Top St. Louis Matchmakers [Reviews And Cost Comparison!]

The 6 best St. Louis matchmakers range from $1,595/month (VIDA Select) to $1,000,000+ (Serious Matchmaking). Top options include VIDA Select for contract flexibility and extensive reach, Enamour for accomplished professionals ($20,000+), and Serious Matchmaking for luxury matchmaking ($25,000-$1,000,000). Most require 6-12 month contracts with varying match guarantees across Missouri and the Midwest.

Report Methodology: The Weighted Review Score combines ratings from Trustpilot, Yelp, and Google, weighted by the number of reviews on each platform. To ensure reliability, services with fewer than 10 total reviews receive a confidence adjustment: 10+ reviews (full weight), 5-9 reviews (90% weight), 2-4 reviews (80% weight), and single reviews (70% weight). For instance, if a service only has a single 5-star review, their weighted score would be 3.5 stars. This prevents services from ranking artificially high based on limited feedback and provides a more accurate comparison based on client experiences. Last Updated: 8/25/2025

Key Insights:

• Specialties: Matched With Love (millennials only), Midwest Matchmaking (rural/farming communities), Enamour (executive matchmaking)
• Budget-friendly: VIDA Select ($1,595-$2,595/month, no long-term commitments), Midwest Matchmaking ($1,800-$3,600+)
• Mid-range: Matched With Love (varies by client), The Date Maven (several thousand+)
• Premium: Enamour ($20,000+), Serious Matchmaking ($25,000-$1M+)
• Strong reviews: VIDA Select (4.5 stars), Enamour (4.2 stars)
• Contract flexibility: Only VIDA Select offers month-to-month options

Our industry experience dates back to 2009, making us well acquainted with the major players and the smaller boutiques. We’ve written well over 200 matchmaker reviews, leveraging our comprehensive knowledge of the industry and first-hand understanding of what clients value most.

These 6 elite Missouri matchmaking services are worth considering!

Enamour

A global matchmaker service renown for its exclusive, invitation-only database, the Enamour team has been helping accomplished St. Louis singles find love since 2009.

Clientele

Enamour is as selective about who it takes on as a client as it is about who can join the singles database. Clients are typically successful, discerning professionals in their 30s+ who are looking for a more tailored matchmaking experience.

Cost/Contract

Matchmaking packages start around $20,000 for a 6-month search. Packages can be customized to fit each client's search requirements.

What To Expect From This St. Louis Matchmaker

Prospect clients begin with a complimentary consultation to learn more about the service and ensure they're the right fit. If you're chosen for membership, you'll be paired with a dedicated personal matchmaker who will be with you throughout the entire experience.

First, she'll get to know all about you and your lifestyle, hobbies, goals, matching criteria, etc. Using an effective blend of AI, relationship psychology, and old fashioned matchmaker's intuition, she'll begin the search from within the exclusive database.

But that's just the beginning. Enamour also leverages recruiting technology as well as an extensive network of scouts to pinpoint candidates from within a wide array of offline and online sources.

Every potential match undergoes a thorough screening process, including an in-depth interview that takes place either in person or via video call. Those who pass are presented to you for approval.

You'll review a full profile and photo array, and your matchmaker will arrange the introduction with those you'd like to meet. After each first date, she'll follow up with both of you to gather insights into your dating process and fine-tune the search as needed.

Enamour also offers services designed to complement the matchmaking process, such as personal styling, dating coaching, professional photography, and more.

Enamour Reviews 

Enamour has a 4.0 star rating on Trustpilot with favorable reviews mentioning thoughtful matchmakers, candid feedback, and exceptional first dates.  

And one individual shared that her date was perfectly matched for her - “I was fortunate to work with Stacy, who is a wonderful matchmaker and is very thoughtful about her approach. My date was a perfect match for me, and i give her a lot of credit for being so intuitive and diligent.”   

 

VIDA Select (by Scott Valdez)

Ready to finally start meeting people who check all your “must have” boxes - and are excited to meet you too? With one of VIDA Select’s matchmakers on your team, dating in St. Louis just got a lot less frustrating.

Clientele

Both men and women can become paying clients, and VIDA Select typically works with successful, professional singles in their late 20s to late 60s.

