Best Tampa Bay Matchmaking Services [With 2026 Cost Comparison!]

The 3 best Tampa Bay matchmakers range from $1,595/month (VIDA Select) to $1,000,000+ (Serious Matchmaking). Top options include VIDA Select for contract flexibility and unlimited matches and Serious Matchmaking for ultra-wealthy men ($25,000-$1M+). Most Tampa matchmakers require annual contracts with substantial upfront fees.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 12/04/2025

Key Takeaways:

• VIDA Select offers flexible matchmaking starting at $1,595/month—ideal for Tampa Bay singles who want to meet highly compatible matches. No blind dates here!
• LUMA Luxury Matchmaking provides personalized matchmaking for professionals, with packages ranging from $15,000 to $200,000+. 
• Serious Matchmaking (Janis & Carly Spindel) caters to wealthy men, with service costs ranging from $25,000 to $1,000,000+ and access to women who meet screening criteria.

Our team of matchmaking experts compiled this guide to help Tampa Bay singles connect with the right matchmaker. With industry experience dating back to 2009, we've written over 200 reviews, leveraging our knowledge and understanding of what clients value most across central Florida's dating landscape.

This insider’s guide to the best Tampa Bay matchmakers is the perfect place to start your search!

Matchmaker: Scott Valdez

Service: VIDA Select

Looking for a Tampa Bay matchmaking service but don’t want to lock yourself into a long-term contract?

VIDA Select offers pay-per-month pricing, meaning you only pay for the time you actually want to meet incredible singles. With the ability to pause, re-start and stop as needed, you’re in complete control of the matchmaking process.

You can choose from a spectrum of matchmaking packages, all designed around how many monthly hours should be involved in the quest to find your perfect match.

Clientele

Successful, accomplished and selective single professionals in their 20s to 60s who are looking for a serious relationship.

Cost

• Monthly Matchmaking: Starting at $1,595 with no long-term commitment.

• Results Guarantee Package: 5+ curated matches you personally approve within 90 days for $5,750—guaranteed results or our work continues at no extra cost.

With an 82% success rate, most VIDA clients meet someone special in just 3 months!

What People Are Saying About VIDA Select

On Trustpilot, VIDA Select holds a 4.5-star rating based on over 400 reviews. 

The majority of reviews gave the service 5 stars, with many people sharing that they enjoyed working with their matchmaker, like this person: 

This individual appreciated the smooth process, quality introductions, and helpful dating advice: 

What To Expect From This Tampa Bay Matchmaker:

As with most elite matchmakers, the first step in the process is an initial consultation to see if the dating service is a good fit for both parties.

Next, you and your personal matchmaker will have an in-depth interview, during which you’ll discuss everything from your lifestyle and match criteria to your relationship goals and history.

Your matchmaker then uses all that information to select highly compatible singles from the Tampa Bay area’s single largest pool of eligible singles.

You’ll have the opportunity to review each potential match - including photos - so you can focus on meeting people you’re genuinely attracted to.

VIDA Select offers an array of additional services designed to help you make the best possible impression, such as personal styling, professional photo editing and dating coaching.

Ready to finally meet that special someone in the Tampa Bay area?

Schedule your free, quick and confidential consultation here!

Matchmakers: Janis & Carly Spindel

Service: Serious Matchmaking

This mother/daughter matchmaking team is actually based in New York City, but they’ve expanded their service to include over 20 large cities around the country - including Tampa.

Clientele

Affluent men (according to Janis Spindel their typical client’s annual income is more than $1,000,000.)

Cost

$25,000 - $1,000,000. There is also a signing fee (starting at $65,000) and a finder’s fee of the same rate. The finder’s fee is due if you are in a relationship with a match for a year, get engaged, or move in together.

What People Are Saying About Serious Matchmaking

Janis Spindel’s Serious Matchmaking has mixed reviews listed on Yelp, resulting in a 3.0-star rating.  

This reviewer mentioned that the service was excellent and was hopeful about being connected with the right men in the future: 

This person shared that a positive experience working directly with Janis: 

What To Expect From These Tampa Bay Matchmakers:

Women can pay a $250 - $1250 fee to be placed into the Serious Matchmaking database (provided they pass the screening interview). But this comes with no guarantee of being matched with a paying client.

For men, the matchmaking process starts by meeting with either Carly Spindel or her mom Janis. After getting to know you and who you’re looking for, they’ll decide whether or not to take you on as a client.

Each year-long contract includes at least 12 matches, and details like the scope your search are customized. Potential matches come from the Serious Matchmaking database, or via scouting efforts in your “dating radius.”

Further Reading

Serious Matchmaking Reviews

Matchmaker: April Davis

Service: LUMA Luxury Matchmaking

April Davis’s upscale matchmaking service isn’t exclusive to the Tampa Bay area - LUMA is based in Minneapolis with locations around the US.

Clientele

Generally successful professionals who are in their 20s to 60s and seeking a long-term, serious relationship.

Cost

$15,000 - $200,000+

What People Are Saying About LUMA Matchmaking 

On Yelp, LUMA carries a 5-star rating based on fewer than 10 reviews. 

This individual is a member of their database, mentioning that the process is fun & easy: 

And this person met someone special through the service: 

What To Expect From These Tampa Bay Matchmakers:

LUMA’s professional matchmakers typically work with a limited roster of clients at any one time, so the first step is a screening process to determine if the service is a good fit for you (and vice versa).

You also have the option of joining the database of 25k+ singles in the LUMA network, which is free. However as a non-paying member, you’ll only be contacted when/if a matchmaker thinks you fit the profile of what a client is looking for in a match.

As a paying client, you’ll sign a 6-month contract that also includes the option to pause your service one time for a month. The details of each membership contract will be customized for each client - factors such as how specific you want your matchmaker to be when identifying potential matches all affect the final cost of your matchmaking service.

Your matches come from LUMA’s database, or if you’ve included the “personal search” service your matchmaker will scout outside of that as well. After each introduction has been made (either an in-person or a video date), both you and your match are expected to report back as to how it went.

Like many upscale matchmaking services, LUMA offers additional services such as dating coaching and personal styling.

Further Reading

LUMA Luxury Matchmaking Reviews