Philadelphia's Best Matchmakers: Top 8 RatedThe 8 best Philadelphia matchmakers range from $1,295/month (VIDA Select) to $1,000,000+ (Serious Matchmaking). Top options include VIDA Select for flexibility and dating pool size, Enamour for accomplished professionals ($20,000+), and Michal Matches for Jewish singles ($4,000+). Most require 3-12 month contracts, though VIDA Select offers month-to-month packages for busy Philadelphia professionals. Matchmaking Service Price Range Total Reviews Weighted Review Score Free Consultation Specialty Founded VIDA Select Starts at $1,295/month 417 ★★★★☆ 4.58 ✓ Yes Single professionals 2009 Enamour Starts at $20,000 13 ★★★★☆ 4.20 ✓ Yes High net worth singles 2009 Michal Matches Starts at $4,000 43 ★★★★☆ 4.8 ✗ No Jewish singles 2017 LUMA Luxury Matchmaking $15,000 - $200,000 79 ★★★★☆ 4.36 ✓ Yes Single professionals 2010 Master Matchmakers Starts at $2,500 179 ★★★★☆ 4.15 ✗ No Single professionals 1999 Three Day Rule $5,900 - $1,000,000 322 ★★★★☆ 4.08 ✓ Yes Single professionals 2010 Serious Matchmaking $75,000 - $1,000,000 103 ★★★☆☆ 3.36 ✗ No Ultra high net worth singles 1993 Aleeza Ben Shalom $15,000 - $50,000+ 0 No reviews available ✗ No Jewish singles 2012 Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 8/23/2025 Key Takeaways: Enamour – Concierge service, starts at $20K for 6 months VIDA Select – No long-term contracts, flexible monthly plans from $1,295/month Michal Matches – Boutique service, Jewish-focused; starts at $4,000 Three Day Rule – $5,900–$19,500, 3–6 month contracts, big national presence Serious Matchmaking – For wealthy men seeking marriage, $25K–$1M+ Master Matchmakers – $2,500+, founded by VH1’s JoAnn Ward LUMA Luxury – Packages from $15K to $200K+, boutique model From the boutique-style independents to the big industry players, our team has reviewed more than 200 matchmaking services. Our insight comes from 14+ years in the industry, comprehensive research, real customer reviews, and a deep understanding of the matchmaking landscape. {banner2:the-subtle-shift-technique}Philadelphia Matchmaker Table of Contents:Best Philadelphia Matchmakers ReviewedEnamourVIDA Select (by Scott Valdez)Michal Matches (by Michal Naisteter)Three Day Rule (by Talia Goldstein)Serious Matchmaking (by Janis & Carly Spindel)Master Matchmakers (by JoAnn Ward)LUMA Luxury Matchmaking (by April Davis)Marriage Minded Mentor (by Aleeza Ben Shalom)Philadelphia Matchmakers – Frequently Asked Questions {banner1:let-us-plan-your-last-first-date} Best Philadelphia Matchmakers ReviewedEverything you need to know is right at your fingertips, including cost, clientele, and a glimpse at their matchmaking process! Enamour Perfect for Philadelphia singles seeking a more bespoke matchmaking experience, Enamour's matchmaking team uses a combination of intuition, relationship psychology and cutting-edge tech to source highly compatible matches for discerning clients. Clientele Single, successful professionals, typically in their 30s to 60s. Cost Matchmaking starts at $20,000 for 6 months; packages can be tailored to fit a client's search requirements. What To Expect Enamour's matchmaking team starts the search for your perfect partner by carefully screening potential matches from the exclusive, invitation-only database. Each match is interviewed for compatibility before being presented to you for approval. The team also utilizes recruiting technology to scout beyond the database, selecting desirable candidates for the interview and vetting process. After each introduction, your matchmaker will check in to see how the date went, gathering feedback to help fine-tune the search if needed. She'll also share insights on how the date went from your match's perspective, giving you invaluable feedback on the dating process. Enamour also offers personal styling, imaging consulting, dating coaching and other concierge services. What Clients Are Saying About Enamour Enamour has a 4.2-star rating on Trustpilot. Many favorable reviews mentioned that their matchmaker provided unwavering support, and the dating coaching helped them transition back into dating easier. This person is now in an amazing new relationship because of the Enamour team: Apply Now VIDA Select (by Scott Valdez) Founded in 2009, VIDA Select is one of Philadelphia’s most affordable matchmaking services. Clientele Men and women in their 20s to 60s. Cost Basic matchmaking packages with VIDA start at just $1,295 per month, requiring no long-term contract. VIDA also offers a results guaranteed package for $5,750, which guarantees a minimum of 5 matches in 90 days or the search continues at no additional cost. With an 82% success rate, the majority of clients begin a relationship with a match in just 3 months. What To Expect This matchmaking service fits your schedule. Because it’s a pay-as-you-go format, you can start/stop your service at any time, as often as you need. VIDA’s elite matchmakers can leverage Philadelphia’s largest database of interesting, high-quality singles - and you pre-approve each one. When you approve a match, we’ll take care of the rest. You just show up for the dates! What Clients Are Saying About VIDA Select VIDA Select holds a 4.5-star rating on Trustpilot, with over 400 reviews. Those who enjoyed working with the service shared positive experiences with their matchmaker, attentive support throughout the entire process, and that VIDA exceeded their expectations. Several clients like this one met someone special: Apply Now Michal Matches (by Michal Naisteter) Michal Naisteter began her career as a professional matchmaker in 2017, working at Three Day