Single Atlanta Reviews [Best Matchmaking Service For You?]

Single Atlanta Matchmakers is a Georgia-based matchmaking service founded by Leisha Murphy in 1998, now run alongside her twin sister Lisa Lyngos. Serving singles statewide, packages reportedly range from $1,000 to $15,000 with no set timeline—you're guaranteed a specific number of introductions rather than months of service. Reviews are mixed: 4 stars on Google but just 2 stars on Yelp (55 reviews), with some clients finding partners and others citing concerns about match quality.

Key Insights:

• Leisha Murphy founded Single Atlanta in 1998; twin sister Lisa Lyngos serves as managing director
• Packages reportedly cost $1,000–$15,000 with negotiable pricing based on individual circumstances
• Contracts guarantee a number of introductions rather than a service timeline—dates come as matches become available
• Matches come from the client database; no AI algorithms are used ("we match people, not profiles")
• Higher-tier packages include pre-screening with photos before introductions
• Reviews are mixed: 4 stars on Google, 2 stars on Yelp (over half of 55 reviews are 1-star)
• The service collaborates with other local and national matchmakers to expand reach

Our team has reviewed over 200 matchmaking services, researching their processes, success rates, and customer experiences. Our reviews are built on extensive research and a keen understanding of the matchmaking industry.

Single Atlanta Matchmakers, also known as Atlanta Matchmakers, was founded by Leisha Murphy in 1998. Today, her twin sister Lisa Lyngos stands by her side as the firm's managing director.

The service works with singles all over Georgia, though clients can request to meet only local singles (such as Atlanta-area professionals specifically).

The twins take a personal, human-centered approach to matchmaking, rejecting algorithmic matching in favor of intuition and experience.

As Lyngos mentioned in an interview, they don’t rely on any AI algorithms for the matching process.

“We don’t use any complicated computer algorithms. After all, how can a computer really understand your values, your preferences, your desires… your story? When it comes to finding love, we believe in a personal touch.”

This philosophy is reflected in the company’s tagline: “Simply put, we match people, not profiles.”

The service advertises throughout Georgia, matching clients from mid-20s through their 80s. You can specify geographic preferences in your contract—for instance, requesting only Atlanta-area singles.

Atlanta Matchmakers also collaborates with other local and national matchmakers, which expands their network of potential matches beyond their internal database.

Prospective clients complete an online form or call directly to schedule an in-person consultation with a relationship consultant.

During this meeting, you'll discuss yourself and your ideal partner criteria. Lyngos explains their process this way, 

“They tell us their stories and together we are able to build a profile of the type of person they would like to meet. This is where our experience really counts. … We know precisely how to successfully guide them through the process.”

You'll also learn about membership options and pricing. If you sign up, they create a "profile card" entered into their database.

The Matching Process

Matches are selected from the client database—you'll be introduced to other paying clients typically ranging from mid-20s to 80s.

When your matchmaker finds a suitable match, you're notified. The amount of information you receive depends on your membership level. More comprehensive packages include a pre-screening option where you can see a photograph before the introduction is arranged.

After each date, you can call your matchmaker to discuss feedback on match quality.

No Timeline, Guaranteed Introductions

Unlike services with set contract lengths, Atlanta Matchmakers guarantees an agreed-upon number of introductions rather than a timeline. Introductions are made as matches become available in the database—which could happen quickly or take considerable time.

You won’t find any pricing or membership options detailed on their website, as this matchmaking duo prefers to discuss the particulars face to face during the sales pitch.

Based on available information, packages generally range from $1,000 to $15,000 depending on membership option.

Negotiable Pricing

According to company responses to BBB complaints, pricing appears negotiable based on individual circumstances. While variable pricing is common in matchmaking (factoring in cities, number of matches, timeline, financial situation), it means different clients may pay different amounts for similar services.

Negotiable pricing is nothing new in the matchmaking industry, however.

Depending on the matchmaking service, prices often vary by client. It can depend on factors like how many cities you’d like to date in, how many singles you want to meet in what length of time, your individual financial situation, etc.

But if you’re uncomfortable with variable pricing, there are options. Many matchmaking services, like VIDA Select, offer a fixed price menu so everyone pays the same amount for a particular level of service.

Reviews for Single Atlanta Matchmakers are mixed across platforms.

Google: 4 Stars

Google reviews are mostly positive. Clients mention positive experiences with matchmakers and the overall process.

This client mentioned a positive experience with his matchmaker and the entire process:

This reviewer also complimented the team and shared that she’s engaged:

Yelp: 2 Stars (55 Reviews)

Yelp reviews are more critical, with over half of the 55 reviews being 1-star.

Several of the 1-star reviewers mentioned that their matches didn’t meet their specified criteria:

Among the Atlanta Matchmakers Yelp reviews, there were a handful of 5-star ratings. 

This client said she met someone special with wedding bells in their future:

Better Business Bureau

Single Atlanta is not accredited with the BBB, but it has an A+ rating. There are no Single Atlanta BBB reviews or complaints currently listed.

Only you can decide if Single Atlanta is the right choice for you. See how you feel after the initial consultation, whether that’s in person or by phone. Take some time to consider all your options before making an expensive commitment to any Atlanta matchmaking service.

Single Atlanta Matchmakers offers a personal, human-centered approach with nearly three decades of experience in Georgia. The twins' "people, not profiles" philosophy appeals to clients who value intuition over algorithms.

The service works best for Georgia singles seeking a traditional, relationship-focused matchmaking approach, those comfortable with negotiable pricing and in-person consultations, or clients who prefer guaranteed introductions over fixed timelines.

There are factors worth considering carefully. The introduction-based model (rather than time-based) means dates come as matches become available, which could take time. Working with a restricted database could also be a potential drawback, as someone who comes close to what you’re looking for may or may not be a client.    

Mixed Yelp reviews (2 stars, with over half being 1-star) suggest inconsistent experiences. Variable pricing means you may pay differently than other clients for similar services. 

For singles seeking transparent pricing and access to a larger dating pool, VIDA Select offers month-to-month matchmaking starting at $1,595 with no long-term contracts. You pre-approve every match based on full profiles with photos, and VIDA's matchmakers leverage the largest pool of Atlanta singles available. 82% of clients meet someone special within 3 months.

Ready to explore your options? Schedule a free, confidential consultation to see which approach fits your goals.