Hunting Maven Reviews [Best NY Matchmaker For You?]

Hunting Maven is a New York City matchmaking service founded in 2010 by Julia Bekker, who trained for 8 years under celebrity matchmaker Janis Spindel. Packages range from $5,000 for 3 introductions to $25,000+ for comprehensive matching with 12 introductions. Bekker primarily works with professional men aged 30–60, while women can join the database for free. Online reviews are extremely limited—just 2 Google reviews (both 5 stars)—making independent verification of client satisfaction difficult.

Hunting Maven at a Glance

Quick Verdict: Is Hunting Maven Worth It?

Worth considering if: You want a matchmaker with elite training credentials—Bekker spent 8 years working alongside Janis Spindel before launching her own service. Her thorough vetting process (including home visits and background checks) suggests she takes client quality seriously. The tiered pricing ($5,000–$25,000+) provides flexibility based on how many introductions you want, and the $379/month coaching option offers lower-commitment access to her expertise.

Think twice if: The extremely limited review history concerns you. With only 2 Google reviews and no presence on Yelp, BBB, or Trustpilot, it's very difficult to independently verify client satisfaction rates or identify patterns in the matchmaking experience. If you need substantial social proof before committing thousands of dollars, you may want to explore services with more robust review histories.

Bottom line: Bekker has strong training credentials and a clear process, but the lack of public reviews means you're largely relying on your consultation impression and any references she provides.

How We Researched This Review

We analyzed Hunting Maven's available reviews, researched founder interviews across multiple publications, and compared the offering to other NYC-area matchmakers.

Disclaimer: This review was researched and written by VIDA Select's matchmaking experts to help singles find the service that best fits their needs and goals. Our industry insights come from 15+ years of matchmaking experience and writing 200+ matchmaking service reviews.

Prior to starting her own firm, Julia Bekker gained experience working for an elite matchmaking service headquartered in New York City. Bekker was offered an executive assistant and event planner position at Serious Matchmaking, where she spent 8 years working closely with well-known millionaire matchmaker Janis Spindel. 

During this time, her passion for matchmaking grew, eventually leading her to establish her own service, Hunting Maven, in 2010.

As she shared in an interview, the name reflects her commitment to searching for matches.

Bekker says matchmaking is more than a job. She considers it to be her true purpose in life, stating, 

“It’s not just my profession; I consider it my calling. I find it very rewarding to help people attain something so special and rare.” 

She also believes connecting people has always been a part of her character. As she puts it, 

“I’ve always been a natural connector, I really get people, and I think they feel that.”

Two years after opening Hunting Maven in NYC, she expanded down into South Florida, co-founding Love Boss Matchmaking. 

Step 1: Initial Consultation

The matchmaking process begins with an initial consultation where men interested in hiring Bekker express their relationship expectations and desires.

Step 2: Vetting Process

Prior to signing clients, Bekker often conducts home visits and background checks to ensure they're a good fit for her services. This thorough vetting distinguishes her approach from matchmakers who rely solely on phone or video consultations.

Step 3: Contract and Search

If both parties agree to move forward, a contract is signed and matchmaking begins. Bekker utilizes her network of singles and conducts personalized searches to identify potential matches.

As she puts it, “I possess a network of high-quality singles and also scout outside my network. It’s like having a personal love hunter.” 

Step 4: Ongoing Scouting

Bekker says she's always looking to expand her network. As she mentioned in an interview, “I love to help and empower people and see them happy and achieving their goals. Seeing their transformation brings me so much joy.” 

Step 5: Feedback Loop

After each introduction, clients provide feedback sharing insights on compatibility and personal impressions, helping Bekker refine the search.

Additional Services

Beyond matchmaking, Hunting Maven offers:

• Personalized coaching
• Image consulting
• On-demand dating advice ($379/month)

Hunting Maven offers a menu of options tailored to individual preferences and needs. Prices range from $5,000 for 3 introductions to $25,000 for 12 introductions.

It’s free for women to join her singles database, however, as a non-paying client you’ll only ever be contacted if you meet the criteria for a paying client. 

Personalized coaching and dating consulting services are available for an additional fee. For those seeking immediate guidance, Bekker offers "on-demand" dating advice for $379 per month. 

How Hunting Maven Compares to Other NYC Matchmakers

Hunting Maven has extremely limited online reviews, making independent assessment of client satisfaction difficult.

Hunting Maven only has 2 older reviews on Google, resulting in a 5-star rating:

Both 5-star reviews praised Bekker’s matchmaking acumen and mentioned they were in relationships as a result of working with Hunting Maven.

Hunting Maven has a listing on Yelp but has not been reviewed yet. This elite matchmaking service also has yet to be reviewed on platforms like Trustpilot and BBB.

Why So Few Reviews?

Limited online reviews aren't unusual for elite matchmaking services—clients often prize confidentiality and may be reluctant to publicly discuss their use of a matchmaker. However, the lack of reviews does make it challenging to identify patterns in client experiences or verify satisfaction rates independently.