Meet Abby Rosenblum [Best Colorado Matchmaker For You?]

Abby Rosenblum is a Colorado matchmaker who founded The Social: Modern Matchmaking in 2018 and merged with Simply Matchmaking in late 2024. Now working with Simply Matchmaking (offices in Denver, Seattle, and San Diego), Rosenblum helps relationship-ready singles find meaningful connections. Database membership costs $275–$500, while full-service packages typically exceed $10,000 for 12-month contracts with unlimited matches. The Social holds 3.6 stars on Yelp (10 reviews).

Key Insights:

• Abby Rosenblum founded The Social: Modern Matchmaking in 2018; she merged with Simply Matchmaking in late 2024
• Simply Matchmaking has offices in Denver, Seattle, and San Diego
• Database membership costs $275 (virtual interview) or $500 (in-person); full-service packages typically start over $10,000
• All packages run 12 months with unlimited matches and pause flexibility
• Matches aren't guaranteed and fees are non-refundable
• The Social holds 3.6 stars on Yelp (10 reviews)
• Rosenblum's coaching emphasizes mindset, self-confidence, and emotional clarity

Our team of matchmaking experts has reviewed more than 200 matchmakers and their services, diving deep into cost, process, client reviews, and more.

With over 14 years of hands-on experience in matchmaking, we know exactly what clients value most in a dating service.

Abby Rosenblum is a Colorado matchmaker who founded The Social: Modern Matchmaking in 2018. In late 2024, she merged her company with Simply Matchmaking and now works as a professional matchmaker for this growing regional service with offices in Denver, Seattle, and San Diego.

Rosenblum didn't set out to become a matchmaker, but the path unfolded as she searched for something more fulfilling than her 9-to-5.

As she shared in an interview with Canvas Rebel, 

“I wanted to do something to help people and to also utilize my people skills, intuitive skills, and listening skills. I really felt like there was something bigger calling me to help others, and at the time, I wasn’t sure if this would be it.”

Curious and driven to make a difference, Rosenblum looked to her own circle of friends and began casually helping them navigate their dating lives. She’d talk to them, learn about what they were looking for in a partner, and enter all that information into a spreadsheet - her first unofficial client list. 

“I remember doing these interviews in my car with the A/C blasting during a lunch break at my day job! One night out with friends, I came up with the name and the idea, and decided to put up the website.”

While still balancing her day job, she officially launched The Social: Modern Matchmaking in 2018, a boutique service for Colorado singles ready for commitment and aligned with their values. By 2022, she was matchmaking full time.

Her ideal clients? People with passion, stability, and purpose - those who are looking to add love to an already full life.

Rosenblum goes beyond surface-level tips, focusing on mindset, self-confidence, and real connection. She coaches clients one-on-one and shares practical insights through social media and media interviews.

Date Yourself First

One of Rosenblum’s core beliefs is that dating should be as much about personal growth as it is about finding a partner. 

“Remember to date yourself, it helps build confidence through the process. Take yourself out to dinner, by yourself, sit alone, and spend some time with yourself.”

Reframe Setbacks

She also reminds singles not to let a rough patch derail their outlook.

“A change in the seasons can be a perfect time for a change in mindset, it’s important to see every person you meet as one step closer to finding your person. If you feel discouraged or like you’re ‘striking out,’ you may need to reframe the way you’re looking at your love-finding journey.”

Look for Clarity

Clarity is another big theme in her coaching. Rosenblum encourages daters to pay attention to how someone communicates and shows up.

“If someone is serious about you, they’re going to give you clarity, not confusion.”

Keep an Open Mind

And when it comes to those sometimes nerve-wracking first dates? Her advice is simple: “Always remember to enter any first date with an OPEN MIND!”

On Yelp, The Social: Modern Matchmaking has a 3.6-star rating based on 10 reviews.  

This client shared that Rosenblum helped him “feel comfortable and confident throughout the whole process.”

And this client mentioned that she interviewed multiple matchmakers before signing up with Rosenblum, being the “only one who had a formal process and methodology.” 

Simply Matchmaking Pricing:

• Database membership: $275 (virtual) or $500 (in-person)
• Men under 30: Starting around $500
• Full-service membership: Typically $10,000+
• Contract length: 12 months with unlimited matches

Curious how this compares to other Colorado matchmakers? Let's take a look.

Colorado Matchmaker Comparison

Companies like Enamour start around $20,000 and offer a highly selective, curated process. Matches are sourced from an exclusive, invitation-only database or via Enamour’s extensive network of scouts. This elite service helps clients all over the world.  

Kris Kenny Connections has 2 membership packages, Classic and VIP, ranging in price from $4,600 to $16,000. Contracts are typically between 6 and 12 months, with additional hold time available. 

Keeper Introduction Services, owned by matchmaker Gabriella Aratow, is based in Basalt, Colorado. Like Simply Matchmaking, KIS also tends to charge in the five-figure range. While exact pricing is not disclosed on their website, the total cost varies depending on the client’s needs.

VIDA Select is another option for Colorado singles looking for a highly customized matchmaking experience. VIDA Select offers a monthly subscription model with packages starting at $1,595/month.

There is also the "90-Day Match Guarantee" option that includes a minimum of 5 highly curated matches you approve for $5,750. Guaranteed results, or the search continues at no additional cost.

You'll work with a dedicated matchmaker who focuses the search based on your specific criteria, without needing to commit to a long-term contract. Plus, qualified candidates receive a free consultation to get started. With an 82% success rate, VIDA clients typically meet someone special in 3 months.

Whether you're considering Abby Rosenblum, a nationwide boutique firm, or a modern matchmaking service like VIDA Select, it's important to find a fit that aligns with both your goals and your budget.

For those who qualify, the initial consultation is complimentary. See if you qualify here!