Three Day Rule Reviews [Cost, Process And More!]

Bottom Line Up Front: Three Day Rule costs $5,900-$19,500+ for matchmaking service, and delivers mixed results according to reviews. Worth it for single professionals in major cities, but success can vary by location and matchmaker quality.

💡 Key Takeaways:

• Operating in 12 major US cities including Los Angeles, New York, and San Francisco
• Free database membership available but no guaranteed matches for non-paying members
• 3 guaranteed matches minimum for paying clients starting at $5,900
• Mixed review ratings: 2.3/5 star Trustpilot vs 4.2/5 star Yelp rating
• Price range varies significantly: $5,900-$19,500 standard packages, plus $1M ultra-luxury option
• Client generally have good things to say about the service, though some report concerns about match quality and the size of the dating pool relative to the pricing.

Three Day Rule positions itself as a premium matchmaking service for busy professionals, but does the investment justify the results? This comprehensive review examines real client experiences, pricing structure, and service quality to help you make an informed decision.

Our team has reviewed more than 200 matchmaking services, delving deep into their processes, success rates, and customer experiences. Our reviews are built on extensive research and the first-hand experience that comes with over 14 years in the industry.

Three Day Rule operates as a professional matchmaking service that bridges the gap between dating apps and ultra-luxury boutique matchmakers, offering personalized attention at a more accessible price point than high-end competitors.

Core Service Model

Three Day Rule's professional matchmakers hand-select potential partners from their extensive database and personal networks, then provide ongoing coaching and feedback throughout the dating process. Unlike purely digital matching services, clients receive dedicated human attention and personalized guidance designed to improve both match quality and dating skills.

Geographic Presence and Market Focus

Founded in 2010 by Talia Goldstein, a former TV producer turned matchmaker, Three Day Rule operates in 12 major metropolitan areas: Los Angeles (headquarters), Boston, Chicago, Dallas, Miami, New York, Orange County, Philadelphia, San Francisco, San Diego, Silicon Valley, and Washington DC. This strategic focus on major cities ensures access to larger pools of educated, career-focused singles.

Dual-Tier Business Model

The service operates on a two-tier system that expands their matching pool while generating revenue from serious relationship-seekers. Free database members create profiles and become available for matching with paying clients, while premium members receive active matchmaking services with guaranteed minimum introductions.

Professional Matchmaker Approach

Each paying client works with dedicated professional matchmakers who combine relationship expertise with modern recruiting techniques. Matchmakers actively seek potential matches through networking events, personal connections, and strategic outreach rather than relying solely on existing database members for higher price packages.

Comprehensive Support Services

Beyond basic introductions, Three Day Rule includes professional photography sessions and date coaching to improve client presentation and dating skills. This holistic approach addresses both finding compatible matches and developing the interpersonal skills necessary for relationship success.

The service targets busy professionals aged 25-45 who have limited time for traditional dating approaches but seek more personalized attention than dating apps provide.

Understanding Three Day Rule's pricing structure can help you evaluate whether their services align with your budget and service expectations.

Free Database Membership

It's free to join Three Day Rule's database of eligible singles. You create an online profile and become available for matching with paying clients, though there are no guarantees you'll receive introductions since their database is quite extensive with thousands of members.

Paying Client Packages

For active matchmaking services where a professional searches for your potential dates, you'll need to join as a paying client with these options:

Standard Packages:

• 3-Month Program: $5,900 (minimum 3 guaranteed matches)
• 6-Month Program: $9,500 (minimum 6 guaranteed matches)
• VIP Membership: $19,500+ for 6 months with enhanced services

Ultra-Luxury Option:

• "Million Dollar" Package: $1,000,000 for 12 months of comprehensive service

Included Services Across All Packages:

• Professional photo shoot with experienced photographer
• Two personal date coaching sessions
• Ongoing matchmaker support and feedback

Million Dollar Package Details

For high-net-worth singles seeking ultimate personalization, the $1,000,000 package provides:

• Unlimited match introductions
• Custom date planning and coordination
• Dedicated 3-person matchmaking team
• Monthly in-person meetings with matchmakers
• Comprehensive date preparation and coaching

Additional Services Available

"Date Strategy Services" offer 50-minute coaching sessions via Zoom, available as individual sessions or packages of 2 or 10 sessions for additional fees beyond base membership costs.

Understanding Three Day Rule's systematic approach helps set realistic expectations about timeline, involvement level, and the type of experience you'll have as a client.

Step 1: Initial Consultation (45 minutes) Your matchmaker conducts a comprehensive assessment to understand your relationship history, preferences, deal-breakers, and compatibility factors. This conversation forms the foundation for your personalized search strategy.

Step 2: Database and Network Review Your matchmaker searches their extensive database and personal network for potential matches meeting your specified criteria, considering both obvious compatibility factors and subtle personality alignments.

