Which Long Island matchmaker offers the most contract flexibility?

VIDA Select provides the most flexibility with month-to-month packages ($1,295-$2,595) and no long-term contracts required. Clients can pause or stop service anytime, paying only for months they want active matchmaking. Other Long Island matchmakers like Serious Matchmaking require annual contracts with $65,000 upfront signing fees, while Agape Match uses 6-month agreements and Rachel Russo requires minimum 6-month commitments.

Do Long Island matchmakers specialize in the Hamptons scene?

Several matchmakers have Hamptons expertise. VIDA Select provides access throughout Long Island including Montauk and the Hamptons. Serious Matchmaking's Janis Spindel summers in East Hamptons and actively recruits in Montauk and Sag Harbor. LastFirst Matchmaking's Emily Holmes Hahn splits time between Manhattan and East Hamptons, with 15% of clients being year-round Long Island residents and specializes in navigating the challenging Hamptons singles scene.

What should I know about upfront fees with Long Island matchmakers?

Most Long Island matchmakers require full payment before your search begins. Many also charge consultation and other fees up front. For instance, Serious Matchmaking charges a $65,000 signing fee plus matching finder's fee if you enter a relationship. Rachel Russo requires a $250 consultation fee, while NYCity Matchmaking charges $475 for initial consultations.

Which Long Island matchmaker has the best reviews?

VIDA Select holds a 4.5-star rating on Trustpilot from 400+ reviews highlighting supportive matchmakers and quality matches. NYCity Matchmaking has a 4.9-star rating on Yelp, with clients praising Michelle Frankel's personalized approach and thorough process. Agape Match maintains a 4.5-star rating on Yelp, with clients appreciating Maria Avgitidis's coaching and Instagram presence. Serious Matchmaking has mixed 3-star reviews, while other services have limited review histories. All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them. {banner3:the-right-person-changes-everything-inline}

Best Long Island Matchmakers [2025 Cost Comparison!]

Home Blog Matchmaker Review

Scott Valdez

Updated 10/26/2025

Table of contents