Who Are The Best Cleveland Matchmakers? Top 4 List [2023]

Not sure which Cleveland matchmakers are worth considering? When it comes to increasing the odds of finally finding your ideal partner, you want to select the best!

Start by checking out these 4 professional matchmaking services.

Then at the end of this short guide, you’ll also get a few crucial questions to ask any Cleveland matchmaker before making your final decision, plus expert advice that will help ensure you’re making the best decision for you!

Rachel Heiser, Cleveland Yentas

Cleveland Yentas is a Jewish matchmaking service, and strictly for Jewish singles looking to meet other Jewish singles in Cleveland. This non-profit organization was started by Rachel Heiser and is funded by a micro grant and private donations.

Clientele

Jewish singles looking for their beshert in Cleveland. They specialize in making traditional matchmaking available for the non-Orthodox Jewish community, but won’t turn away Orthodox singles.

Cost

Free

Contract

No

What To Expect

Jewish singles interested in working with a Yenta can fill out a profile online. Once you’ve done that, you’ll be contacted if and when a potential match is found in their database. If both parties express interest in meeting each other, you’ll receive contact info so you can arrange the date.

The “Cleveland Yentas” are a group of volunteers from the Cleveland area who meet once a month to review matches. They often review new profiles as they come in, but the magic mostly happens when they’re all together at the meeting.

Founded In

2013

April Davis, LUMA Luxury Matchmaking

A national matchmaking service with branches across the US, LUMA launched in Minneapolis. April Davis later expanded the service, including Ohio branches in Cleveland, Columbus and Cincinnati.

The Cleveland location is 1273 West 9th, #102.

Clientele

LUMA markets its services for “single affluent executives and professionals.” Both men and women can purchase dedicated matchmaking services.

Cost

$2,800 - $100,000

Contract

Yes

What To Expect

LUMA offers two ways to join - either as a passive member with a profile in their singles database of around 20,000, or as a Premium member.

A passive membership is exactly what it sounds like - you’ll only be contacted should your profile happen to align with a Premium client’s wish list.

The cost of a Premium membership is tailored according to each client’s individual circumstances and desired partner traits. All the details will be outlined in your membership contract, which is paid for up front.

Once you’re onboard, your matchmaker will take a closer look at up to 40 Cleveland singles from their internal database. Of that larger group, the candidates who most closely match your preferred traits will come in for a screening interview.

Once all that has happened, you’ll be presented with at least 3 matches. If the actual date seems to go well, the two of you can decide to swap contact details and set up another meeting.

If not, you’ll have the option to purchase more matches and the interview process begins all over again.

Founded In

2010

Further Reading

LUMA Luxury Match Reviews

Barbie Adler, Selective Search

This executive matchmaking service isn’t based in Cleveland, but does help Cleveland singles. Barbie Adler launched it in Chicago, and the company now has a national presence.

Clientele

“Accomplished” singles, 90% of whom are men, looking for serious relationships and/or marriage.

Cost

$15,000 - $50,000+

Contract

Yes

What To Expect

The least expensive matchmaking package is offered only to “young executives” under the age of 36. It includes up to 6 matches, and unlike the other packages the contract can be limited to 6 months.

Matchmaking service contracts for those 36+ run for a full year and start at $25,000 for up to 10 matches with Cleveland. If you’re interested in expanding your search beyond Cleveland, you’ll have to pay at least $50,000.

There’s one other thing to keep in mind with Selective Search - if you want the ability to pause your membership in increments of 30 days at a time, you’ll need to make provisions for that prior to signing.

If you opt to purchase a membership, you’ll be introduced to some of the singles from Barbie Adler’s database.

Founded In

2000

Further Reading

Selective Search Reviews

Scott Valdez, VIDA Select

VIDA Select offers elite matchmaking services with one big difference - your matches aren’t limited to singles in an internal database.

Instead, your dedicated VIDA matchmaker will use the latest tech and data analysis techniques to find high-quality Cleveland singles who meet not just your “most important” criteria, but all your criteria. No compromising!

