Is Cat Cantrill The Best Scottsdale Matchmaker For You?

Cat Cantrill's matchmaking service, originally The Heart Agency in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, relocated to Scottsdale, Arizona and rebranded as "The Scottsdale Matchmaker" in 2025. Packages range from $350-$4,500+, from coaching-only to full matchmaking. The service has a 5-star Google rating (16 reviews) and emphasizes self-empowerment coaching before matching. Note: She doesn't show photos before blind dates.

Key Insights

• Based In Scottsdale: Cat Cantrill moved from Cedar Rapids to Scottsdale, Arizona in 2025 and rebranded from "The Heart Agency" to "The Scottsdale Matchmaker"; she now serves clients in Scottsdale and nationally
• Cost: Services range from $350-$4,500+; lower tier includes 3 months of coaching; higher tiers offer tailored matchmaking; some packages include 3-month hold time
• Reputation: 5-star Google rating (16 reviews under The Heart Agency) plus 5-star rating (9 reviews under Cat Cantrill's name); no Yelp, Trustpilot, or BBB reviews yet
• No photos policy: Cantrill doesn't show photos of matches before blind dates, believing this encourages clients to look beyond surface-level appearances
• Process timeline: Approximately 2 months of getting to know clients before any matching begins; includes personality tests, background checks, and self-led online course
• Match sources: Online dating platforms, social media, agency events, internal database ("The Library"), and partner matchmaker networks

From the small independents to the big industry players, our team of experts has reviewed over 200 matchmaking services. 

Our insight comes from comprehensive research, real customer reviews, and a deep understanding of the matchmaking landscape. With 15+ years of firsthand industry experience, we know what customers value in a service!

Cat Cantrill began her journey connecting people during her tenure as a dance instructor. Originally from Arizona, Cantrill found herself navigating life as a divorcee and a single mother of two in Iowa. 

During this challenging time, she found solace in coaching women at her dance studio in Cedar Rapids. She often found herself providing holistic mentoring, helping her students gain confidence and resilience. 

Over time, the women she coached began asking for advice and guidance in finding their happily ever after.

The support and encouragement from her clients made her realize that she could extend her impact beyond the dance studio, enabling people to find joy in personal relationships. 

Reflecting on her experience, she told The Gazette, 

"I was a matchmaker in that studio. I created a space for people to come together, to have relationships with each other."

Cantrill said she recognized her talent for bringing out the best in people seeing “the good in everyone.” 

In 2022 she decided to take a leap of faith and become a matchmaker, launching The Heart Agency in Cedar Rapids. She has since rebranded as "The Scottsdale Matchmaker", and now operates out of Arizona. She helps clients in Scottsdale as well as nationally.

In addition to matchmaking, Cantrill uses multiple platforms to share her dating insights. She hosts a podcast named "Dear Matchmaker," and organizes live dating game shows such as "Game For Love."

She also frequently shares advice via her podcast, in interviews, and on social media. Here are some of her best dating tips from around the web:

As you might guess from her dating advice, Cat Cantrill's matchmaking philosophy gravitates towards self-empowerment. 

As she puts it, 

"They bring it out themselves. I just give them the tools they need to do it." 

Her approach to matchmaking involves not just identifying potential partners but also guiding her clients to recognize their inner strength.

Cantrill works closely with clients, providing tailored coaching throughout the process. 

One-on-one coaching programs with this Arizona matchmaker involve bi-monthly sessions where clients gain insights into potential obstacles in their love life. The coaching also helps clients gain an understanding of their core values and compatibility parameters, which Cantrill says is instrumental in finding suitable matches.  

While coaching clients, Cantrill encourages them to discover their individuality and interests before getting into a relationship. 

It's her belief that singles should understand their worth, recognizing that they deserve a fulfilling life. She often observes that traits clients seek in partners are oftentimes what they're lacking in themselves.

According to Cantrill, establishing a rewarding and satisfying life first widens the possibility of attracting other happy and content people. 