Rule. She branched out on her own in 2022, launching Michal Matches. Clientele Michal Matches primarily works with clients in the greater Philadelphia area, with a special focus on her roots within the Jewish community. Cost Matchmaking packages start at $4,000, with the final price factoring in your match preferences, scope of the search, and package duration. Depending on the package, your contact can span 3, 6 or 12 months. The initial consultation with Naisteter lasts an hour, and costs $350. What To Expect You can join Michal Matches as a client, or opt to have your profile included in the database. Joining the database is free, but booking the $350 consultation will give you priority consideration as a potential match. But if you want Naisteter to do a proactive search on your behalf, you’ll need to join as a paying client. After learning more about you, your lifestyle, and your dating goals in the initial consultation, Naisteter will pair you with compatible clients from her database of 4,500+ Philadelphia singles. She also proactively scouts both for clients and for database members, sourcing candidates at events, online, and while she’s out and about. Naisteter doesn’t guarantee a specific number of matches, but aims for presenting you with at least 1 per month. What Clients Are Saying About Michal Matches Michal Matches has a 4.8-star rating on their Google business page with over 40 reviews. Many of the 5-star reviews mention Naisteter’s dating coaching advice, her professionalism, and her personable demeanor. And this individual is meeting “so many new people” by working with the service: Screenshot Further Reading Michal Matches review Apply Now Three Day Rule (by Talia Goldstein) This dating agency is based in Los Angeles, but Three Day Rule has expanded to Philadelphia too. Clientele Men & women, mid 20s - mid 60s. Cost The 3-month membership option is $5,900, and guarantees at least 3 introductions. There is also a 6-month membership that includes a minimum of 6 matches during that time frame for $9,500. 6-month "VIP" memberships start at $19,500. Both 6-month options include a pro photo session. Joining the database is free, but there’s no guarantee you’ll be matched with a paying client. What To Expect You’ll be matched with other members in TDR’s database of eligible Philadelphia singles. Three Day Rule matchmakers also approach interesting, attractive people at places such as Whole Foods or local events. When your matchmaker locates a suitable potential match, you’ll be sent their profile (including photos) for review. If you accept the match you’ll receive contact info, and you’ll take the initiative to reach out and schedule a date. What Clients Are Saying About Three Day Rule Three Day Rule carries a 4.2 rating on Yelp with almost 300 reviews. Some reviewers shared that their matchmaker’s communication and advice helped them become more confident, while others mentioned that the matchmakers gave them time and attention. This person is confident in the service’s ability to find them a life partner: Further Reading Three Day Rule review Apply Now Serious Matchmaking (by Janis & Carly Spindel) They’re two of New York City’s most high-end matchmakers, but their services extend to Philadelphia singles as well. Janis Spindel has been matchmaking since 1993. Clientele Men who want a marriage/serious relationship. Cost Both matchmakers offer 1-year contracts, during which you’ll receive at least 12 introductions. Carly’s matchmaking services start at $25,000 and go upwards of $350,000. To work directly with Janis, prices start at $50,000 and go up to $1,000,000, making her a legit millionaire matchmaker. You also have the option to have both of them search for your ideal partner, which starts at $80,000. Contracts also include a signing fee, which varies by client but starts at $65,000. The same rate is also charged as a finder’s fee, should you date one of your matches for 12 months, start living together, or get engaged. To join the database of eligible singles, women can pay a screening fee to meet with Janis, and will be included if they pass the interview. What To Expect Either Janis or Carly will meet with you over a meal, and get to know you in a casual setting. A membership package will be recommended, and you’ll pay the entire fee up front - then the search is on. What Clients Are Saying About Serious Matchmaking With a 3.1 rating on Yelp, Janis Spindel's Serious Matchmaking receives mixed feedback. Satisfied clients highlight personal growth during the process and how Janis & Carly connected them with “the right gentlemen.” And this reviewer had a good time attending a camp weekend at Janis’s home: Further Reading Serious Matchmaking reviews Apply Now Master Matchmakers (by JoAnn Ward) You may recognize JoAnn Ward as one of the stars of Tough Love, a VH1 matchmaking show which she hosted with her son (and fellow matchmaker) Steve Ward from 2009-2013. Clientele Men and women seeking serious relationships. Cost Matchmaking services start at $2,500, which includes the $450 “qualification fee” that’s part of the initial consultation. What To Expect After signing the contract and paying the entire membership fee upfront, the matchmaking process starts with a series of 3 1-hour “coaching” sessions via Skype. During these sessions, you’ll discuss your past relationships and current goals, as well as basics like your hobbies, occupation, and background. When your matchmaker finds a suitable match, you’ll receive a profile complete with a photo. Provided the interest is mutual, you’ll each receive the other's phone number and it’s on