VIDA Select vs Agape Match: Cost And Process Compared

The clearest difference between VIDA Select and Agape Match comes down to how each service is structured.

Agape Match is built around a boutique, high-touch model. Founder Maria Avgitidis is a fourth-generation matchmaker, and the service typically works with 15 to 20 clients at a time. Maria has said she only takes on clients she believes have a strong chance of being successfully matched. That selectivity will appeal to singles who want a very traditional matchmaking experience and are comfortable making a substantial upfront investment.

VIDA Select is built around flexibility, offering monthly matchmaking starting at $1,695. Clients continue for as long as they need the service, without being locked into a long-term contract. There is also a 90-day Match Guarantee package that includes a minimum of 5 curated matches, along with other service options.

Agape Match is a premium service with pricing to match. Matchmaking packages for men range from $30,000 to $100,000 for 6 months of active searching and a minimum of 6 introductions. There may also be a $5,000 success fee if a relationship with an Agape match lasts 6+ months.

VIDA Select's monthly matchmaking starts at $1,695, and VIDA also offers a 90-Day Match Guarantee package that includes at least 5 highly curated matches for $6,000.

For many singles, price is a deciding factor. Agape Match is worth considering if budget is not a major concern and you specifically want a boutique NYC matchmaker. VIDA Select is the more accessible option if you want a professional matchmaker without making a significant investment before the process even begins.

Curious about how these prices stack up to other matchmakers? Check out our complete guide to matchmaker cost!

Both services offer curated introductions, but the process works a little differently for service.

Agape Match follows a traditional matchmaking model. Paying clients start with an in-person consultation, then move into an active search. Once a match is identified, the team plans the date and provides post-date feedback.

Agape also has a free database option for women. Free database members are not receiving an active search; they are waiting to be selected as potential matches for paying clients.

VIDA Select also offers traditional matchmaking, but the process is more flexible and modern. Instead of relying only on its private member database, VIDA's team also searches across a much larger pool of compatible singles. Clients review full match profiles, including photos, before agreeing to meet, so you stay in control of who makes it onto your calendar.

That review-before-you-meet structure is a major distinction for singles who do not want blind dates. You can evaluate someone's profile, photos, and compatibility before deciding whether to move forward.

Definition: Curated Introduction

An introduction to a single person who has been individually screened and personally selected by a matchmaker based on the client's specific compatibility criteria, rather than algorithmically suggested or pulled from a fixed database without active vetting.

One of the most important questions to ask any matchmaker is: where do your matches actually come from?

Agape Match sources potential matches from its own database and through Maria Avgitidis's professional network, including the Matchmaker's Alliance. That can be valuable, especially in a relationship-driven market like New York City.

But there is a natural limitation to any database-based model: your ideal partner has to already be in that network, or reachable through it.

VIDA Select takes a broader approach. Rather than limiting the search to the internal database, VIDA's matchmakers proactively identify compatible singles from the largest available pool of relationship-minded people. That can be especially helpful if your criteria are hyper-specific, you live outside NYC, or you want to maximize the number of high-quality people your matchmaker can consider.

If you do not live in or near New York City, geography may be the deciding factor in this comparison.

Agape Match is headquartered in New York City. Its primary service area covers New York, New Jersey, Philadelphia, Boston, Chicago, and Washington DC. Maria also works with Greek singles across North America and internationally. Outside of those Northeast markets, the match pool thins out quickly.

VIDA Select works with single professionals across the United States and internationally. The team can search any major metropolitan area, which means clients are not limited by whether they happen to live near the matchmaker's home office. The size and quality of your local match pool is one of the biggest factors in how quickly you meet someone compatible.

Agape Match will appeal to singles who want to hand over more of the process to a matchmaker. The service handles date planning and provides feedback after dates. For some busy professionals, that hands-off structure is part of the appeal.

VIDA Select is a better fit if you want expert help, but still want visibility and control. VIDA clients review curated matches before deciding whether to meet them. That means you are not showing up to dates based only on a matchmaker's judgment.

This is an important distinction for singles who care about physical attraction, lifestyle fit, and dealbreakers. A matchmaker's recommendation matters, but so does your own sense of whether you are excited to meet someone.

Choose Agape Match If You:

• Are based in or near New York City.

• Want a highly boutique matchmaking experience with a small client roster.

• Are comfortable investing $30,000 to $100,000 upfront.

• Prefer a traditional, full-service model where the matchmaker handles most of the process.

• Want to work with a founder-led service with deep NYC matchmaking roots.

• Are comfortable with a database and network-driven search.

• Are open to a blind-dating approach without seeing photos in advance.

Choose VIDA Select If You:

• Want professional matchmaking without a $30,000+ upfront commitment.

• Prefer a month-to-month structure instead of a 6-month contract.

• Want to review full profiles before agreeing to any date.

• Live outside NYC or want a broader, proactive search strategy.

• Want access to a larger pool of compatible singles.

• Are serious about finding a relationship but do not want to pay for active search time you may not need.

• Prefer a modern matchmaking process with more transparency and client control.

Book a complimentary consultation with a VIDA matchmaker to learn more.