Cost/Contract

VIDA Select offers an array of packages, with pay-as-you-go monthly service starting at $1,595. There is also a "results guaranteed" option that starts at $5,750. That package includes at least 5 curated matches personally approved by you over the course of 90 days, or the search continues at no additional cost.

With an 82% success rate, the majority of VIDA clients begin a relationship within 3 months.

What To Expect From This St. Louis Matchmaker

Founded in 2009, VIDA Select combines the best aspects of traditional matchmaking with modern tech and data analysis. That means you’ll be meeting highly compatible people hand selected from St. Louis’s largest dating pool. 

But unlike other matchmakers in St. Louis, with VIDA Select there’s no need to sign a lengthy, binding contract - or pay for all those months of service up front.

VIDA Select offers the convenience of paying one month at a time. That means if you meet The One right away, or you decide it’s not quite the right fit for you, simply don’t continue the next month! It’s that easy. 

The first step is a quick screening process which only takes a few minutes.

If you qualify, you’ll be invited to schedule a complimentary call to learn more about how VIDA Select can potentially change your life. On average, clients report meeting someone with true soul mate potential in just 11 dates! 

That’s because your personal matchmaker gets to know you and your ideal partner criteria, so you’ll be presented with comprehensive profiles of St. Louis singles you can’t wait to meet.

VIDA Select Reviews 

You’ll find that VIDA has mostly positive reviews on Trustpilot. The matchmaking company has a 4.5-star rating, with several of the 5-star reviews sharing how much they liked their matchmaker, like this person:    

Another reviewer shared that their matchmaker was amazing by saying, “She is uplifting and always in a good mood. She instantly makes you feel comfortable with the idea of meeting your perfect match. I’ve been married for 17 years, and starting to date was mentally draining. She made this experience pleasant, enjoyable, and fun! I absolutely adore her!”  

 

The Date Maven (by Suzanna Mathews)

Suzanna Mathews’ matchmaking team is headquartered in Wichita, Kansas. But she works with singles in St. Louis as well, making her an option if you’re looking for a Missouri matchmaker. Mathews launched her service in 2011.

Clientele

Mathews generally takes on only a small handful of clients at any given point in time, usually between 3 & 5. Clients are typically men and women in their 30s looking for something serious, or mature singles looking to date again after the end of a long-term relationship.

Cost/Contract

Matchmaking costs will be disclosed during your initial consultation, but typically start in the neighborhood of several thousand dollars. Clients sign a contract for matchmaking services.

What To Expect From This St. Louis Matchmaker

Potential clients start with a consultation to determine if coaching or matchmaking is the better route, or if you’d benefit from a combination of the two. 

If you sign a contract for matchmaking services, the singles you meet will be selected from her internal database. Mathews is also affiliated with the Matchmakers Alliance, so she’ll use those connections to find compatible singles for you to meet as well.  

The Date Maven Reviews 

When it comes to matchmaking service reviews, The Date Maven has yet to be reviewed on platforms like Trustpilot or Google, and doesn’t have a listing with the BBB either.  

The service does have a claimed yelp page but with no reviews.

Further Reading

The Date Maven Review

 

Midwest Matchmaking (by Courtney Quinlan)

Named because they work with singles throughout the Midwest, Courtney Quinlan’s professional matchmaking service is based in Omaha.

Previously known as “Omaha Love” back when it launched in 2009, Midwest Matchmaking specializes in working with singles living both in big cities like St. Louis and in the rural and farming communities surrounding them.

Clientele

Quinlan works with both men and women as paying clients, generally singles over 25 looking for marriage.

Cost/Contract

Varies per client, but typically around $1,800 - $3,600+. Contracts generally include either 6 or 12 months of service.

What To Expect From This St. Louis Matchmaker

Potential clients have two options: work directly with a matchmaker as a Private member, or submit your profile as a potential match for paying clients.

The second option is free, but you’ll only meet someone if you happen to mesh with their requirements.

To have a matchmaking search the database on your behalf, you’ll need to become a Private member. That also starts via an online application, and the next step is a free, on-hour consultation with Quinlan or someone on her team.

Paying clients have several choices, all of which will be described during that initial call. Membership options range from having Quinlan as your personal matchmaker or paying for access to the database of profiles and searching for compatible potential matches yourself.

If you’d rather your own profile not be viewable to those paying for access, there’s an option for that too.