She explained her matchmaking process this way in an interview:

“Sometimes, the matchmaking piece isn’t necessarily bringing two people together. Sometimes, the matchmaking piece is the disconnect you have with yourself, and it’s rematching within yourself. Sometimes that’s all it takes.”

This perspective places emphasis on internal harmony as a prerequisite for forging successful relationships.

If you’re interested in working with Cantrill, the first step involves completing an online inquiry and uploading a photo of yourself. 

Once she’s reviewed your submission, Cantrill will reach out to schedule a ‘Cat Chat’ where she’ll meet with you one-on-one. During this meeting, she’ll also discuss the membership options available. 

It's worth noting that the matchmaking process does not begin immediately upon signing up. According to her website, Cantrill spends around 2 months getting to know you before any matching takes place.  

You’ll then go through the Dating Blueprint, which involves personality tests and background checks. The Dating Blueprint also includes a self-led online course that delves into topics like attachment theory, chemistry versus compatibility, and tips on maintaining long-term relationships.

To identify potential matches, Cantrill utilizes a variety of resources such as online dating platforms, social media, agency-based events, and her database of singles. Additionally, she leverages her matchmaking network to find possible matches. For instance, she partners with fellow matchmaker Erica Suzanne McKay to help clients in Scottsdale.

Once a match has been identified she'll reach out and share their profile to gauge a client's interest. 

However, Cantrill does not show photos of the suggested matches prior to meeting up in person. She believes blind dates encourage clients to dig deeper than surface-level appearances. 

Services range between $350 to $4,500+ depending upon the level of engagement and specifics of your package. 

At the lower end, Cantrill offers 3 months of coaching, while the higher tier involves a tailored matchmaking package. Certain levels of membership include a 3-month hold time if you need to pause service.

Singles also have the option to sign up to be part of her singles database, "The Library," for free. However this is a passive membership, you may never meet anyone that way.

Beyond one-on-one matchmaking, Cantrill coordinates speed dating events and singles mixers in the area.

Now that you know what to expect from her service, let's see what other clients had to say about their experience working with matchmaker Cat Cantrill… 

The service had a 5-star rating on their Google business page based on 16 reviews when it was based in Cedar Rapids:

Many of the reviews, like these two, mentioned having a good experience with Cat Cantrill's speed dating events:

And this former client mentioned receiving support & encouragement throughout her dating journey while working with Cantrill:

She also has a Google listing under her own name, which also has a 5-star rating based on 9 Cat Cantrill reviews.

The reviews were all from clients like these two who appreciated the coaching they received:

On Yelp, Cantrill has a listing but it has yet to receive any reviews. It has also not yet been reviewed on platforms like Trustpilot or the BBB. 

Online matchmaking service reviews can be helpful, but star ratings are just one piece of the puzzle. You’ll also want to factor in considerations like cost, where your matches come from, and how you feel about blind dates. 

Not revealing photos of potential matches is not uncommon. Many matchmakers will tell you verbal descriptions and written profiles help keep clients focused on traits that go beyond the superficial. 

And that may be what you prefer. But on the flip side, many singles believe physical attraction is an essential part of chemistry. They’d prefer to invest time, energy, and money on first dates with matches they’re confident they’re attracted to.

If that’s you, why not also consider a matchmaking service like VIDA Select where you can review a full profile, including photos, of potential matches before agreeing to meet them? 

VIDA takes a modern approach to matchmaking that leverages the largest source of Cedar Rapids singles there is. That means you can look forward to dates with matches who check all your boxes, because you get to pre-approve them. 

Some matchmaking packages are offered on a month-to-month, pay-as-you-go basis - with no long-term contract required. Monthly service starts at $1,595.

There is also a "90-Day Match Guarantee" package that includes a minimum of 5 highly curated matches for $5,750. Results guaranteed, or your search continues at no additional cost.

82% of VIDA clients feel the sparks start to fly with someone special within 3 months of signing up. Intrigued? See if VIDA is the right approach for you!