Best Cincinnati Matchmaking Services [2025 Edition]

The 3 best Cincinnati matchmakers range from $1,595/month (VIDA Select) to $500,000+ (Selective Search). Top options include VIDA Select for contract flexibility and unlimited matches, LUMA Luxury Matchmaking for comprehensive screening ($15,000-$200,000+), and Selective Search for executive-level service ($25,000+).

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 11/22/2025

Key Insights:

• Most Flexible: VIDA Select offers monthly packages starting at $1,595 with no long-term contract, as well as a "90-Day Match Guarantee" package option.
• Mid-range: LUMA Luxury Matchmaking services from $15,000-$200,000+ - clients receive at least 3 vetted matches from their database after extensive screening. 
• Premium: Selective Search matching services starting at $25,000 for local searches, with the possibility of paying $50,000+ for national searches. 

Our team of experts has reviewed 200+ matchmakers and their services, delving deep into their process, success rates, and customer experiences. Our reviews are built on extensive research and a keen understanding of the matchmaking industry.

Here are 3 Ohio matchmaking services worth considering, as well as some insider’s advice you’ll want to check out before picking up that phone and scheduling a consultation…

Scott Valdez, VIDA Select

VIDA Select goes beyond traditional matchmaking - where matchmakers are limited by the singles in their internal database.

VIDA’s matchmakers have access to a nearly unlimited pool of singles living in and around Cincinnati, and use a combination of data analysis and advanced tech to find your perfect match.

Clientele

VIDA is perfect for successful, professional singles who are just missing one thing in their lives…

Cost

Clients can choose from an assortment of matchmaking packages offered at the different levels of service.

Monthly service starts at $1,595, with no long-term contract required. VIDA also offers a "90-Day Match Guarantee" package that provides at least 5 highly curated matches you personally approve for $5,750. Guaranteed results, or the search continues at no additional cost.

VIDA Select has an 82% success rate, with the majority of clients meeting someone special within 3 months.

What To Expect

Every VIDA client starts with a quick phone screening, as not everyone is the right fit for the service. Once you’re in, your matchmaker will get to know you better, and find out what type of person is your ideal partner. Then we’ll get to work finding incredible singles that you can’t wait to meet!

You don’t have to worry about awkward, disappointing blind dates - you pre-approve everyone before agreeing to meet them by reviewing photos and a full profile. No compromising required. Plus, all VIDA clients enjoy unlimiting matching, so you can control the pace.

And since matchmaking services are purchased on a monthly basis rather than pre-paying for a 6- or 12-month contract, you can suspend, completely stop and/or resume your search as often as you want.

Give the service a try, and if it’s not for you, simply stop! But on average, VIDA clients meet Someone Special after 11 dates - so why not see who our elite matchmakers can find for you?

Go here to get started!

Founded In

2009

VIDA Select Reviews 

On Trustpilot, VIDA Select has a 4.5-star rating based on over 400 reviews. 

Several people praised their matchmakers, sharing that they were supportive, uplifting, and thoroughly vetted their matches like these: 

April Davis, LUMA Luxury Matchmaking

While you’ll find a local office at 250 East 5th Street, Suite 1500, this elite matchmaking service isn’t based in Cincinnati. It’s national, with branches in Cleveland, Columbus and across the US. The headquarters are in Minnesota.

Clientele

April Davis and her team primarily help career-minded men and women, such as executives, CEOs, etc., find a serious relationship.

Cost

$15,000 - $200,000+

What To Expect

Prospective LUMA clients can choose between two options: submitting a profile to become one of the 20,000+ matchable candidates in their database, or paying for matchmaking service. Because it’s free, the first option comes with no guarantee of meeting any Cincinnati singles.

The cost of working with a LUMA matchmaker varies, as each person’s criteria is different. But once you’ve signed the contract and purchased the membership, the process works the same way for each client.

First, your matchmaker takes a look at all the Cincinnati singles in the LUMA database, and selects between 30 and 40 people with potential. She’ll then whittle down that pool of candidates to a smaller group that will be invited in for an interview.

