Michal Matches Review [Best Matchmaker For Jewish Singles?]

Philadelphia matchmaking with a Jewish specialty.

Michal Naisteter is a Philadelphia-based matchmaker who launched Michal Matches in 2022 after several years at Three Day Rule. She works with singles across demographics but specializes in Jewish matchmaking. Packages start at $4,000, with a 3-month membership running $5,500. The process begins with a $350 strategy session before you commit.

Key Takeaways:

• Philadelphia matchmaker Michal Naisteter offers matchmaking services to singles, including specialized Jewish matchmaking. 
• Membership packages start at around $4,000 for professional matchmaking services, with options ranging from 3-month ($5,500) to 12-month commitments. 
• The matchmaking process begins with a $350 strategy session where clients discuss their dating goals and preferences, followed by personalized match screening and date planning. 
• Positive client reviews highlight Naisteter's strengths in both matchmaking and dating coaching, with some reviewers sharing they benefitted from attending her singles events. 

With so many options on the table, it's smart to do a little research on Michal Matches before deciding if Michal Naisteter is the right Philadelphia matchmaker for you.

Our team of experts aims to make your research process significantly less time-consuming with this Michal Matches review.

From the smallest local boutiques to the biggest global dating agencies, we’ve reviewed over 200 matchmakers. With over 14 years of hands-on matchmaking experience, we know exactly what clients are looking for in a service.

Michal Naisteter started her career as a professional matchmaker in 2017 when she applied for a job at Three Day Rule, Talia Goldstein’s national service.

After matchmaking there for several years, Naisteter struck out on her own, launching Michal Matches in 2022. Naisteter refers to herself as a super-connector, considering matchmaking an integral aspect of her identity.

Her service is open to singles from all demographics in the greater Philadelphia area, and she specializes in matchmaking for Jewish singles. 

Naisteter also co-hosts “The Yentas,” which is a podcast featuring fellow Jewish matchmakers Aleeza Ben Shalom and Danielle Selber. The three discuss various aspects of dating and relationships, and offer up plenty of dating and relationship advice.

Central to her matchmaking philosophy is the idea that success ultimately rests with the client and having the right mindset. As she explained, 

"Matchmakers are conduits, we aren't wizards. We think of ideas and the people who say yes to connection are the people who find connections.”

Michal Naisteter views matchmaking as more than just pairing up to people. She sees herself as a guide, helping clients streamline their prospects while infusing hope into the process. In her own words, 

“A matchmaker's role is to limit it, to narrow it down, and to also help people see there's a human on the other side of this. Our role is to give people permission to believe that love is out there, and it's possible to find it.”

If you're considering hiring this Philly matchmaker, your first step as a prospective client is to complete a membership information profile online. 

Next, you'll be scheduled for a 60-minute strategy session with Naisteter, which costs $350. Be prepared to talk about your dating history and challenges, your lifestyle, match preferences, etc.

This is also your opportunity to learn about how the service works, so put some thought into the questions you want to ask! 

(For a quick run-down on what you should know about any service you’re thinking about hiring, bookmark our Insider’s Guide To Hiring A Matchmaker!)

If you decide to come onboard as a client, Naisteter will search her database for potential matches. She also scouts for candidates via social media, IRL events, and even while out and about in her own daily life, such as grocery shopping. 

Naisteter says she isn't shy about walking up to strangers and introducing herself:

“Hey, I’m Michal. I’m a married matchmaker. Are you by any chance single, ’cause I think you’re really cute.”

Before Naisteter considers pairing anyone with a client, she has a "heart-to-heart" discussion with each candidate. Those who pass the vetting process will be included in her database of around 4,500 eligible Philadelphia singles. 

According to the Toronto Star, Naisteter has worked with over 50 paying clients since setting up shop. 

Next, let’s take a look at what some of them had to say about the experience in their Michal Matches reviews...

Michal Matches has a 4.9-star rating on their Google page based on 25+ reviews.

Several of former clients mentioned they benefited from Naisteter’s coaching and dating advice:

And these reviewers had a positive experience attending a Michal Matches singles event:

The vast majority of Michal Matches reviews on its Google business profile were positive. 

There were only a handful of negative ones. One was a 1-star review that offered no commentary, and the other was from someone Michal Naistereter said she didn’t recognize as a client. 

It was a 2-star review from someone who wasn’t happy with the perceived match quality:

Michal Matches has a Yelp page, but the service has not yet been reviewed. It has likewise not been reviewed on platforms like Trustpilot or the BBB.

Michal Matches packages start at $4,000 and go up from there. Ultimately, the total cost depends on factors like match preferences, the scope of your search, and package duration. 

For instance, as she revealed in an interview with Toronto Star, a 3-month membership costs $5,500, with more expensive memberships that last 6 and 12 months. While matches aren’t guaranteed, the goal is at least 1 per month. 

With so many Philadelphia matchmakers to choose from, you're likely wondering how that price tag stacks up to other services you might be considering.

For instance, if you’re looking to meet exceptional matches, Enamour is likely on your radar. Taking a “white glove” approach to the search for your ideal partner, Enamour maintains a highly-curated, invitation-only database of eligible singles. 

As a client, your dedicated matchmaker will also leverage recruiting technology as well as an extensive network of scouts to source matches both online and offline. Each candidate is thoroughly vetted for compatibility before being presented as a potential match.

Enamour’s packages start around $20,000.

Master Matchmakers, run by mother-son duo JoAnn and Steve Ward, was originally headquartered in Philadelphia but now serves clients all over the US from its homebase in Florida. 

Matchmaking packages start at around $2,500 and include a combination of date coaching and personal matchmaking. The final cost depends on factors like which matchmaker and coach you work with, how many matches you want to receive, etc.

Michal Naisteter’s fellow podcast host Aleeza Ben Shalom works with Jewish singles across the US and Israel. She provides both matchmaking and coaching, and her services run anywhere from around $15,000 to $50,000+.  

Ben Shalom starred in Netflix’s Jewish Matchmaking, and she’s also a published author and relationship expert. 

VIDA Select is another service that should definitely make your shortlist. The seasoned team of personal matchmakers has been helping singles since 2009, taking a modern approach that leverages the single largest source of eligible Philadelphia singles there is. 

Rather than requiring a multi-month contract, some matchmaking packages are offered on a pay-as-you-go basis. Monthly service starts at $1595. 

There is also a "90-Day Match Guarantee" package that includes at least 5 highly curated matches you approve for $5,750. Guaranteed results, or the search continues at no additional cost.

With an 82% success rate, most VIDA clients meet someone special within 3 months.

Want to discover how VIDA can find your perfect match too? Go here to learn more!