Clientele

VIDA’s modern matchmaking service is the perfect fit for professional “Total Package” singles seeking the same in a partner.

Cost

Clients have a full range of monthly packages to choose from, across 3 levels of service. Package cost is highly reflective of the total number of hours you'll need devoted to your 'perfect partner' search, with the complexity of your match criteria and the number of locations factored in.

For Basic matchmaking, packages start at $995 per month of service. Premium matchmaking packages begin at just $1595/month, and Elite package options start at only $2395/month. On average, VIDA clients meet someone special in only 3 months!

Contract Required

No

What To Expect

After a quick screening process to ensure VIDA is the right fit for you (and vice versa), the search for your ideal partner begins almost immediately.

Each monthly package includes unlimited matching potential - but you only invest your time and money on first dates with people who pass the most important screening process of all - yours. You can approve (or decline) each match after seeing photos and perusing a full profile!

And here’s another perk - convenient monthly packages mean there’s no long-term commitment. You’re not paying up front for up to a year’s worth of service when you have no idea what to expect.

Pay as you go means exactly that - continue the service if you want to meet new, incredible Cleveland singles, stop the service when you want to date someone exclusively, or if you decide VIDA isn’t right for you!

Find out more and see if you qualify for the service here.

Additional Services

Dating coaching, style and image consulting, professional photography and retouching

Founded In

2009

3 Expert Tips For Choosing The Best Cleveland Matchmaker

#1: Take Local Reviews With A Few Grains Of Salt

Local review platforms such as Yelp, Google and Facebook are where many people head first - but they shouldn’t be your last stop. Since most don’t take steps to vet reviews, glowing ones are sometimes posted by a matchmaking service’s own employees.

You may also find very few or no reviews about a matchmaking service, and that’s not a bad thing - happy customers may not take time out of their busy schedules to write one.

Doing a quick search for “Alerts” on the Better Business Bureau’s site is a good idea.

The BBB will flag matchmaking services who receive what they call a “pattern of complaints” or appear to engage in questionable tactics like “bait and switch” - i.e. promising one thing during the sales presentation but not delivering:

Whenever the same type of complaints start to emerge on multiple different review sites, that’s likely an indication you should do more research and ask plenty of questions.

#2: Prepare Your Questions Before The Initial Consultation

Having a clear vision of what type of matchmaking service you’re looking for can help prevent you from committing yourself to a long-term contract you won’t be happy with - and can’t get out of.

The best way to get a glimpse of how a company operates is to ask a lot of questions, starting with these:

Decide for yourself what the “right” answer is, and consider matchmaking services whose operating style aligns with what you’re looking for. If you get the sense that a matchmaking service’s representative is being evasive with the answers, that could be a red flag - and that brings us to the third tip:

#3: Don’t Skim The Contract, Read It

Ohio state law allows for a Right To Rescind - so technically you’ll have 3 business to cancel once you’ve signed the contract.

However, if you change your mind you’ll have to follow the cancellation policy exactly or you may have to fight a legal battle for that refund. And if you ask for it outside of that 3-day window, you’re likely out of luck.

Here is how Columbus Singles, another Ohio matchmaking service, explained their refund policy in a complaint filed against them with the BBB:

Matchmaking services are a financial investment, some more than others.

Some matchmakers rely on persuasive sales techniques (read: high pressure) that include pressuring you to sign the contract right now - often at a reduced price. If you let an emotional sales pitch distract you from the contract language, you may be in for some frustration down the line when you realize exactly what you’re getting for your money.

Money which is gone, by the way, since you likely paid in full up front. Or to put it in a different perspective - is a matchmaking service going to work up to their full potential to make you happy after they’ve cashed your check?

Or would you rather select a service like VIDA Select where you pay monthly - and can stop your service at any time if you’re not happy with it?

Why not see how one of VIDA’s elite matchmakers can change your life? Click here!

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.