You’ll end up being introduced to at least 3 of the singles who pass that final step of the screening process. You make the decision to see any of them again by swapping contact info during your first date. If you aren’t interested in any of them, you’ll need to restart the process by purchasing another round of matches.

Founded In

2010

LUMA Matchmaking Reviews 

LUMA has a 5-star rating on Yelp; however, there are fewer than 10 reviews.  

This person shared that they are glad to be part of the database of potential matches: 

And this person said they met someone special: 

Further Reading

LUMA Luxury Match Reviews

Barbie Adler, Selective Search

Prior to matchmaking, Barbie Adler helped find CEOs positions at Fortune 500 companies. She decided to swap head hunting for heart hunting, and opened Selective Search in Chicago. It has since expanded into a national matchmaking service with offices across the US.

Clientele

Most of Selective Search’s paying clients are “accomplished” men, i.e. CEOs, execs, investors, etc.

Cost

$25,000 - $500,000+ for 12 months of service

What To Expect

For the majority of prospective clients, matchmaking packages start around $75,000 and go up from there. She does offer a $25,000 "introductory" package, but that only applies to clients in specific circumstances.

Selective Search does include hold time in addition to the 12-month contract, however you have to discuss it prior to signing it. That means you’ll have to make an educated guess as to how much you might need.

Once Adler and her team have finalized your membership details, you’ll meet singles pulled from her national database of 275,000 or so eligible singles.

Founded In

2000

Selective Search Reviews 

Selective Search has mixed reviews on Yelp, resulting in a 3.0-star rating.

This individual mentioned the professionalism and enthusiasm of their matchmaker: 

And this person shared that the service values safety and discretion: 

Further Reading

Selective Search Reviews

Many people start - and stop - their preliminary research with Google or Yelp reviews. And while you may gain some valuable insight regarding past customer experience, it’s good to keep in mind that happy, satisfied customers aren’t as likely to devote time and energy to writing an internet review as unhappy ones.

And as with any business that relies on good press to get customers, there’s also the possibility that an employee may even pretend to be a customer and write positive reviews of their own service. Neither Yelp nor Google takes many steps to verify authenticity, so consider that as you’re reading reviews that may seem a bit unrealistically enthusiastic.

That being said, internet reviews can give you valuable insight into how a matchmaking service approaches customer service. A representative of the company may respond to a review or a complaint, especially on sites like the Better Business Bureau that have a formalized complaint process.

Often, you can get a sneak peek of what you’ll be agreeing to in your contract, and what other customers thought of the service compared to what’s spelled out in the document they signed.

For example, here is how Ohio Singles responded to a BBB complaint from a client who was unhappy with both the frequency and the quality of his matches:

As you can discern from the above complaint, understanding exactly what is spelled out in all that paperwork you sign is essential - because those details will likely prevent you from being able to get your money refunded in the event your not happy with the service later on.

Make Sure You Ask The Right Questions Up Front

Asking insightful, direct questions during your initial consultation helps narrow down which matchmaking services you’re seriously considering.

These 5 examples will get your list started:

Having your list of questions prepared beforehand keeps them fresh in your mind. It also gives you a chance to consider what answers you want to hear - because there are no right or wrong ones. It all comes down to what type of process you’re comfortable investing in.

Ohio has a “Right To Rescind” statute on the books, which provides customers 3 business days to reconsider and cancel a contract.

But there’s a slight catch. Many matchmaking services have a strict cancellation policy that your signature acknowledges you agree to and understand. If you don’t follow it to a T, you may not be legally entitled to that refund after all.

Depending on which matchmaking service you’re considering, you could be paying a significant amount of money up front. That means the check is proverbially cashed before you have any idea what the service will actually be like, or if it’s a good fit for you.

If that thought gives you pause, why not opt for a matchmaking service like VIDA Select that doesn’t require all the money up front?

With VIDA, you won’t have to lock yourself into a long contract - you just pay by the month! If it turns out the matchmaking service isn’t for you, don’t pay for another one! It’s that simple!

Besides, VIDA’s matchmakers typically find a client’s perfect match after just a handful of months - usually after 11 dates. How does it happen so fast? Easy - they’re not constricted to a limited internal database!

Want to find out more about how VIDA works its magic? Discover how it all works here!