the two of you to initiate contact. If you go on a date, you can discuss your feedback afterward with your matchmaker. What Clients Are Saying About Master Matchmakers On Trustpilot, Master Matchmakers holds a 3.3 rating. Those who gave the service 5 stars said they were encouraged by the dating coaching, introduced to quality matches, and several individuals mentioned meeting someone special. Further Reading Master Matchmakers reviews Apply Now LUMA Luxury Matchmaking (by April Davis) This boutique matchmaking service, formerly known as “Cupid’s Cronies”, is based in Minneapolis but April Davis and her team have a presence in Philadelphia. Clientele Men and women seeking serious relationships. Cost A basic membership package starts at $15,000 and options can run over $200,000. You can become a “passive member” for free, which means your profile is listed in their database of Philadelphia singles, but you’re not guaranteed to be matched with any paying clients. What To Expect Each LUMA matchmaker only takes on 15-20 clients at a time, so the first step in the process is an interview to see if you’re a good fit for the service, and vice versa. Your matchmaker will then conduct interviews with up to 40 passive members, and send you a minimum of 3 potential matches from that group. You’ll go on a date with each one, and can exchange phone numbers during the course of the evening if you’d like. Then you’ll contact your matchmaker and discuss how the date went. What Clients Are Saying About LUMA The matchmaking service has a 5-star rating on Yelp, however, that’s based on only 3 reviews. One reviewer mentioned that they are having a good experience being part of LUMA’s database of singles. Another mentioned quality matches, thoughtful matchmakers, and good customer service, while the third shared that they had met their life partner. Further Reading LUMA Matchmaking reviews Apply Now Marriage Minded Mentor (by Aleeza Ben Shalom) Founder of Marriage Minded Mentor and Aleeza Ben Shalom matchmaking, Ben Shalom is a Jewish matchmaker, dating coach and relationship expert. She's also the star of Jewish Matchmaking, a Netflix show that follows her journey to help Jewish singles find their perfect match. Clientele Ben Shalom is based in the greater Philadelphia area, but she provides Jewish matchmaking and coaching to singles in Israel and all across the US. Cost Her package pricing is not advertised on her website, however based on the questions in her contact from you can likely expect to pay between $15,000 and $50,000 to have Ben Shalom as your personal matchmaker. What To Expect Aleeza Ben Shalom Matchmaking is partnered with two online Jewish matchmaking websites, SawYouAtSinai and JMatchmaking. That means you can opt to have your profile included in her Marriage Minded Singles database, or in her larger network. Either option is free, however it does not include a proactive search. An affiliated matchmaker will only contact you when (and if) a paying client is seeking someone like you. Ben Shalom's website advises she only personally works with a limited number of matchmaking clients. If you're interested in being one of them, the first step is filling out the contact form on her website. In addition, Marriage Minded Mentor also offers dating coaching, and matchmaker training to those who are interested in becoming a matchmaker themselves. What Clients Are Saying About Marriage Minded Mentor Even though this professional matchmaker has gained significant media attention, particularly for her Netflix series Jewish Matchmaking, there's a surprising scarcity of customer feedback on Aleeza Ben Shalom's matchmaking services or Marriage Minded Mentor. Apply Now Philadelphia Matchmakers – Frequently Asked Questions Which Philadelphia matchmaker specializes in Jewish singles? Two Philadelphia matchmakers focus on Jewish clients. Michal Matches, founded by Michal Naisteter in 2022, specializes in the Jewish community with packages starting at $4,000 and a database of 4,500+ Philadelphia singles. Aleeza Ben Shalom offers Jewish matchmaking through Marriage Minded Mentor, partnered with SawYouAtSinai and JMatchmaking, with packages ranging $15,000-$50,000 and featured on Netflix's Jewish Matchmaking show. Do Philadelphia matchmakers offer month-to-month flexibility? Only VIDA Select offers month-to-month packages ($1,295-$2,595) with no long-term contracts required. All other Philadelphia matchmakers require contracts: Michal Matches uses 3-12 month agreements, Three Day Rule requires 3-6 months, Enamour typically uses 6-month contracts, and Serious Matchmaking requires full annual commitments with substantial upfront fees. Which Philadelphia matchmaker has TV/media experience? Several Philadelphia matchmakers have media backgrounds. JoAnn Ward of Master Matchmakers hosted VH1's "Tough Love" show from 2009-2013 with her son. Aleeza Ben Shalom stars in Netflix's "Jewish Matchmaking" series and provides relationship expertise across media platforms. What's included with boutique Philadelphia matchmaking services? Boutique services offer personalized attention with limited client rosters. Michal Matches provides proactive scouting and aims for 1+ matches monthly. LUMA limits matchmakers to 15-20 clients with interviews of up to 40 database members. Enamour includes personal styling, imaging consulting, and dating coaching. Master Matchmakers includes three 1-hour coaching sessions, while most services provide post-date feedback and search refinement. All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them. {banner3:the-right-person-changes-everything-inline}
