Three Day Rule Reviews [Cost, Process & More!]

Looking for Three Day Rule reviews? You’ll find all the details you need right here, including price, membership plans, and what real clients have said about their experience with this modern matchmaker!

💡 Key Takeaways:

• Operating in 12 major US cities including Los Angeles, New York, and San Francisco, Three Day Rule maintains a free database of eligible singles while offering paid clients personalized matchmaking services.  
• Client reviews across several platforms (Yelp 4.3 stars, BBB B+ rating) generally have good things to say about the service, though some clients report concerns about match quality and the size of the dating pool relative to the pricing.
• Three Day Rule matchmaking services start at $5,900 for a 3-month package with 3 guaranteed matches, while their VIP memberships cost around $19,500 for 6 months. There is an ultra-exclusive package available for 3 clients yearly that costs $1,000,000.

Our team has reviewed more than 200 matchmaking services, delving deep into their processes, success rates, and customer experiences. Our reviews are built on extensive research and the first-hand experience that comes with over 14 years in the industry.

Let's dive in!

Three Day Rule Locations

Talia Goldstein founded Three Day Rule in 2010, after quitting her day job as a TV producer to pursue her love of matchmaking. 

Inspiration for the company name came from the movie Swingers, whose characters explained how the 3 Day Rule works. That’s how long you should wait to call a girl you’ve just met. (The company doesn’t believe in this rule, it’s just in their name.)

Since then, Three Day Rule has grown into a professional matchmaking service headquartered in Los Angeles with offices in 11 other cities: Boston, Chicago, Dallas, Miami, New York, Orange County, Philadelphia, San Francisco, San Diego, Silicon Valley, and Washington DC.

Three Day Rule Pricing

It’s free to be listed in Three Day Rule’s database of eligible singles. You simply fill out a profile online, and then wait to be matched with paying clients. There are no guarantees you will be matched in the pool, as their database is quite extensive.

If you want a matchmaker to actively look for your potential dates, you’ll need to join as a paying client. Three Day Rule prices start at $5,900.

Potential clients can choose from these membership options:

• A minimum of 3 matches guaranteed over the course of 3 months for $5,900
• A minimum of 6 matches guaranteed over the course of 6 months for $9,500
• VIP memberships start at $19,500 for 6 months of matchmaking

All packages include a photo shoot with a photographer and 2 date coaching sessions.

For those looking to hire a luxury matchmaker, Three Day Rule offers a $1,000,000 package. It's a 12-month program offered to high-net-worth singles looking for personalized services. Here is what you get for your million dollar investment:

• Unlimited matches
• Date planning
• 3-person matchmaking team
• Monthly meetings with your matchmakers
• Date prep & coaching

Wondering how Three Day Rule prices compare to other services? Check out this Three Day Rule cost article!

They also offer “Date Strategy Services" in the form of 50-minute sessions via Zoom. You can purchase 1, 2, or 10 sessions for an additional fee.

To get started, you fill out the online contact form.

Then you’ll have a phone consultation with a professional matchmaker in your city. The initial interview lasts around 45 minutes, and you’ll talk about yourself and what you’re looking for in a match and a long-term relationship.

Three Day Rule does not accept everyone as clients, as they want to ensure they are able to properly service the clients that join.

If you are offered a membership and decide you want to join the dating service as a paying client, you’ll sign a 3- or 6-month contract.

Where Do Your Matches Come From?

You’ll be introduced to any free members in the database who meet your criteria, and contacts from your matchmaker’s personal network.

Three Day Rule matchmakers also recruit eligible singles at events, and will approach any intriguing people they come across while out and about to ask if they’d like to join the dating pool.

When your matchmaker identifies a potential match, she’ll meet with that person to ensure they’re a good fit.

You’ll then receive a picture and a bio. Because each match is thoughtfully chosen, this presentation counts as one of your “official” matches even if you decide you don’t want to meet that person.

If you accept the match, contact information is exchanged and it’s up to you to schedule the date. Your matchmaker will gather feedback on the quality of the match after the date, so they can use that feedback to hone in on your search parameters moving forward.

Three Day Rule Matchmaking Reviews From Real Customers

You won’t find many client reviews on mainstream review platforms like Trustpilot or Google.

Three Day Rule has a 4.3-star rating on Yelp, based on over 250 reviews. The majority are 4 & 5-star. Clients like these three reported a positive experience with their personal matchmaking service:

A few of the Three Day Rule Yelp reviews were 1 or 2-star. This client praised her matchmaker but ultimately wasn't happy with her experience:

Additionally, some users have taken to Reddit to post about their experience working with Three Day Rule. 

Several individuals mentioned being in their free database, with some people suggesting it’s a drawback: 

“I signed up on their database for free. I had a date with one of their clients a couple years ago. The date was fine but I think he was coached by his matchmaker to be very pushy in setting up the 2nd date and it completely turned me off.” 

While others felt it was standard in the industry and not a concern:

“Most matchmaking services let you add yourself to their database to be considered as a match for their clients. It’s not shady, and the clients don’t have access to the database. It’s a tool for the matchmakers.” 

Or this person:

“This is not bait. We are in the pool of candidates that their clients are looking for. The bigger the pool, the better the choices are for their clients.”

This individual shared that working with Three Day Rule caused their confidence to dwindle:

“I paid thousands and this company destroyed my confidence instead of building it up at a very sensitive time in my life. There’s nothing masterful about their matchmaking - they just hire whomever - and they don’t have access to anyone you can’t find yourself. The guys they had gone out with me had clearly been pressured into it and a couple bailed on me and TDR still tried to count those as matches.” 

However, many of these cannot be confirmed as legitimate clients without the company’s confirmation or response to their comments.

Three Day Rule has an B+ rating with the Better Business Bureau based on less than 20 reviews.

The service got predominately 4 or 5-star ratings with several people sharing that they had a good experience working with Three Day Rule like these: 

Of those who gave the service 1-star the comments were centered around match quality: 

This national matchmaking company has definitely gotten more positive press than negative, which likely means they’re doing something right.

All product and company names are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.