmartMatchApp that she didn’t plan to become a matchmaker. She “fell into this career” and it ignited her passion for making love connections that last. 

In 2009, Quinlan broke away from the dating service company she was working for to begin her own. She called it Omaha Love Matchmaking, which specialized in connecting singles around Omaha. It was voted the area’s “Best Dating Service” from 2016 to 2019. 

In her interview with SmartMatchApp, Quinlan briefly touches on the matchmaking process that’s helped her build her business: “I’ve always matched with intuition, so I don’t use any kind of formulas or personality tests.”

In 2018, Omaha Love was renamed Midwest Matchmaking when they expanded their services to cover the entire Midwest. 

Now their service represents singles in Nebraska, St. Louis, Des Moines, Minneapolis, and Kansas City.

Quinlan also offers “Love Coach” sessions. These date coaching sessions are available for clients and non-clients who wish to work on building their personal skills for long-lasting relationships.

Clients are typically busy professionals who range in age from their early 20s to mid-80s, with her largest bracket being clients in their 30s to 50s.

In an interview with KC Women’s Magazine, Quinlan explained that her service gives clients “the exposure to the quality of men/women that they are currently lacking.”

Potential clients start by filling out a short form on their website before being contacted for an initial consultation.

During this first appointment, you can expect to share what type of singles you’re hoping to meet. You’ll also learn about the Midwest Matchmaking membership options, cost, etc. (More on price coming right up!)

If you decide to hire this boutique matchmaker, you’ll be matched with other clients as well as with singles who have a profile included in the Midwest Matchmaking database. After reviewing a profile and a photo, you can accept or pass on each match as it’s presented to you. 

When both halves of a pairing say “yes”, Quinlan and her team arrange the date and time for the date. It’s up to you and your match to decide if you’d like to meet in person or via video, and where you’d like to meet. 

You’ll both receive a post-date survey where you can provide feedback. At that point you can decide to go on a second date, or request your next match.

A passive membership is free, but you’ll only have a profile included in their database. This means that Quinlan and her team won’t proactively search for matches on your behalf, so you’ll only be contacted if your profile is compatible with a paying client’s specifications.

For a proactive search done on your behalf, you’ll need a Private membership. There are several levels available, with contracts in varying lengths. 

A 6-month membership starts around $1,800 and a 12-month membership starts around $3,600. Several factors affect the cost, including the level of service you want, and if you want to browse the database on your own or have a matchmaker select profiles for you. 

Having your profile kept private in the database requires a larger investment, as does working directly with Quinlan. At the “Platinum” level of membership, Quinlan’s team will scout outside of the Midwest Matchmaking database for compatible singles.

There is no guaranteed number of matches during the course of your contract. Paid members are promised “active matching”, but you’ll receive them one at a time, as they are identified.

Curious what previous clients have to say about their Midwest Matchmaking experience? Let’s take a look at some matchmaking service reviews…

This Nebraska matchmaking service is accredited by the BBB, and has an A+ rating.

There is a single client review, resulting in a 1 out of 5 star customer review rating. However Midwest Matchmaking responded via the BBB platform saying the description of her experience was not accurate.

There was also 1 BBB complaint for Midwest Matchmaking closed within the last 3 years.

Midwest Matchmaking has far more reviews on Google, with a 4.2 rating based on 100+ reviews.

Many reviewers like these three reported a positive experience:

But there were a handful of negative Google reviews for Midwest Matchmaking and Courtney Quinlan. For example, this reviewer expressed frustration with the matching process:

Midwest Matchmaking has 8 Yelp reviews, resulting in a 1.5-star Yelp rating.

There is a single 5-star review, left before the service had rebranded to Midwest Matchmaking:

The remaining reviewers gave the service a single star. The most common complaints were lack of matches and inconsistent communication.

Reviews can provide helpful insights, and how a company responds on a review platform can be an enlightening peek into their approach to customer service. But reviews also need to be considered with a grain of salt.

When you’re considering which matchmaking service to hire, it ultimately comes down to how you feel about certain aspects of the service. Budget is a consideration, as is where your matches will come from.

Some services, like Midwest Matchmaking, count scouting outside of their existing database as a premium perk. That means your package will be more expensive if you want to cast a wider net. 

And while your soulmate might have signed up for the same service you chose, keep in mind that compatibility has to flow in both directions. That’s why making quality matches requires an extensive database, and if the matchmaker you end up hiring doesn’t have one, you may end up meeting matches who are available rather than compatible.

If you’re looking for a matchmaking service with an extensive reach, consider VIDA Select! Thanks to a modern approach, VIDA’s matchmakers have access to the largest pool of eligible singles there is. 

That means you can look forward to better first dates with singles who check all your boxes. As a client, you’ll get to approve all your matches based on a profile and photos. And here’s another way VIDA stands out from the competition - no long-term contracts!

VIDA offers matchmaking packages on a pay-as-you-go basis, so you won’t have to commit to  6 months to a year of service you may not end up needing. 

Want to learn more about VIDA Select? Go here!