Midwest Matchmaking doesn’t specify a set number of matches you’ll get at any membership level - you’ll receive a profile to review when someone compatible is found. 

If both sides of the pairing express interest, the first date (usually meeting for drinks/coffee or having a video call) is arranged for you. And afterward, both parties will have the opportunity to discuss how the introduction went.

Midwest Matchmaking Reviews 

You’ll find limited reviews for Midwest Matchmaking online. The service only has 1 active review through the BBB, however, it does hold an A+ rating.   

Quinlan’s service holds a 1.7-star rating on Yelp based on fewer than 10 reviews. Those who didn’t have a good experience expressed their concerns about the quality of their matches and the lack of communication from their matchmaker.  

There was a single 5-star review that shared, “Courtney and her team are exceptional at what they do as well as passionate.

Further Reading

Midwest Matchmaking Review

 

Matched With Love (by Darci Roberts)

Native Missourian Darci Roberts established her matchmaking venture, Matched with Love, in her home city of St. Louis in 2022. Roberts’ close friend and licensed therapist Jasmine Mauss joined the team to offer date coaching services to clients.

Clientele

Roberts created Matched with Love to work exclusively with young professional millennials who are looking for a long-term relationship.

Cost/Contract

The total package price varies per client, taking into account factors such as your match preferences and contract length. Contracts typically span between 3 and 12 months.

There’s no cost to join the singles database, however that is a passive membership so you may never meet anyone that way.

What To Expect From This St. Louis Matchmaker

Matched with Love works with both male and female millennials. The process starts with filling out a contact form on their website, leading you to receive an in-depth questionnaire via email. Completing the questionnaire automatically adds you to their singles database.

If you've indicated you want to purchase a package, a consultation call is arranged to discuss the process and pricing details. If both parties agree to work together, a contract is signed and you'll pay for your matchmaking package.

Next, you'll meet with Roberts to discuss your expectations and the qualities you're looking for in an ideal partner. Suggested matches are either drawn from the singles database or from her matchmaking network.

Matched With Love Reviews 

You won’t find many reviews just yet for Matched With Love. We didn’t come across any client feedback on Trustpilot, Yelp, or Google. That’s not too surprising since the service only launched in 2022, so it’s still relatively new to the scene. Roberts has been building a client base steadily, but it takes time to gather enough customers who’ll leave online reviews.    

Further Reading

Matched With Love Reviews 

 

Serious Matchmaking (by Janis & Carly Spindel)

If you’re in the market for a millionaire matchmaker, Janis Spindel and her daughter Carly should make your short list. They call the East Coast home - NYC to be exact. But they have a presence in a handful of cities around the country, making them a good option if you're looking for matchmakers in St. Louis.

Spindel launched her luxury matchmaking service back in 1993.

Clientele

With a price tag that runs all the way up to $1,000,000, Serious Matchmaking is for successful, professional men - typically high-level executives, moguls, etc.

Cost/Contract

$25,000 - $1,000,000. Contracts generally last at least a year, and include one match per month. There is a signing fee for new clients that starts at $65,000, as well as a "finder's fee" of the same rate if you get into a relationship with a match that lasts 12 months, you get engaged, or you move in together.

What To Expect From This St. Louis Matchmaker

Since the Spindels typically only provide active matchmaking services for men, women apply to join their exclusive match database as a passive member. 

Women don’t pay for matchmaking service, but may never actually meet a paying client. And not just any woman can have her profile included - there’s a screening process to get through first. 

It consists of filling out the online application form, attaching photos, and then passing an interview. The interview isn’t free; the $250-$1,250 non-refundable fee depends on whether or not you meet with one of the Spindels one-on-one or in a group setting.

The Spindels are just as particular with the men they take on as paying clients. Their matchmaking process starts with an initial consultation to determine if you’re right for the service. 

Once a contract is signed, men can expect to meet at least 12 women from Spindel’s database over the course of 12 months.

Serious Matchmaking Reviews 

Serious Matchmaking has mixed reviews on Yelp, resulting in a 3-star rating. Satisfied clients highlight personal growth during the process, with one person noting that Janis "helps you become the best version of yourself."

Another reviewer emphasized that while the matchmaking journey requires "time and patience," they appreciated how the team at Serious Matchmaking consistently managed to "connect me with the right gentlemen."

Further Reading

Serious Matchmaking Reviews