Step 3: In-Person Match Verification Before presenting anyone to you, your matchmaker meets potential matches in person to verify compatibility, assess personality fit, and ensure they meet your stated preferences and lifestyle requirements.

Step 4: Match Presentation You receive a photo and biographical information about each potential match. Because matches are thoughtfully chosen through this vetting process, each presentation counts as one of your "official" guaranteed matches even if you decline to meet.

Step 5: Contact Exchange and Date Coordination If you approve a match, contact information is exchanged and you're responsible for scheduling the initial date. Your matchmaker may provide venue suggestions or dating guidance as needed.

Step 6: Post-Date Feedback and Refinement After each date, your matchmaker collects detailed feedback about compatibility, chemistry, and any concerns. This information refines future search parameters to improve subsequent match quality.

Match Sourcing Strategy

Three Day Rule finds potential matches through multiple channels:

Database Members: Free members who've joined their extensive singles database

Personal Networks: Contacts from your matchmaker's professional and social connections

Event Recruitment: Eligible singles approached at networking events, social gatherings, and professional venues

Active Outreach: Matchmakers approach interesting people they encounter in daily life to expand the available pool

Important Limitation: Each presented match counts toward your package guarantee regardless of whether you choose to meet them, making it crucial to trust your matchmaker's judgment and provide clear feedback about preferences.

Three Day Rule's customer experiences vary significantly across review platforms, creating a complex picture that requires careful analysis to understand service quality reality.

Yelp Reviews: 4.2/5 Stars (250+ Reviews)

Positive Client Experiences:

The majority of Yelp reviews are 4-5 stars, with clients praising their personal matchmaking experience. Common positive themes include:

• Professional matchmaker communication and attentiveness
• Quality of matches that aligned with stated preferences
• Helpful dating coaching and feedback sessions
• Successful long-term relationships resulting from introductions

Clients like these three reported a positive experience with their personal matchmaking service:

Critical Feedback on Yelp:

Some 1-2 star reviews express frustration despite praising individual matchmakers. Common concerns include:

• Limited dating pool size relative to premium pricing
• Matches that didn't meet specified criteria
• Difficulty getting responses from potential matches
• Value questions about cost versus results achieved

Here are a few examples:

Trustpilot Reviews: 2.3/5 Stars (6 Reviews)

Uniformly Negative Experiences:

All six Trustpilot reviews are 1-star ratings, suggesting clients who felt compelled to share negative experiences sought this platform for complaint resolution.

Geographic Service Inconsistency: One detailed review described positive initial experiences in Philadelphia, followed by significantly worse service quality after relocating to Miami, suggesting inconsistent matchmaker quality across different cities.

Match Quality Complaints: Multiple reviews cite matches that clearly didn't meet basic stated criteria: "Four of my five matches didn't meet fundamental requirements I'd specified upfront, making me question whether my preferences were actually considered."

Another client complained about the quality of the matches he received, saying four of the five didn't meet his criteria:

Reddit User Experiences

Free Database Member Perspectives:

Reddit discussions reveal mixed experiences from non-paying database members:

• Some report feeling pressured during dates with paying clients who'd been coached to push for second meetings
• Others view database participation as standard industry practice that benefits everyone by expanding match pools
• Several mention successful connections despite being free members

Paying Client Concerns:

Some Reddit users report negative experiences as paying clients:

• Confidence damage from poor match quality
• Feeling matches were pressured into dates rather than genuinely interested
• Questions about matchmaker hiring standards and training quality

Here's a sampling of Reddit reviews:

“I signed up on their database for free. I had a date with one of their clients a couple years ago. The date was fine but I think he was coached by his matchmaker to be very pushy in setting up the 2nd date and it completely turned me off.” 

“Most matchmaking services let you add yourself to their database to be considered as a match for their clients. It’s not shady, and the clients don’t have access to the database. It’s a tool for the matchmakers.” 

“This is not bait. We are in the pool of candidates that their clients are looking for. The bigger the pool, the better the choices are for their clients.”

“I paid thousands and this company destroyed my confidence instead of building it up at a very sensitive time in my life. There’s nothing masterful about their matchmaking - they just hire whomever - and they don’t have access to anyone you can’t find yourself. The guys they had gone out with me had clearly been pressured into it and a couple bailed on me and TDR still tried to count those as matches.” 

Important Caveat: Reddit reviews cannot be verified as legitimate clients without company confirmation, so these should be considered alongside official platform reviews.

Better Business Bureau: A- Rating (11 Reviews)

Generally Positive BBB Experience:

Three Day Rule maintains BBB accreditation with an A- rating and 4.64 stars based on limited reviews. Most BBB reviews are 4-5 stars with clients reporting positive overall experiences.

Common BBB Complaints: The few 1-star BBB reviews center on match quality concerns similar to other platforms, suggesting this is a consistent theme across client experiences regardless of review venue.

Of those who gave the service 1-star the comments were centered around match quality: 

This national matchmaking company has definitely gotten more positive press than negative, which likely means they’re doing something right.