Pittsburgh Matchmaker Top List [Cost And Reviews!]

The 3 best Pittsburgh matchmakers range from $1,595/month (VIDA Select) to $20,000+ (Enamour). Top options include VIDA Select for contract flexibility and largest database access and Enamour for successful professionals seeking a luxury service. Most matchmakers require 12-month contracts with upfront payments, though VIDA Select offers month-to-month packages with 90-day average success rates.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 11/27/2025

Key Takeaways:

• Contract flexibility differs significantly: VIDA Select offers month-to-month packages starting at $1,595 while traditional services typically require 12-month commitments paid up front.
• Database sizes impact match variety: Traditional local matchmakers often maintain a limited database of match candidates, while others like VIDA Select and Enamour take a tech-driven approach that leverages Pittsburgh's largest pool of eligible singles.
• Pittsburgh matchmaking services primarily cater to accomplished professionals between 30 and 75 seeking serious relationships, offering varying levels of personalized service and coaching support.

Disclaimer: This guide was researched and written by VIDA Select's editorial team to help singles find the service that best fits their needs and goals. As a matchmaking service ourselves, we bring a unique industry perspective. Our insights come from 17+ years of matchmaking experience, writing 200+ matchmaking service reviews, analyzing public information and reviews on reputable platforms, and feedback from clients who used other services before hiring VIDA. While this guide is updated regularly, it may not reflect current pricing for all services.

Our team of matchmaking experts has created this guide to help singles in Pittsburgh narrow down their options and find the best matchmaker.

VIDA Select (by Scott Valdez)

Scott Valdez’s matchmaking team isn’t limited to a small internal rolodex. They dive right into Pittsburgh’s largest pool of eligible singles! That means you can look forward to dates with matches who meet all your relationship “must haves.” 

Thanks to a powerful combination of tech and intuition, VIDA Select has modern matchmaking down to a science.

Clientele

VIDA Select works with accomplished, relationship-minded singles, generally in their late 20s to 60s.

Cost & Contract

Monthly service begins at $1,595. There is also a "90-Day Match Guarantee" package that provides at least 5 curated matches you personally approve for $5,750. Guaranteed results or the search continues at no additional cost.

On average, clients meet someone special within 3 months of beginning service.

What To Expect

VIDA Select’s matchmaking process starts with a quick online screening, as not every Pittsburgh single qualifies for the service.

The next step is an initial consultation, which is free. You’ll learn all about how the service works, share your dating goals and more. 

Once you’ve chosen the service level that fits you best, you’ll meet your dedicated personal matchmaker! During this 90-minute interview, she’ll learn all about you, your lifestyle, and your ideal partner criteria.

Then, the VIDA Select team gets to work! No disappointing blind dates with Pittsburgh singles who don’t meet any of your benchmarks, because you’ll have the opportunity to review potential match profiles and approve each one.

Your matchmaker is with you throughout every step of the process. And VIDA Select offers additional services like dating coaching and personal styling, so you’ll walk into every date with confidence.

Enamour

An international service with a presence in Pittsburgh, Enamour's team of seasoned matchmakers has been helping clients find their ideal partners since 2009.

Clientele

Enamour caters to successful, discerning professionals seeking a high-end, tailored matchmaking experience.

Cost & Contract

Matchmaking packages start around $20,000 for 6 months of service.

What To Expect

As a client, you'll be paired with a dedicated personal matchmaker. She'll learn all about you, your lifestyle and hobbies, and your ideal partner criteria during an information-gathering interview, and work with you to adjust your search as needed throughout the process.

The search for highly compatible matches begins within Enamour's exclusive, invitation-only database. But the team also uses a combination of AI and recruiting technology to pinpoint exceptional candidates from a variety of online and offline sources.

Each potential match is vetted via an in-person or video screening process, and dates can be arranged for you. After each introduction, your matchmaker will check in with both you and your match. You'll have the opportunity to provide feedback, as well as receive valuable guidance and insights into your dating process.

Enamour also offers a variety of complementary services, including personal styling, dating and relationship coaching, and image consulting.

The Modern Matchmaker (by Susan Dunhoff)

Located in Squirrel Hill, professional matchmaker Susan Dunhoff helps singles in the Greater Pittsburgh area. She has a background in marketing & communications, but has been matchmaking for over 30 years. 

As Dunhoff explained in an interview with P100, she was having trouble finding relationship worthy singles to date while running her marketing firm. 

Realizing there were other busy professionals in her same situation, she began matchmaking “on the side” for around 8 years before launching The Modern Matchmaker.

Clientele

Most of Dunhoff’s clients are between 35 & 75. She describes them as selective professionals who value their confidentiality. 

Cost & Contract

Matchmaking contracts last for 12 months. Dunhoff offers a guaranteed number of matches, which is specified in your contract.

Matchmaking services come at three levels, starting with database access to selected matches. At the higher package levels, Dunhoff will scout outside her internal database of around 1,000 singles. 

She doesn’t disclose her pricing online, but based on media articles her services start around several thousand dollars.

What To Expect

Singles interested in learning more about this Pittsburgh matchmaker start with an in person or video consultation. You’ll also submit a profile form, which you and Dunhoff will go over during the call.

This information helps her “get on the same wavelength” about what’s important to you in a relationship.

She’ll also go over the membership options, all of which involve a year-long contract. At the lowest level of service, you’ll have the ability to review profiles of selected matches in her internal database. 

If you opt for one of the more expensive memberships, Dunhoff will scout for singles outside of her rolodex as well.

When both you and your prospective match are interested in meeting, she will schedule a date. Afterwards, she welcomes feedback about how the date went, match quality, etc. so that she can adjust her search as needed.

Further Reading

The Modern Matchmaker Reviews