One On One Matchmaking Review [Best ATL Matchmaker For You?]

One On One Matchmaking is a boutique Atlanta matchmaking service founded by Sarah Kathryn Walmsley in 2008. Packages cost between $3,500 and $10,000 for a minimum of 10 guaranteed matches. The service holds a 4.7-star rating on Google and 4.5 stars on Yelp. Clients are matched with other paying clients and singles from the Eight At Eight database. Reviews praise successful matches and overall experience, though some clients note limited options in certain age ranges.

Key Insights:

• Sarah Kathryn Walmsley founded One On One Matchmaking in 2008; she also owns Eight At Eight, which she purchased in 1998
• Matchmaking packages cost between $3,500 and $10,000 for a minimum of 10 guaranteed matches
• Pricing varies based on search difficulty and extras like home visits and date coaching
• Clients are matched with other paying clients plus singles from the Eight At Eight database
• The service holds a 4.7-star rating on Google and 4.5 stars on Yelp
• Positive reviews highlight successful matches; critical reviews cite limited options in some age ranges
• The office is located at 3102 Roswell Road NW in Atlanta

Our team of matchmaking experts has reviewed over 200 services, researching key aspects like cost, process, and client experiences. With over 16 years of industry experience, we know first-hand what customers value most in a matchmaker.

Sarah Kathryn Walmsley started her matchmaking career early, purchasing Eight At Eight Dinner Club for $2,000 in 1998 when she was just 22 years old. Eight At Eight is a dinner-party-style matchmaking service that brings together groups of singles for hosted events.

In 2008, she launched One On One Matchmaking as a "VIP" option for Atlanta clients who prefer traditional one-on-one dates over group dinner settings.

The One On One Matchmaking office is located at 3102 Roswell Road NW in Atlanta.

The process begins by filling out an online form to request an appointment. You'll answer several screens of questions to create a mini-profile and can upload up to 5 photos.

Based on your responses, a matchmaker will reach out to schedule a personal interview if she thinks you're someone they can work with. This in-person meeting lasts about an hour and covers your dating history, relationship goals, and background information.

Once you become a client, you're matched with other paying clients as well as singles from the Eight At Eight database. All date details are pre-arranged on your behalf.

After each date, your matchmaker follows up with your match to gather feedback. This information helps refine future searches and provides coaching opportunities to improve your overall dating approach.

One On One Matchmaking charges between $3,500 and $10,000 for a minimum of 10 guaranteed matches.

The price range depends on how challenging your matchmaker expects your search to be based on your criteria, plus whether you want extras like home visits and date coaching.

The specific number of guaranteed matches during your contract term is determined during your initial consultation.

One On One Matchmaking has positive ratings across major review platforms, with some clients reporting successful relationships and others noting limitations.

Yelp: 4.5 Stars

One on One Matchmaking recommended reviews on Yelp are mostly positive, earning them a solid 4-star rating.

This client said she was using One on One to get back into the Atlanta dating scene:

This client was happy with the overall experience:

Other clients weren’t quite so happy with the Atlanta singles they were matched with, or the customer service they received:

Better Business Bureau

There are no One on One Matchmaking BBB reviews, and one complaint, although it wasn't immediately clear if the person had used the service or only had a consultation. 

Google: 4.6 Stars

Google reviews for One on One Matchmaking are mostly positive, resulting in a 4.6-star rating. Both of these clients met someone through the service:

This client hadn’t met the right person yet, but was pleased with her matches so far:

On the other end of the spectrum, this client felt like there weren’t many matches in her age range:

And this client felt like they weren’t using any particular screening criteria for selecting matches:

Maria Avgitidis, owner of Agape Match in New York City, also left a Google review praising this Atlanta matchmaking service:

So is this the best Atlanta matchmaker for you?

Only you can answer that - but hopefully the One on One Matchmaking reviews you just read will give you some guidance.

One On One Matchmaking offers a straightforward boutique matchmaking experience with guaranteed introductions and post-date feedback. The pricing is mid-range compared to other professional matchmakers, and the strong Yelp and Google ratings suggest most clients have positive experiences.

The service works best for Atlanta singles comfortable with the $3,500–$10,000 investment for 10+ matches, those who want guaranteed introductions with post-date coaching, and singles whose criteria align well with the existing client base and Eight At Eight database.

There are some factors to consider. Boutique matchmaking services that match clients primarily with other clients may have limited options in certain demographics or age ranges—a concern raised in some reviews. You're also committing to and paying for the full contract upfront before experiencing the service.

For singles seeking more flexibility, VIDA Select, offers month-to-month matchmaking with no long-term contracts. VIDA's matchmakers have access to Atlanta's largest pool of eligible singles, so you're not limited to an internal database. You pre-approve every match based on profiles and photos, ensuring you're excited about every first date. Most clients meet someone special within 3 months.

Ready to explore your options? Schedule a free, confidential consultation to see which approach fits your goals.